News:

If you need instructions on how to get through the hotels, check out the enclosed instruction book.

Main Menu

Bush administration sneaking in one last rule

Farted by FLOUNDERMAN_CLOCK, December 06, 2008, 12:07:29 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

RomanClock

Quote from: William. Shatner.;1463216Again, I will stress that doctors chose their own professions. If somebody is studying to become a doctor and finds out about a procedure in an area of specialized medicine(which they should know well ahead of time if medical schools are doing their jobs), they can choose to study a different area. Long story short, if a doctor has to perform a procedure that (s)he finds morally unacceptable, it's the doctor's own fault.
All of this bill's supporters seem to be overlooking the fact that not all doctors have to perform abortions or participate in any of the other procedures described, which all seem to be reproductively oriented. Besides, the only reasonable objection I can see any doctor having to any of those procedures is a refusal to look at living things as objects that can be broken down into a set of mechanisms and chemical reactions, which is essentially what medical science is. So is a doctor who is morally opposed to these procedures really fit to be a doctor, anyway?

If someone is kind enough to devote years of their life studying medicine to help people, they aren't going to do something that they don't want to do, and you shouldn't force them to. Doctors aren't slaves to the system like some people seem to think, doctors are generally caring people and will try to help the patient, otherwise they wouldn't have become a doctor! Saying "its their fault for becoming a doctor" is an idiotic reason to say doctors shouldn't be able to choose how they practice.
Slurpee said it pretty simply, this just protects them.
Also, its not all about reproduction, nor is it about any religion. It could be euthanasia, abortion, performing a risky surgery, prescribing harmful drugs, performing augmentative surgeries, etc.
You're just so closed minded, doctors aren't there to be slaves, they are there to help you, and if they think what you want to do is harmful, they aren't going to do it and you shouldn't force them either.
lemayo lol :soups:

mauserclock

wow, roman didnt even read it
thats pretty typical

Silly Putty Clock

Quote from: RomanClock;1463230If someone is kind enough to devote years of their life studying medicine to help people, they aren't going to do something that they don't want to do, and you shouldn't force them to. Doctors aren't slaves to the system like some people seem to think, doctors are generally caring people and will try to help the patient, otherwise they wouldn't have become a doctor! Saying "its their fault for becoming a doctor" is an idiotic reason to say doctors shouldn't be able to choose how they practice.
Slurpee said it pretty simply, this just protects them.
Also, its not all about reproduction, nor is it about any religion. It could be euthanasia, abortion, performing a risky surgery, prescribing harmful drugs, performing augmentative surgeries, etc.
You're just so closed minded, doctors aren't there to be slaves, they are there to help you, and if they think what you want to do is harmful, they aren't going to do it and you shouldn't force them either.

I'm not being closed-minded here, I'm just trying to be realistic. I rather like the idea of freedom. I think it's the most important and valuable thing in modern times. The problem with freedom, however, is that sometimes, it isn't as simple as you'd like it to be. I would want doctors to be able to decide what they're willing or unwilling to do for patients, but the fact of the matter is that some doctors would abuse it. I think it would be acceptable for doctors to be able to refer patients for moral reasons. Ideally, there should be freedom to back out of performing a procedure, but there should be some distinction between those that the doctor believes to be immoral for religious reasons and those that are immoral because they are unnecessary or harmful to the patient. Up until this point, I was just adressing those that were mentioned in the first post, which would be strictly religious matters (although, in the case of an abortion, it might not be, depending on how far along the baby is). I realize that I accused you and those who share your opinions of overlooking important details when I myself did the same thing. These issues just aren't black-and-white. I still don't think doctors should be able to refuse procedures on religious grounds. For instance, from what I understand, Jehova's Witnesses believe that blood transfusion is equivalent to cannibalism and therefore evil. I'm sure you will agree that this is an unreasonable additude, as the main thing that is wrong with cannibalism is that is requires people to be killed, not that the flesh of one person helps to sustain another.
Really, if one were to look at it in their way metaphorically enough, one could come to believe that the entire field of medicine is evil, since it depends on people sacrificing their time and energy to keep others healthy and save their lives.
8=======D~~~~>_<~~~~C=======8

RomanClock

Quote from: William. Shatner.;1463241I still don't think doctors should be able to refuse procedures on religious grounds. For instance, from what I understand, Jehova's Witnesses believe that blood transfusion is equivalent to cannibalism and therefore evil. I'm sure you will agree that this is an unreasonable additude, as the main thing that is wrong with cannibalism is that is requires people to be killed, not that the flesh of one person helps to sustain another.
Really, if one were to look at it in their way metaphorically enough, one could come to believe that the entire field of medicine is evil, since it depends on people sacrificing their time and energy to keep others healthy and save their lives.

For one, morals =/= religion, even still, the doctor should be able to decide what he himself will or will not do for the patient, and if the doctor doesn't want to to what the patient wants, the patent should find another doctor, and if the doctor is incompetent enough to ignore obvious patient needs, then he wouldn't be a doctor for long either. Second, if someone thought blood transfusion was evil (which I'm sure is a tiny number of people), they wouldn't be a doctor! And if they thought all medicine was evil, they'd never become a doctor anyway!

Edit: Thanks Mauser for being ignorant! You really contribute to this thread!
lemayo lol :soups:

Poltergeist

Quote from: Marlin Clock;1463143The doctor's job is to care for a patient.

Unless they no longer choose to.

Morals are loose, what if a doctor chooses not to help someone because he personally doesn't like them? Morally he can argue he can't save the life of an ass.

Silly Putty Clock

Quote from: Poltergeisty;1463260Unless they no longer choose to.

Morals are loose, what if a doctor chooses not to help someone because he personally doesn't like them? Morally he can argue he can't save the life of an ass.

I'm not sure if they could legitimately do that, but what if doctors start refusing to save people because they oppose their views? Personally, I don't consider conservatives to be evil, but not everybody feels the same way about people whose opinions are different from their own.

By thw way, Roman, part of what I was saying was that morals didn't equal religion.
Quote from: William. Shatner.I also find it extremely ironic that you call his exagerrated statement "propogandist bullshit" when you yourself used the term "moral fiber" when a term like "strong religious beliefs" would have been more fitting, strongly implying that those who follow conservative Christian religious beliefs are somehow morally superior to others.
You seem to have a short memory.

My point was that, depending on one's religious views, one could consider different things to be immoral. For instance, artificial insemination and birth control. I see no non-religious reason to be opposed to those, but there are many people who are. I will never understand why, but there are people who are so caught up in religious indoctrination that they believe that it's a bad thing to allow people to have sex without the risk of unwanted pregnancy or even to create life through an artificial process. Of course, the former is not quite as unreasonable as the latter, and I know that many people, especially in the States, are opposed to birth control, but I personally think it's a silly and misguided belief. From my understanding, the whole "no sex without babies" thing is based on a really weird interpretation of two little sections in a book. I don't know exactly what it says though, and I'm curious about it, so I'd actually like it if somepody here who knows what the passages are to post them here for analysis.

I'd also like to add that I realize operations like vasectomies are risky and that the risk can be a significant factor in deciding whether it's the right thing to do.
8=======D~~~~>_<~~~~C=======8

Silly Putty Clock

Quote from: CadillacClock;1463412I am so glad I did not read this thread.

Roman ruined it. He just won't stop begging the question.
8=======D~~~~>_<~~~~C=======8

Silly Putty Clock

Quote from: CadillacClock;1463428I'm sure Marlin ruined it too.

I don't know. At least it was fun while he was posting. The thing is, this has become a debate about religion's impact on morality. If I understand correctly, Roman's been saying that religion has absolutely no effect on what a doctor considers to be right or wrong and therefore should be completely overlooked in deciding whether this bill should be passed or not. He's stalling the debate. Marlin was just saying that doctors abusing their freedoms would have no effect on the price of certain procedures, which to me seems to defy the most basic fundamentals of economics.
8=======D~~~~>_<~~~~C=======8

Marlin Clock

I seem to understand that you know nothing of church dogma if you find sex for pleasure fine. The act of non-conceptual sex is being selfish. It's saying your self-pleasure is more important, which it should never be.

Also, this states denial of doing procedures, not denial of treating patients.

Silly Putty Clock

Quote from: Marlin Clock;1463440I seem to understand that you know nothing of church dogma if you find sex for pleasure fine. The act of non-conceptual sex is being selfish. It's saying your self-pleasure is more important, which it should never be.

Also, this states denial of doing procedures, not denial of treating patients.

Who's narrow-minded now? Sex is a basic biological impuse. That's like saying that eating without having the runs something terrible is selfish. I do realize that there's a difference between diarrhea and a kid, but I'm adjusting the consequences here to suit eating, which is absolutely essential for life. And what about teen pregnancies? These are often cases when the parents might not have the time or the means to look after a baby, and most likely have no desire to do so. And don't give me that bullshit about how it's as easy as abstaining. Sex is extremely difficult to resist, and that's if you're not seeking it, as I think you'll agree most people who have sex do. You know what your  problem is, Marlin? You're too self-righteous.

Also, I know Church dogma. I was a pretty devout Anglican up until I reached the age of reason, which was twelve or thirteen in my case. My descent into atheism was a slow and gradual one, marked by despair, so I can't really tell exactly when I started to doubt my religion. All I know is that for the longest time I blindly accepted whatever the church said as right.
I know Church dogma. I just entertain the idea that it might be wrong. Don't you ever accuse me of ignorance based on my beliefs. I am ENLIGHTENED. One day, if all goes badly, you might be too.
8=======D~~~~>_<~~~~C=======8

zl

Gotta side with Marlin here.  I think it is better for a doctor to follow his own morals than those of a bigger institution.

I can't see how forcing a doctor to perform an abortion he considers to be murder could at all be acceptable in a free society.

Marlin Clock

Quote from: CadillacClock;1463466“Judge not, that you be not judged. For with the judgment you pronounce you will be judged, and with the measure you use it will be measured to you. Why do you see the speck that is in your brother's eye, but do not notice the log that is in your own eye? Or how can you say to your brother, ‘Let me take the speck out of your eye,’ when there is the log in your own eye? You hypocrite, first take the log out of your own eye, and then you will see clearly to take the speck out of your brother's eye. (matthew 7:1-5)

To judge another spiteful is to do so with arrogance and in sin. You are not God and cannot take his position in casting harsh judgment. Live and let live, Marlin. Christ did not hate the nonbelievers.
Oh come off it, caddy. Am I condemning anyone? Have I gone to any singular person and said; "You are an evil sinner."?

So anyway, opposing contraception lines perfectly with that. Condemn the sin, not the sinner.

Marlin Clock

Quote from: William. Shatner.;1463461Who's narrow-minded now? Sex is a basic biological impuse.
It's a basic biological impulse because it is for the creation of offspring, which is why contraception goes in clear opposition to it.
QuoteThat's like saying that eating without having the runs something terrible is selfish. I do realize that there's a difference between diarrhea and a kid, but I'm adjusting the consequences here to suit eating, which is absolutely essential for life. And what about teen pregnancies? These are often cases when the parents might not have the time or the means to look after a baby, and most likely have no desire to do so. And don't give me that bullshit about how it's as easy as abstaining. Sex is extremely difficult to resist, and that's if you're not seeking it, as I think you'll agree most people who have sex do. You know what your problem is, Marlin? You're too self-righteous.
Adoption ring a bell? And when have I ever said abstinence is easy?

QuoteAlso, I know Church dogma. I was a pretty devout Anglican up until I reached the age of reason, which was twelve or thirteen in my case. My descent into atheism was a slow and gradual one, marked by despair, so I can't really tell exactly when I started to doubt my religion. All I know is that for the longest time I blindly accepted whatever the church said as right.
I know Church dogma. I just entertain the idea that it might be wrong. Don't you ever accuse me of ignorance based on my beliefs. I am ENLIGHTENED. One day, if all goes badly, you might be too.
I blindly follow nothing. I believe in my heart, fully and freely, the rights and wrongs I have come to accept as truths.

Exclamation Mark

Quote from: Marlin Clock;1463470Oh come off it, caddy. Am I condemning anyone? Have I gone to any singular person and said; "You are an evil sinner."?

So anyway, opposing contraception lines perfectly with that. Condemn the sin, not the sinner.

Quote from: Marlin Clock;1463099This isn't about doctors choosing their patients you overly aggressive sociopath, g another person, for any reason.

Think before you speak asshole.


HMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM
Quote from: Crucifix;1556967I now have a 14 year old girl hitting on me. If I had proof she wasn\'t a 50 year old man I\'d be masturbating right about now :>

AMPEEEM

Quote from: Marlin Clock;1463075They weren't allowed to do that before? You must be against free will if you think that's a bad thing. What's the use of the Hippocratic Oath if a doctor is forced to work against their morals?

Because he may have incorrect judgment. Take for example, my birth. When I was born, my parents wanted to give me water but my Doctor told my parents that they should only breast feed me, because I needed to get used to it. Because of this, I became dehydrated, nearly killing me.

QuoteIf a doctor believes an unborn child is a person, then performing an abortion would go completely against harming another person, for any reason.
That would make the Doctor selfish who is not respecting another person's view.

Yes, in the end though, whether or not a doctor is Christian, its not right to make him do something that he does believe is murder, even though that makes no sense to me, but it is wrong for a doctor to not commit this act if the person who wants an abortion has been around town and no one will do it. Thats just putting a horrible strain on this person who has her own beliefs and a doctor should respect that, no matter what he thinks is right.

zl

Quote from: CadillacClock;1463477Although, there are often complications where an abortion could save the mothers life. In which case, the choice must be made as to whether the woman or the child will die. Doctors have to deal with death on a regular basis and some very serious choices must be made. The choices should always reflect the benefit of the patient, not the doctor('s morality) in question.

Quote from: CadillacClock;1463487Do you know why this debate is stupid? Because it's based on moral opinions. Morals vary from person to person. A doctor, a good doctor, should only act for the benefit of the patient. To assume that they would put there own morality above the patients choice and will being is absurd and dangerous. That is the absurdity of this law.

I would not wish for Roman or Marlin as my Doctors.

So you are basically saying, the patient's morality should trump the doctor's. That has some reason to it...the patient is the one paying the bill.

But I'd like the doctor profession to not be one that forces you to abandon or disregard your morality.  I think forcing someone to betray themselves in that way is an unhealthy way to run any institution.

Are these things so contradictory?

I imagine, in a save-the-child-or-the-mother scenario, it would be best to learn the mother's opinion beforehand - if it comes to that choice, what would she choose?  Then pair her up with a doctor who will support that choice.  It means some extra work, in setting up appointments and some more questions when hiring doctors...I think that's fair.

WreckingBallClock

Hey I've got an idea. Since the debate is based on morals, how about we let the morals of doctors decide whether we should accept if we should allow morals to play a role in whether or not doctors can deny a patient due to the doctor's own morals?

I think it's a pretty sweet idea.

zl

Quote from: CadillacClock;1463510Not really what I was getting at. Patients always have the choice to refuse treatment. Patients often die because they refuse treatment. A patients opinion in matters involving there own body is always up to them.

It is the doctors own morality that bothers me. A doctor should never refuse to commit an action if it saves the persons life. Regardless of their religious or philosophical beliefs on the matter.

And I think a doctor should have that right to refuse.  I think this will make them less valuable to hospitals that want doctors who will perform certain operations - so that refusing doctor will have a harder time finding work, may have to set up his own clinic.  Makes sense to me.

poopbutt

Quote from: Sean Connery;1479838Horsemen, whore like your mother and semen

AbsintheClock

I actually agree with this. If a doctor finds something morally objectionable they shouldn't have to participate in it. All the same I think people have a right to take their business elsewhere. Although I think it would be fair to the patient to allow a doctor to know what they find morally objectionable in the first place instead of pulling a "surprise" treatment on them. This should also allow people who already have these cemented beliefs to connect with doctors who share their beliefs. It all seems perfectly logical to me.