News:

If you need instructions on how to get through the hotels, check out the enclosed instruction book.

Main Menu

The Repression of Social Evolution By Existing Authorities

Farted by AlbinoClock, February 27, 2009, 03:03:01 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

AlbinoClock

When the decisions of our policy makers are in direct opposition to the every day activities of the populace, it is always a losing battle for the policy makers and generally a huge waste of money.

File sharing is a perfect example. People have decided that they'd like information to be free, and following this line of thought have created infrastructures for doing this. These infrastructures have repeatedly been rendered unsustainable and replaced with new infrastructures. First we had ftp servers, then napster and the other early p2p services, now we have torrents. Before all that we had cassettes and VHS. My early memories include getting around primitive DRM (lol game manual questions and anti-piracy indexes that "couldn't be photocopied",)*. At every step of technology we've done whatever we could to give our friends copies. This is a natural and healthy instinct to share, and should be fostered, not restricted. We want free information, and physics says we get to have it. It's not our fault that the law is in conflict with physics.

Another example is the marijuana industry. There is an infrastructure in place to deliver a desired product to its end users despite all attempts to dismantle it. Every time someone gets taken down, someone else steps into their place, not because it's organized but because people want it. If enough people want something, they're going to have it. There's nothing to be done about it, other than making it safer for everyone and allowing the activity to function as a normal contribution to society.

How is this not apparent to policy-makers? If they are that out of touch with our societies, what the hell are we doing allowing them to make our policies for us?



*i guess that's just RM

AstronautClock


AlbinoClock


RomanClock

Well for one, just because people want it doesn't make it a good thing, nor does it justify crime, or that its moral. So basically your whole argument is based on your opinion of what you think other people want. If that many people wanted weed, it would be legal but its not. And selling and buying information is a huge industry, there's no way all information can be free. Why do you think we pay for college? Teachers? Job experience? That's all forms of information and all of it has a price attached to it, and depending on what kind of information you know some people will pay more for it than others.

I would agree though, that the government usually messes things up.
lemayo lol :soups:

AlbinoClock

Quote from: RomanClock;1530200Well for one, just because people want it doesn't make it a good thing, nor does it justify crime, or that its moral. So basically your whole argument is based on your opinion of what you think other people want. If that many people wanted weed, it would be legal but its not. And selling and buying information is a huge industry, there's no way all information can be free. Why do you think we pay for college? Teachers? Job experience? That's all forms of information and all of it has a price attached to it, and depending on what kind of information you know some people will pay more for it than others.

It's not a matter of whether it's a good thing, it exists. Despite years of drug wars, it is thriving. Marijuana is a 300 billion+ dollar industry and there isn't a damn thing anyone can do about it. Now you can throw a fit about that and start tossing people in jail, or you can be realistic and make the best of the situation.

It's the same with file sharing. Open exchange of information has caught on and is supported sufficiently to exist despite the best efforts of its opponents.  It's a question of what you're going to do with it, not whether you can stop it. You can't stop it. It's here.

This inflexibility is a sign of immature, unfit leadership, and it requires correction.

As far as schools go, you don't pay teachers for information, you pay them to be an expert. You pay book stores and publishers for information, which your teacher guides you through and offers advice on. This is not a service that can be mass produced, unlike the books themselves. Services will always carry value, it's the way that copied works are distributed that is in dispute.

RomanClock

Quote from: AlbinoClock;1530202300 billion+ dollar industry
Is this for just America or the world, per month, year, decade? And whats the source?

Quote from: AlbinoClock;1530202This inflexibility is a sign of immature, unfit leadership, and it requires correction.
I really don't like taxes, and I bet 99% of America doesn't like them, I guess congress just doesn't understand America because they haven't gotten rid of taxes. They are just so immature and unfit for leadership. Perhaps if we got rid of taxes, we wouldn't have any tax fraud!
(Well, they are incompetent, but for different reasons)

Quote from: AlbinoClock;1530202As far as schools go, you don't pay teachers for information, you pay them to be an expert. You pay book stores and publishers for information, which your teacher guides you through and offers advice on. This is not a service that can be mass produced, unlike the books themselves. Services will always carry value, it's the way that copied works are distributed that is in dispute.
They are an expert because they know it. Anyone can read a book and tell you whats in it, but a teacher has to actually know the subject, not just a book, because books only cover whats in them, and can't give you anything more than whats in them. You have to ask the teacher a question to get an answer, not the book. The book can only explain it one way.
lemayo lol :soups:

AlbinoClock

Quote from: RomanClock;1530217Is this for just America or the world, per month, year, decade? And whats the source?

I thought it was Marijuana INC, but looking back they say tens of billions or more per year. So I could well be off on that figure of 300 billion, but it's still gigantic and legalization could only increase its size.


QuoteI really don't like taxes, and I bet 99% of America doesn't like them, I guess congress just doesn't understand America because they haven't gotten rid of taxes. They are just so immature and unfit for leadership. Perhaps if we got rid of taxes, we wouldn't have any tax fraud!
(Well, they are incompetent, but for different reasons)

You don't like taxes at all? That's surprising. See, I like a few taxes on myself and many taxes on those richer than me. This allows for services for myself and the rest of the people who live in the area being taxed. Services are good because they make it more feasible to have a working business and thus feed the local economy. Maybe if those who could afford it were taxed a little more heavily the education system would be decent enough to create adults who understand what taxes are for.

The actuality of the situation seems to show that people will tolerate paying taxes, since they can't get jobs otherwise and businesses that stop paying them are closed down by the government. There has been no large, flexible, self-regenerating infrastructure to fight taxation. On the other hand, the marijuana industry as well as the file-sharing infrastructure are self-regenerating and flexible and fucking gigantic.

Despite years of arrests, the pot flows. Despite years of lawsuits, piracy is easy and wide-spread. Fighting against these things doesn't help, which is why it's immature to treat them in the way we do. We're punishing our society for evolving, instead of trying to adapt our policies to an evolving society.

QuoteThey are an expert because they know it. Anyone can read a book and tell you whats in it, but a teacher has to actually know the subject, not just a book, because books only cover whats in them, and can't give you anything more than whats in them. You have to ask the teacher a question to get an answer, not the book. The book can only explain it one way.

Exactly, and that's why they can't be replaced by file sharing. On the other hand, the enormous quantity of freely available resources on the internet can be used to obtain all the information in any given text book and far more.

Maltese

Quote from: AlbinoClock;1530237I thought it was Marijuana INC, but looking back they say tens of billions or more per year. So I could well be off on that figure of 300 billion, but it's still gigantic and legalization could only increase its size.

You don't like taxes at all? That's surprising. See, I like a few taxes on myself and many taxes on those richer than me. This allows for services for myself and the rest of the people who live in the area being taxed. Services are good because they make it more feasible to have a working business and thus feed the local economy. Maybe if those who could afford it were taxed a little more heavily the education system would be decent enough to create adults who understand what taxes are for.

Exactly, and that's why they can't be replaced by file sharing. On the other hand, the enormous quantity of freely available resources on the internet can be used to obtain all the information in any given text book and far more.

amazing post.

CrustClock

...so much blithely one-sided, unoriginal bullshit. 'The populace', in your usage, only means people sympathetic to your arguments. Straight away you tell me that you don't give a shit about even considering shades of grey. Even if the majority of  people would rather, knowing there will be no consequences, steal music than buy it (surprise fucking surprise), how does that justify it? Mass defiance of a person (the musician's) rights is a selfish activity, not an expression of ideals. The majority of people dismiss environmental issues, and it's because of the same safety-in-mass-selfishness which protects pirates from the feelings of guilt theft from a record store would bring. Such mass-selfishness and reliance on convenience is the kind of attitude which law-makers should fight against, not keel down to. Your idea of what 'the populace has decided' is a greatly depressing portrait of the human race.

As for your second paragraph, I could try to formulate a response... but what would be the point? You could talk till the cows come home about marijuana, but I've already read what you've had to say a million times over. You're boring.

AlbinoClock

Quote from: CrustClock;1530314...so much blithely one-sided, unoriginal bullshit. 'The populace', in your usage, only means people sympathetic to your arguments. Straight away you tell me that you don't give a shit about even considering shades of grey. Even if the majority of  people would rather, knowing there will be no consequences, steal music than buy it (surprise fucking surprise), how does that justify it? Mass defiance of a person (the musician's) rights is a selfish activity, not an expression of ideals.

It's not a matter of some abstract "the people" wanting it, it's a matter of very specific individuals wanting it and others being willing to facilitate it. I don't see why everyone keeps looking over this bit, but I'll say it again, it doesn't matter whether or not it is positive or negative, it exists and can't be effectively prevented. Funds spent to prevent things that can't be prevented are wasted funds that lead to wasted time. Taking a more realistic approach to the situation is not only more likely to actually result in some success, but is less wasteful.


QuoteThe majority of people dismiss environmental issues, and it's because of the same safety-in-mass-selfishness which protects pirates from the feelings of guilt theft from a record store would bring. Such mass-selfishness and reliance on convenience is the kind of attitude which law-makers should fight against, not keel down to. Your idea of what 'the populace has decided' is a greatly depressing portrait of the human race.

Luckily the government has the ability to regulate legitimate industries that contribute to pollution, such as the automotive industry. If cars were illegal, the government would not possess this power. By making a given thing illegal, the government loses any say in how business will be conducted in regard to whatever that thing is. By making a product illegal, the government relinquishes any control over its distribution. At least, this is the case when they attempt to prohibit something that's readily available.

RomanClock

Quote from: CrustClock;1530314...so much blithely one-sided, unoriginal bullshit. 'The populace', in your usage, only means people sympathetic to your arguments. Straight away you tell me that you don't give a shit about even considering shades of grey. Even if the majority of  people would rather, knowing there will be no consequences, steal music than buy it (surprise fucking surprise), how does that justify it? Mass defiance of a person (the musician's) rights is a selfish activity, not an expression of ideals. The majority of people dismiss environmental issues, and it's because of the same safety-in-mass-selfishness which protects pirates from the feelings of guilt theft from a record store would bring. Such mass-selfishness and reliance on convenience is the kind of attitude which law-makers should fight against, not keel down to. Your idea of what 'the populace has decided' is a greatly depressing portrait of the human race.

As for your second paragraph, I could try to formulate a response... but what would be the point? You could talk till the cows come home about marijuana, but I've already read what you've had to say a million times over. You're boring.

I am surprised that I mostly agree with Crust.
lemayo lol :soups:

Maltese

Quote from: RomanClock;1530472I am surprised that I mostly agree with Crust.

crust, this is a sign that you are wrong.

RomanClock

Quote from: Maltese;1530473crust, this is a sign that you are wrong.
No, it means that dissimilar ideals can have intersecting principles.
lemayo lol :soups:

Maltese

Quote from: RomanClock;1530476No, it means that dissimilar ideals can have intersecting principles.

and those principles are wrong.

thanks for helping me make my point

BunnyClock

I wonder how big a percentage of americans want weed legalized

Maltese

Quote from: BunnyClock;1530618I wonder how big a percentage of americans want weed legalized

last figure I heard was 23 percent, but that's probably wrong

BunnyClock

Quote from: Maltese;1530625last figure I heard was 23 percent, but that's probably wrong

pft I'm guessing 8% at max

Maltese

Quote from: BunnyClock;1530631pft I'm guessing 8% at max

that's why I thought it sounded wrong

CrustClock

Quote from: Maltese;1530238amazing post.
Quote from: Maltese;1530473crust, this is a sign that you are wrong.
Quote from: Maltese;1530614and those principles are wrong.

thanks for helping me make my point

is this all you do? It's the most pathetically evasive debate style I've ever encountered.

Maltese

Quote from: CrustClock;1530663is this all you do? It's the most pathetically evasive debate style I've ever encountered.

this isn't debating, this is just insulting roman because I can.