News:

If you need instructions on how to get through the hotels, check out the enclosed instruction book.

Main Menu

cc help me out 2.0

Farted by SirClock, September 25, 2009, 09:34:42 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

SirClock

I finally finished my website, I could use a couple of testimonials.

http://www.creatustoons.com

It is very small, and not very fancy, but I just need it to be presentable and simple. On my browser for some reason it fucks up the alignment of flash with background, and I honestly think it may be only me... somehow.

SirClock

Quote from: weenie roast;1671957I would recommend using javascript to embed flash. I'd also recommend using div (or span) tags when having that hover effect with image links.

other than that it's good :D

edit : however, if you want my entire testimony on what you could improve, feel free to IM me on AIM : organeyze. it's good as it is now, but you COULD make it better with a few changes.
Oh yeah. I'm totally aware of the fact that my coding is probably just scraping by, I'm terrible at it. This is ok as long as it works and looks nice

F U Clock

Nah, the bands don't align in my browser either. Weird... Is it padded at the top at all, or set to margin-top 0 for everything?

Looks cool though. I really dig your mouseover previews for the subsections.

Loki Clock

1. You made a flash website, so you can't search it, nor can you use it with accessibility options.
2. You have an intro, which means every time you load the site you have to wait an extra 5 seconds or so to get past something entirely ornamental to the actual functional site, including every time you go to a page and then go back to the index. If you insist on keeping the intro, either redirect to the real menu after the intro ends so that you have a real destination corresponding to the real homepage, or have some flag that is either set perceptibly in the URL or is set after the first viewing of the intro.
3. You have sound. This hinders aural accessibility (that is hearing things actually functional). This is also really annoying if you already have something playing. You have a slightly more sophisticated version of the 1999 anime midi background loop that doesn't turn off unless you leave the site.
4. You have no way of turning the sound off. If anything, sound should only come on if manually switched on.
5. Most of the site consists of purely ornamental graphics and animations. Rollovers and wingdings, a massive waste of time, space, and processor expenditure. This is a slightly more sophisticated version of the 1999 gratuitous gif splatter.
6. Some pages open in a new window, some don't. Pages should never open in a new window by default, and this option should be left to the user's judgement. In most browsers, it's easier to specify to open in a new window than it is to specify to open in the existing one, but the user doesn't have that choice to begin with because you made it an exclusively flash website. If anything, it should be consistent. Either make all links open in the existing window (please this) or make them all open in a new window. No random mix-and-matching, and please add some actionscript to add an "open in [other target]" option to the links.
7. Not nearly everyone uses a goddamn mail client. Make your e-mail address a text box that people can select the contents of, and if you like, have a mail client button next to that.

DigitalLemonClock

BAN EVERYBODY

DWARFINATORclock


F U Clock

Quote from: ᛚᚮᚴᛁ᛫ᚴᛚᚢᚴᚴᛆ;16720371. You made a flash website, so you can't search it, nor can you use it with accessibility options.
2. You have an intro, which means every time you load the site you have to wait an extra 5 seconds or so to get past something entirely ornamental to the actual functional site, including every time you go to a page and then go back to the index. If you insist on keeping the intro, either redirect to the real menu after the intro ends so that you have a real destination corresponding to the real homepage, or have some flag that is either set perceptibly in the URL or is set after the first viewing of the intro.
3. You have sound. This hinders aural accessibility (that is hearing things actually functional). This is also really annoying if you already have something playing. You have a slightly more sophisticated version of the 1999 anime midi background loop that doesn't turn off unless you leave the site.
4. You have no way of turning the sound off. If anything, sound should only come on if manually switched on.
5. Most of the site consists of purely ornamental graphics and animations. Rollovers and wingdings, a massive waste of time, space, and processor expenditure. This is a slightly more sophisticated version of the 1999 gratuitous gif splatter.

Welcome to what an artist's website looks like. He's not making a website for an insurance company or something, he's flexing his creative muscles.

paperbag man

Quote from: CadillacClock;1672117And if the site is to be in anyway used as a visual portfolio to his work it should be as easily accessible as possible. There have been many artistic and functionable websites out there.
 
I think Loki had some very valid points. And, I really agree with the point about the sound. Sound, on any website, is simply a nuisance. I wouldn't bother browsing one that had a continious loop.
just as an example check out www.grimcrow.com its not mine im just a fan of his and thought i should throw in an example for sirclock
i am a newb of newbs
 

F U Clock

Quote from: paperbag man;1672120just as an example check out www.grimcrow.com its not mine im just a fan of his and thought i should throw in an example for sirclock

That loads about a hojillion times slower than SirClock's.

Should there be music on Sir's page? Prolly not. But no sound at all? What about mouseovers? Complaining that he made a Flash page, with an intro, with "ornamental" graphics is just silly. Look at some of the sites on the FWA. http://www.thefwa.com/

AdrenalineClock

There's nothing wrong with an artist using his art talents to make his art website a piece of art in itself.

What would people be searching for anyway?  It's all right there.

SirClock

Yeah, when I said I just wanted enough to scrape by, I wasn't joking. Again, I'm not a good coder, I'm a shitty coder. But besides that, thats perfectly ok, because the people I'm going to show the portfolio to aren't going to expect me to be anything but a shitty coder.

The site is based on design principals, not "golden code" principals. With that said, no Loki, I'm not about to completely re-design my site just because its against the "golden rules" to have a flash site in the first place (PS: I looked at your own site and loled). Rules like that are actually totally counter-productive to what I should be doing anyways, considering I'm only focused on demonstrating my graphic capabilities. I made a non-flash version to stop that bickering anyways.

Quote from: CadillacClock;1672130I would remove the tacky changing fonts in displaying your animations. It looks amateur, incredibly so. Pick a style and stick with it.I would also suggest adding onto (changing the style of) that page with, well, anything and everything. At the moment, it's just a few random fonts with pictures to your flash. You can do better than that.
No I can't. You must not have seen my last version >_>
Also, I don't agree that different fonts is amateur. I'm clearly trying to give each cartoons title its own unique style. Probably too over-emphasized But I don't think its an eye-sore, just kinda cheesy

Quote from: CadillacClock;1672130That violin loop serves no purpose but to annoy. Get rid of it. I hate loading a website with some awful unnecessary music.
I find music very necessary in adding to the feel of a website. Makes it less boring too. The violin isn't a loop, its quite short. But I definitely do need to add in a mute button.
Quote from: CadillacClock;1672130The photoshop universe background over a city backdrop is pretty amateur and uncreative. I certainly wasn't impressed by it. Again, you can do it better and I suggest you do.
Here I completely disagree. There is nothing amateur about that backdrop, I put alot of effort into making it continuously changing, different every time and colorful. Thats not just one PS background.
Quote from: CadillacClock;1672130Nobody wants to hear DING DING DING as they scroll through the selections.
That kind of thing never bothers me, and I don't see it as a problem. Your the second person to mention it to me, if I get more complaints I guess I'll do something

SirClock

Quote from: CadillacClock;1672164so, if you just wanted what you had, why did you ask for opinions?
Opinions are fine. What you gave me were opinions. Good. What Loki gave me was a massive irrelevant list of shit most I'm never going to even consider. (His site would get an A+ from such a list, but to me looks like garbage).

Quote from: Eff Yoo Clawk;1671965Nah, the bands don't align in my browser either. Weird... Is it padded at the top at all, or set to margin-top 0 for everything?

Looks cool though. I really dig your mouseover previews for the subsections.
This is my primary concern as of now. The bands were always fine for me until the last time I updated the flash file (not touching dimensions, or the html at all) and thats what did it. Somehow. It doesn't make sense that that could mess up anything, but none of this stuff ever seems to make any sense to me. If someone could give me a pointer how to tidy up the 'background-flash-object alignment' please let me know.

F U Clock

QuoteI don't want to make an argument out of this but who said he couldn't add mousovers? How about just getting rid of that  awful violin loop? Mousovers are fine but (to, Sir) don't go overboard with them. Nobody wants to hear DING DING DING as they scroll through the selections.

I don't want to get an argument either, but you said, "I really agree with the point about the sound. Sound, on any website, is simply a nuisance." If you had said "music," I might have responded differently.

I just hate this programmer's backlash against fancy Flash websites. For an artist or designer, their website should be a piece of art in itself. Therefore, I don't see a problem with the site being comprised of a lot of "ornamental graphics and animations."

EDIT: Sir, see if in the HTML you can either pad the background img a few pixels so it matches (margin-top:5px; or something) or wrap a div around the Flash (which it should already have) and make sure it has no margin at the top.

SirClock

Quote from: Eff Yoo Clawk;1672186I don't want to get an argument either, but you said, "I really agree with the point about the sound. Sound, on any website, is simply a nuisance." If you had said "music," I might have responded differently.

I just hate this programmer's backlash against fancy Flash websites. For an artist or designer, their website should be a piece of art in itself. Therefore, I don't see a problem with the site being comprised of a lot of "ornamental graphics and animations."
Indeed, I'm trying to land me a job as an animator, not a programmer. (And they don't check for programming skills for animators, even when applying at pixar). I certainly can't have any glitchiness on the site tho

I think it actually may have been a simple fix (for once) for those bars they are aligned for me now. Let me know if there's any other bugs (bugs are the primary concern)

NintendrCkolc

The bands are also a bit screwed up on my end. The only thing I have to complain about is that your art gallery and animation gallery open up a new tab or window... Try to keep it all in the same window if possible.

Other then that nice job.

F U Clock

Quote from: SirClock;1672192Indeed, I'm trying to land me a job as an animator, not a programmer. (And they don't check for programming skills for animators, even when applying at pixar).

I think it actually may have been a simple fix (for once) for those bars they are aligned for me now.

Reupload so the CC can see ya' dude.

SirClock

Quote from: Eff Yoo Clawk;1672194Reupload so the CC can see ya' dude.
Should be up now
Quote from: The Big N;1672193Try to keep it all in the same window if possible.
Yea, I'll have to change that

Loki Clock

#17
Quote from: Eff Yoo Clawk;1672186I just hate this programmer's backlash against fancy Flash websites. For an artist or designer, their website should be a piece of art in itself. Therefore, I don't see a problem with the site being comprised of a lot of "ornamental graphics and animations."

I have the same philosophy on all art forms, which is the law of parsimony. Also, Sir, you seem to be under the impression that web design as an art form is merely an extension of other kinds of visual art and is not an art form in and of it's self. A painting does not make a good car any more than it makes a good website.

Quote from: Eff Yoo Clawk;1672116He's not making a website for an insurance company or something, he's flexing his creative muscles.

This is statefarm's website: http://www.statefarm.com/

It's awful. You know what these two sites have in common? Bad taste. They're gaudy.

Finally, believe it or not, I put a lot of time and thought into my current website's design. I've been doing this a decade, now, and even if you laugh at my work, know that everything about that website is a decision, not a personal limitation.

SirClock

Quote from: ᛚᚮᚴᛁ᛫ᚴᛚᚢᚴᚴᛆ;1672953I have the same philosophy on all art forms, which is the law of parcimony. Also, Sir, you seem to be under the impression that web design as an art form is merely an extension of other kinds of visual art and is not an art form in and of it's self. A painting does not make a good car any more than it makes a good website
Yes, it is an extension of other arts. Its also an art form in itself. And the point is a good painting is still a good painting. I want to show off the fact I'm a good artist, not a "perfect" web-designer.

I havn't built my site with any of the goals in mind that your site has. I don't want my site to look or feel or appear like yours, ever, ever, ever. I wanted something original, and pretty. Not something I could run on a floppy-disk drive, thanks.

I think thats what FU was trying to explain.

Really this thread was intended to have others browse the site and check for bugs. Not correct me on my entire philosophy of design.

AmberArachnidClock

Well you asked for some testimonials and you got some testimonials.

Websites evoke just as much of an impression on the viewers as the artwork itself, if not sometimes more so. Don't use "Bad Programmer" as an excuse, it's very possible to make a nice looking portfolio site with limited programming knowledge. Right now it just looks a little unprofessional, and paying attention to some of the critiques in this thread would go a long way to a better looking and more impressionable website.

And Loki's really isn't that bad. It's very easy to navigate and loads fast. It just isn't very visual.