News:

If you need instructions on how to get through the hotels, check out the enclosed instruction book.

Main Menu

Changing my resolution does not change my frame rate in games.

Farted by SoBe Clock, October 08, 2009, 11:21:24 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

SoBe Clock

As much as I know about computers, this baffles me. I need to know if anyone can help me figure out how to solve this problem.

Here are my specs:

Notebook series and model: ASUS W90VP-X2 (Although all W90 series notebooks use the same drivers and extremely similar hardware so I imagine a way to fix this on one would work on all of them)
CPU: Intel Core 2 Quad Q9000 CPU @ 2.3GHz (Overclocked)
CPU L2 Cache: 6MB
RAM: 6 GB DDR3
Screen: 18.4" WUXGA
Max Resolution: 1920 x 1080  (60Hz)
Hard Disk: 320GB - 7200 RPM
Optical Drive: DVD Super Multi
Graphics Card: ATI Mobility Radeon HD 4870 X2
Video Memory: 1 GB GDDR5
Operating System: Windows Vista Home Premium 64-bit

Now I've tried several games on the following resolutions.
1920x1080 (16:9)
1680x1050 (16:10)
1400x1050 (4:3)
1280x1024 (4:3)
1280x720 (16:9)

My video card can preserve aspect ratios to keep any resolution looking correct on the screen without stretching it tall or wide.

I've benchmarked several games at these resolutions, with and without "preserve aspect ratio" on. The FPS only got like 3 or 4 frames better between 1920x1080 and 1280x720, and I think that was just due to coincidence. This isn't a problem for me right now as I can even play games like Crysis, Red Faction Guerrilla, GTA IV, and other ridiculously stressful games on high/max at 1920x1080 and still get smooth frame rate and game play. What I'm worried about is future games that maybe I couldn't handle on max quality at max resolution. I figured if I just lowered the resolution a bit, games would run a lot better without having to sacrifice the quality of the graphics. After all, that's how just about every computer ever works. Unfortunately, my games run the same at any resolution, and I'd rather have the performance improve at lower resolutions. Does anyone know what could be causing this strange situation and if there's something I can tweak to get it working like every other computer I've used?

Oh and I've already looked throughout the display settings and the Catalyst Control Center and unless there's something I'm missing I don't see something to change that would affect this.

Odo

╔══════════════ ೋáÆ'¦â˜Æ'áÆ'¦à³‹ ══════════════â•â€"
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ Repost this if ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ you are a beautiful strong black woman ~ ~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ who donââ,¬â,,¢t need no man ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
╚══════════════ ೋáÆ'¦â˜Æ'áÆ'¦à³‹ ══════════════╝


SoBe Clock

Quote from: Liser;1678245this is going to sound silly but


vsync?

Turning Vsync on or off didn't make much of a difference at all, but I think I only tested it at the highest and lowest of those resolutions.

I'll go back and test it at multiple resolutions in case I didn't, but I don't expect that's the problem. I almost never use it.

Odo

well vsync just caps your fps at your screens refresh rate, so turn it off on all settings, it doesn't help anyway
╔══════════════ ೋáÆ'¦â˜Æ'áÆ'¦à³‹ ══════════════â•â€"
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ Repost this if ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ you are a beautiful strong black woman ~ ~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ who donââ,¬â,,¢t need no man ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
╚══════════════ ೋáÆ'¦â˜Æ'áÆ'¦à³‹ ══════════════╝


SoBe Clock

Quote from: Liser;1678262well vsync just caps your fps at your screens refresh rate, so turn it off on all settings, it doesn't help anyway

Yeah, I know what it does. I tried it just in case.
Turning Vsync on didn't seem to make a difference except for a few FPS, and the FPS was still almost the same at all resolutions.

Vsync can also be used to fix the issue where your cursor in the game has a delay and moves after you move your mouse instead of the same time. (Also works to fix delayed keystroke response) Fortunately I do not have that problem on my computer, so I'm leaving it off.


Any other ideas anyone?

The Spoiler

Maybe you're CPU-limited? I don't know if popular benchmarks tell you whether you're CPU or GPU-limited, but it's worth a shot.

If these games offer settings for typical CPU bottlenecks (physics complexity, AI complexity,etc), give that a try too.

P.S I don't have a clue about which ATI cards are good or which recent CPUs are good, so if I'm obviously wrong, forgive me.

SoBe Clock

Quote from: The Spoiler;1678578Maybe you're CPU-limited? I don't know if popular benchmarks tell you whether you're CPU or GPU-limited, but it's worth a shot.

If these games offer settings for typical CPU bottlenecks (physics complexity, AI complexity,etc), give that a try too.

P.S I don't have a clue about which ATI cards are good or which recent CPUs are good, so if I'm obviously wrong, forgive me.

Both my CPU and Graphics card are far more than enough for any game on the market. My processor is a quad core, and my video card is ridiculously powerful. If either of them wasn't enough to handle the games I wouldn't get such good frame rates in 1920x1080.

I'll reiterate that I do get really good frame rates on any game out right now even at high and at 1920x1080, so even if I can't solve this issue it's of no consequence at the moment. This is more of a concern for future games.

The Spoiler

Well what framerates are you getting? Are they hovering around an obvious fps limit like 30 or 60 fps?

SoBe Clock

Quote from: The Spoiler;1678580Well what framerates are you getting? Are they hovering around an obvious fps limit like 30 or 60 fps?

Well, certain, more stressful games have frame rates around there. Crysis between 30 and 40. Far Cry 2 between 45 and 60. GTA4 between 40 and 50. Then there are other games like Unreal Tournament 3 that get over 80, Team Fortress 2 and Left 4 Dead between 80 and 110, and Counterstrike Source that gets between 140 and 180. So there's nothing limiting my frame rate for all the games.

Blue

First of all, nobody ever plays games at any resolution lower than the maximum native resolution of one's monitor. There's no reason to. Doing so doesn't give one the boost in performance as it once did in years past, and in some cases you will get poor performance at lower resolutions.

This has alot to do with newer rendering engines. These engines use a lot of HDR and blending techniques and those take up a hell of alot more resources than pumping out the pixels for your maximum resolution.

So, if you want better performance, tweek the video settings per game. First thing, dissable any kind of anti-aliasing.  With higher resolutions there is no point, as it doesn't add anything to the game, but instead just makes lines and edges less sharp. On high resolutions it actually does you a detriment by blurring distant objects, and it costs a LOT more gpu processing than you would think.

After that look at other HDR effects, like bloom and motion blurring, parallax surface texturing, etc. Sometimes lowering these settings to just below the maximum will make huge differences in performance. "Maxing Out" your graphics settings is silly if you have to lower your resolution to do so with decent frame rates.

I play games at 2560x1600 resolution. Sometimes at this resolution the effects that make the game look good at low resolutions are only tiny glimmers of enhancement, or even difficult to see at all. Meanwhile using those effects at such high resolutions can lower the frames per second VERY dramatically.
[FLASH=http://files.myfrogbag.com/mupff0/snowflake.swf]width=670 height=200 quality=medium wmode=transparent[/FLASH]

SoBe Clock

Quote from: Blue;1679201First of all, nobody ever plays games at any resolution lower than the maximum native resolution of one's monitor. There's no reason to. Doing so doesn't give one the boost in performance as it once did in years past, and in some cases you will get poor performance at lower resolutions.
I'll believe that. However, my desktop and my friend's laptop both struggle running certain games, let's use crysis for example, at their max resolutions. They can keep the quality and lose just a little bit of resolution (I'm talking one or two settings, not much) and maintain much higher frame rates that way, while still keeping high quality. They both use GeForce 9800 series cards, and, albeit they are not the newest cards on the market, they are from 2008, which is not old by any means.

QuoteThis has alot to do with newer rendering engines. These engines use a lot of HDR and blending techniques and those take up a hell of alot more resources than pumping out the pixels for your maximum resolution.
So, if you want better performance, tweek the video settings per game. First thing, dissable any kind of anti-aliasing.  With higher resolutions there is no point, as it doesn't add anything to the game, but instead just makes lines and edges less sharp. On high resolutions it actually does you a detriment by blurring distant objects, and it costs a LOT more gpu processing than you would think.
Trust me, I absolutely never use anti-aliasing. I know all about what these kinds of things do and how much resources they hog up. I'm just thinking there should be some difference in performance with resolution changes.

QuoteAfter that look at other HDR effects, like bloom and motion blurring, parallax surface texturing, etc. Sometimes lowering these settings to just below the maximum will make huge differences in performance. "Maxing Out" your graphics settings is silly if you have to lower your resolution to do so with decent frame rates.
Alright, I can  see where you're coming from with that. It's a good thing I get great performance on all games currently out without lowering the quality, so it's not a concern for right now.

QuoteI play games at 2560x1600 resolution. Sometimes at this resolution the effects that make the game look good at low resolutions are only tiny glimmers of enhancement, or even difficult to see at all. Meanwhile using those effects at such high resolutions can lower the frames per second VERY dramatically.
This just supports my theory that performance should improve as resolution changes though.


If the situation is just being caused by the way my monitor and video card work, then I guess I'll just work with it. After searching for a while, it doesn't seem like there is any way to change it.