News:

If you need instructions on how to get through the hotels, check out the enclosed instruction book.

Main Menu

MBTI Type

Farted by AlbinoClock, November 08, 2009, 06:14:08 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

DigitalLemonClock

Quote from: RomanClock;1690117By using similar logical fallacies you could apply the Forer affect to any situation that involves personality.

Example:

You are a caring individual.
vs
You take peoples emotions into account and empathize with them on a personal level.
vs
You understand peoples feelings, but you do not have an interest in them.

please explain, i dont think i understand what youre saying
BAN EVERYBODY

RomanClock

Quote from: DigitalLemonClock;1690132please explain, i dont think i understand what youre saying

This test actually asks questions about your personality, and then uses a simple algorithm to deduce the closest match the answers have to its pre-defined personality types and then provides specific information describing it.

A horoscope has no input and as such must use vague statements that have a number of interpretations.

The difference between this test and something that actually causes the Forer effect is that it has input and is specific. If you're really picky though, you could use logical fallacies to say that all interaction creates the Forer effect because of bias and interpretation. However, the effect is simply an extension of rationality (the mind thinks of some way to fit together possibly unrelated or vague concepts together)
lemayo lol :soups:

AnkhClock

Or we could just have fun with this but take it with a grain of salt.



RomanClock

Quote from: Lucius Fox;1690164Or we could just have fun with this but take it with a grain of salt.

That doesn't make sense!
Why would taking this test with a grain of salt make it any more fun?!
lemayo lol :soups:

DigitalLemonClock

Quote from: RomanClock;1690162This test actually asks questions about your personality, and then uses a simple algorithm to deduce the closest match the answers have to its pre-defined personality types and then provides specific information describing it.

A horoscope has no input and as such must use vague statements that have a number of interpretations.

The difference between this test and something that actually causes the Forer effect is that it has input and is specific. If you're really picky though, you could use logical fallacies to say that all interaction creates the Forer effect because of bias and interpretation. However, the effect is simply an extension of rationality (the mind thinks of some way to fit together possibly unrelated or vague concepts together)

i am questioning the value of categorising personality types in this way when that value cannot be properly assessed because of inherent biases like this

i am also questioning the specific information describing them because i can recognize myself in all of them to varying degrees, making it a likely scenario that each one can apply to a wider group of people than the test claims

saying you could hypothetically observe the forer effect in 'all interaction' is not true, because it is the combination of certain variables that influence the subject's judgement, rating the analysis of their personality higher than they might have, that are simply not present in 'all interaction', not even if you're 'really picky'.

they are, however, present in things like horoscopes

and personality tests

but im not saying you shouldnt waste 5 minutes on this and be amused by the results

it just didnt do much for me
BAN EVERYBODY

Slurpee

well I mean we've already called into question the applicability of the questions being asked toward the results being sought that's like the first thing I did. binary answers don't contain enough information to verify what the information being given actually is, and since the results are just approximations of the type of person that would typically supply whatever information is being given, they're only going to be accurate to that extent, hence marlin getting two semi-accurate results depending on which of two potentially accurate responses he selected.

the whole thing is just an extrapolation on "do you do mean things for no reason? no? the results are in and based on the answers you provided we can tell that you're an ok dude."
different categories of classification play off each other in different ways. is this guy mean, is this guy self-aware? no and yes? well then he's a nice guy who's self-aware. we'll call him The Librarian and name some things that nice and also self-aware guys might do.

the problems and deviations, and the part where the horoscope effect comes into play is that the more you attempt to expand on extrapolating complex human thoughts feelings and interactions from binary answers that could come about for any number of actual reasons, the less accurate you're going to get.

I thought this was obvious :wiebel:

DigitalLemonClock

well it seems obvious to me as well but the Myers-Briggs Type Indicator is serious business to a lot of people
BAN EVERYBODY

Slurpee

chalk it up to a natural human desire to pigeonhole shit, I guess.

RabidClock

I thought it was fun :(


Slurpee


PirateClock

Your Type is
ENTP

You are:

    * distinctively expressed extravert
    * moderately expressed intuitive personality
    * slightly expressed thinking personality
    * slightly expressed perceiving personality

Walt Disney, Benjamin Franklin, Ray Kurtzweil, Buckminster Fuller, Richard Feynman, Thomas Edison, Camille Paglia, Richard Feynman, Leonardo da Vinci, James Cameron, Patricia Schroeder (politician) Alexander the Great, Confederate General J. E. B. Stuart, Sir Walter Raleigh and Nicola Tesla are examples of an Inventor Rationals.

Fictional Characters:
"Q" (Star Trek--The Next Generation)
Shirley Feeney (Laverne and Shirley)
Bugs Bunny
Wile E. Coyote
Garfield the cat

http://typelogic.com/entp.html

Im gonna invent some shit yo!  I did one of these test only way way bigger for school, the kind of test you actually have to pay a shitload for and takes you 4 hours to fill out. Anywho they roughly divided people in 4 types. Some people would score high in two types. I however scored high in 3 types. Apparently this is very very rare, im rational and thinking AND extrovert and creative AND empathic and optimistic. I'll be very silent and observing when i need to be and i can be very extrovert and shit when i need to be aswell. I don't have any problem presenting for large groups of people for instance.


Also Wile E. Coyote has always been my favorite Loony Toon, now i know why!
_pirate_butchcavities (20:29:15): FUCK CLOCKS _pirate_

PirateClock

Quote"Clever" is the word that perhaps describes ENTPs best. The professor who juggles half a dozen ideas for research papers and grant proposals in his mind while giving a highly entertaining lecture on an abstruse subject is a classic example of the type. So is the stand-up comedian whose lampoons are not only funny, but incisively accurate.

ENTPs are usually verbally as well as cerebrally quick, and generally love to argue--both for its own sake, and to show off their often-impressive skills. They tend to have a perverse sense of humor as well, and enjoy playing devil's advocate. They sometimes confuse, even inadvertently hurt, those who don't understand or accept the concept of argument as a sport.

ENTPs are as innovative and ingenious at problem-solving as they are at verbal gymnastics; on occasion, however, they manage to outsmart themselves. This can take the form of getting found out at "sharp practice"--ENTPs have been known to cut corners without regard to the rules if it's expedient -- or simply in the collapse of an over-ambitious juggling act. Both at work and at home, ENTPs are very fond of "toys"--physical or intellectual, the more sophisticated the better. They tend to tire of these quickly, however, and move on to new ones.

ENTPs are basically optimists, but in spite of this (perhaps because of it?), they tend to become extremely petulant about small setbacks and inconveniences. (Major setbacks they tend to regard as challenges, and tackle with determin- ation.) ENTPs have little patience with those they consider wrongheaded or unintelligent, and show little restraint in demonstrating this. However, they do tend to be extremely genial, if not charming, when not being harassed by life in general.

In terms of their relationships with others, ENTPs are capable of bonding very closely and, initially, suddenly, with their loved ones. Some appear to be deceptively offhand with their nearest and dearest; others are so demonstrative that they succeed in shocking co-workers who've only seen their professional side. ENTPs are also good at acquiring friends who are as clever and entertaining as they are. Aside from those two areas, ENTPs tend to be oblivious of the rest of humanity, except as an audience -- good, bad, or potential.


This is pretty fucking accurate imo. Specially the bold parts are spot on.
_pirate_butchcavities (20:29:15): FUCK CLOCKS _pirate_

AbsintheClock

ISTP
QuoteThe nature of Crafters is most clearly seen in their masterful operation of tools, equipment, machines, and instruments of all kinds. Most us use tools in some capacity, of course, but Crafters (as much as ten percent of the population) are the true masters of tool work, with an innate ability to command tools and to become expert at all the crafts requiring tool skills. Even from an early age they are drawn to tools as to a magnet-tools fall into their hands demanding use, and they must work with them.

Like all the Artisans, Crafters are people who love action, and who know instinctively that their activities are more enjoyable, and more effective, if done impulsively, spontaneously, subject to no schedules or standards but their own. In a sense, Crafters do not work with their tools, but play with them when the urge strikes them. Crafters also seek fun and games on impulse, looking for any opportunity, and just because they feel like it, to play with their various toys: cars, motorcycles, boats, dune-buggies, hunting rifles, fishing tackle, scuba gear, and on and on. They thrive on excitement, particularly the rush of speed-racing, water-skiing, surfing. And Crafters are fearless in their play, exposing themselves to danger again and again, even despite frequent injury. Of all the types, Crafters are most likely to be risk takers, pitting themselves, or their technique, against chance or odds.

Crafters are hard to get to know. Perhaps this is because they tend to communicate through action, and show little interest in developing language skills. Their lack of expressiveness can isolate them at school and on the job, and even though they hang around with their own kind in play, they let their actions speak for them, and their actual conversation is sparse and brief.

Crafters can be wonderfully generous and loyal to their friends, teammates, and sidekicks, often giving up their evenings or weekends to help with building projects or mechanical repairs-house remodeling, for example, or working on cars or boats. On the other hand, they can be fiercely insubordinate to those in authority, seeing rules and regulations as unnecessarily confining. Crafters will not usually go against regulations openly, but will simply ignore them. More than anything, Crafters want to be free to do their own thing, and they are proud of their ability to do it with an artist's skill.

Bruce Lee, Michael Jordan, Woody Allen, Alan Shepard, Chuck Yaeger, Michael Douglas, Lance Armstrong, and Kathrine Hephurn are examples of Crafter Artisans.

DiscoBallClock

I got ENFJ

QuoteEven more than the other Idealists, Teachers have a natural talent for leading students or trainees toward learning, or as Idealists like to think of it, they are capable of calling forth each learner's potentials. Teachers (around two percent of the population) are able - effortlessly, it seems, and almost endlessly-to dream up fascinating learning activities for their students to engage in. In some Teachers, this ability to fire the imagination can amount to a kind of genius which other types find hard to emulate. But perhaps their greatest strength lies in their belief in their students. Teachers look for the best in their students, and communicate clearly that each one has untold potential, and this confidence can inspire their students to grow and develop more than they ever thought possible.
In whatever field they choose, Teachers consider people their highest priority, and they instinctively communicate personal concern and a willingness to become involved. Warmly outgoing, and perhaps the most expressive of all the types, Teachers are remarkably good with language, especially when communicating in speech, face to face. And they do not hesitate to speak out and let their feelings be known. Bubbling with enthusiasm, Teachers will voice their passions with dramatic flourish, and can, with practice, become charismatic public speakers. This verbal ability gives Teachers a good deal of influence in groups, and they are often asked to take a leadership role.
Teachers like things settled and organized, and will schedule their work hours and social engagements well ahead of time-and they are absolutely trustworthy in honoring these commitments. Valuing as they do interpersonal cooperation and harmonious relations, Teachers are extraordinarily tolerant of others, are easy to get along with, and are usually popular wherever they are.
Teachers are highly sensitive to others, which is to say their intuition tends to be well developed. Certainly their insight into themselves and others is unparalleled. Without a doubt, they know what is going on inside themselves, and they can read other people with uncanny accuracy. Teachers also identify with others quite easily, and will actually find themselves picking up the characteristics, emotions, and beliefs of those around them. Because they slip almost unconsciously into other people's skin in this way, Teachers feel closely connected with those around them, and thus show a sincere interest in the joys and problems of their employees, colleagues, students, clients, and loved ones.
Mikhail Gorbachev, Oprah Winfrey, Pope John Paul II, Ralph Nader, John Wooden, and Margaret Mead are examples of Teacher Idealists.

[FLASH=http://files.myfrogbag.com/kqk1bc/discosig.swf]http://width=300 height=200[/FLASH]

CourgetteClock

QuoteIdealist Portrait of the Teacher (ENFJ)

Even more than the other Idealists, Teachers have a natural talent for leading students or trainees toward learning, or as Idealists like to think of it, they are capable of calling forth each learner's potentials. Teachers (around two percent of the population) are able - effortlessly, it seems, and almost endlessly-to dream up fascinating learning activities for their students to engage in. In some Teachers, this ability to fire the imagination can amount to a kind of genius which other types find hard to emulate. But perhaps their greatest strength lies in their belief in their students. Teachers look for the best in their students, and communicate clearly that each one has untold potential, and this confidence can inspire their students to grow and develop more than they ever thought possible.

In whatever field they choose, Teachers consider people their highest priority, and they instinctively communicate personal concern and a willingness to become involved. Warmly outgoing, and perhaps the most expressive of all the types, Teachers are remarkably good with language, especially when communicating in speech, face to face. And they do not hesitate to speak out and let their feelings be known. Bubbling with enthusiasm, Teachers will voice their passions with dramatic flourish, and can, with practice, become charismatic public speakers. This verbal ability gives Teachers a good deal of influence in groups, and they are often asked to take a leadership role.

Teachers like things settled and organized, and will schedule their work hours and social engagements well ahead of time-and they are absolutely trustworthy in honoring these commitments. Valuing as they do interpersonal cooperation and harmonious relations, Teachers are extraordinarily tolerant of others, are easy to get along with, and are usually popular wherever they are.

Teachers are highly sensitive to others, which is to say their intuition tends to be well developed. Certainly their insight into themselves and others is unparalleled. Without a doubt, they know what is going on inside themselves, and they can read other people with uncanny accuracy. Teachers also identify with others quite easily, and will actually find themselves picking up the characteristics, emotions, and beliefs of those around them. Because they slip almost unconsciously into other people's skin in this way, Teachers feel closely connected with those around them, and thus show a sincere interest in the joys and problems of their employees, colleagues, students, clients, and loved ones.

Mikhail Gorbachev, Oprah Winfrey, Pope John Paul II, Ralph Nader, John Wooden, and Margaret Mead are examples of Teacher Idealists.

A full description of the Teacher and the Idealists is in People Patterns or Please Understand Me II

I'm Clockcrew's very own Oprah.

EDIT: These parts are actually very accurate. Scary stuff.