News:

If you need instructions on how to get through the hotels, check out the enclosed instruction book.

Main Menu

Lets talk about the election

Farted by AbsintheClock, September 11, 2011, 07:17:13 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

AnkhClock

Quote from: RibsClock;1852292definite arguments could be made against me being on staff.

Don't vote for Corpseginder

he's a douche



AlbinoClock

Quote from: RibsClock;1852310Limiting how

Limiting in that some of the people voting felt that there weren't enough people on the ballot. If all nominees were on the ballot and write-in candidates were a possibility this would not be the case.

SockpuppetClock

Quote from: FloundermanClock;1852315Clam is George Bush and I'm Dennis Kucinich. I promise as the first socialist admin of the Clock Crew to give suffrage to dolphins.
bb10 is ron paul


AbsintheClock


AlbinoClock

Quote from: RibsClock;1852322Because they didn't get enough votes in nomination, or got too many "no" votes.

I fail to see how that's a problem.

You fail to see how people thinking that there weren't enough people on the ballot is a problem?

AlbinoClock

Quote from: RibsClock;1852336What I am saying is that it seems to me that this is not a problem inherent to the system, but rather people being unhappy with how people voted. If more people had nominated and voted for more candidates, there would be more candidates on the ballot, it's as simple as that.

Except that this isn't some entrenched and proven system. There are complaints that the ballots were lacking, there isn't a question about that. It's pointless to debate this with you because you're in brick wall mode, so I'm not going to anymore.

AlbinoClock

Quote from: RibsClock;1852343huh what wait did I miss the part where this became angry or something

Not angry, just pointless.

AnkhClock

Quote from: SockpuppetClock;1852324bb10 is ron paul


ahahahaha holy shit



FLOUNDERMAN_CLOCK

Here's what I think we should of done:

1: vote in ten staff members
2: vote among those staff members who should be admin

Two elections, much fairer and cleaner.

AlbinoClock

Quote from: RibsClock;1852347Seems to me that you're going "You are irrational, this conversation is over!" and I feel like I missed the part where this became entrenched or adversarial at all just because I didn't agree with the one conclusion on the matter.

But hey, whatever man. Talk or don't.

It's not that at all. I've gotten to know you a fair bit over the past few years, and I don't know exactly why, but there's a point at which there's no reason to continue to try to discuss a matter with you, and I've identified this as one of those situations.

AlbinoClock

Quote from: FloundermanClock;1852350Here's what I think we should of done:

1: vote in ten staff members
2: vote among those staff members who should be admin

Two elections, much fairer and cleaner.

That's better than changing the meaning of people's supermod votes.

PineappleClock

Quote from: FloundermanClock;1852350Here's what I think we should of done:

1: vote in ten staff members
2: vote among those staff members who should be admin

Two elections, much fairer and cleaner.

Yes, that's probably how we will want to do it next time - our nominate an admin OR supermod looked good on paper but left us with only two admin nominees and three positions.
I think what we will do this year is offer the admin position to the three people who do best in the election, and if they decline offer it on down the line until someone wants it. The job descriptions are different enough to the point where people might not necessarily want the added responsibilities.

This is a big experiment so we'll be learning from the mistakes.

pop-tart

My only concern is one that unfortunately has no solution in politics.

There are quite a few incumbents running. None of the current 'office holders' were brought in by any sort of democratic process. They themselves got to decide who was up for 're-election.'

Some have no business being in their positions because they honestly don't do anything. Still love these guys, but being in the position for prestigious motivations instead of actual contributing.. why not step out and let someone else in?

I'm certainly not saying an open seat election would make any sense.. but with the exception of Piney.. no one should have been exempt from the general public nomination process.

Long story short... everyone seems generally happy with the way the site is being run right now since the 'change.' Anti-incumbent votes are very rare when people are content with the 'state of the union.' So this election runs the risk of keeping inactive smods in place... or smods who's personal values and opinions are not necessarily beneficial to the progress of the community as a  whole.. and theoretically impeding growth and development.

God bless George Dubya.

FLOUNDERMAN_CLOCK

Quote from: pop-tart clock;1852355So this election runs the risk of keeping inactive smods in place... or smods who's personal values and opinions are not necessarily beneficial to the progress of the community as a  whole.. and theoretically impeding growth and development.

I personally voted in the incumbent thing for people who were active. There were very good people I didnt vote for because they werent active. IE pirate and munglai. The incumbents are all people who are active. I also plan on voting against anyone who starts impeding progress.

Unless its me because I am going to become admin, go mad with power, and sit on my ass for three straight years at the end of which I will delete the site.

pop-tart

Quote from: FloundermanClock;1852359I personally voted in the incumbent thing for people who were active. There were very good people I didnt vote for because they werent active. IE pirate and munglai. The incumbents are all people who are active. I also plan on voting against anyone who starts impeding progress.

Unless its me because I am going to become admin, go mad with power, and sit on my ass for three straight years at which point I will delete the site.

And that's how it should work... intelligent people will vote with the same thought process.

But people are nuts. They vote on popularity. Cult of personality, brother.

Scotty McCreery beat James Durbin, man.

FLOUNDERMAN_CLOCK

Quote from: pop-tart clock;1852361And that's how it should work... intelligent people will vote with the same thought process.

But people are nuts. They vote on popularity. Cult of personality, brother.

Scotty McCreery beat James Durbin, man.

I plan on amassing a cult of personality. Regardless it doesnt matter if I'm elected or not. The resulting staff is a puppet government of mine anyways. I run this shit.

pop-tart

Quote from: FloundermanClock;1852363I plan on amassing a cult of personality. Regardless it doesnt matter if I'm elected or not. The resulting staff is a puppet government of mine anyways. I run this shit.

I am strangely comfortable with that :)

AnkhClock

Flounderman Clock for Dear Leader



Asshatclock

There's nothing for me to say other then that I've voted 10 times on myself.

miracle fruit

Quote from: FloundermanClock;1852291If I get admin I have some hilarious skins planned.
enter clockchan.org
Quote from: AlbinoClock;1852320i'm mad i didn't get majority in my nomination thread
ok then