News:

If you need instructions on how to get through the hotels, check out the enclosed instruction book.

Main Menu

Lets talk about the election

Farted by AbsintheClock, September 11, 2011, 07:17:13 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

YoYoClock

I mentioned a while ago I think it was unfair to have it be too easy for incumbents to get on the ballot. I also feel that next time incumbents are subject to renomination. Maybe a similar situation to this time can occur, but the staff at the time only choose 2 or 3 smods to stay on the ballot with renomination.


EDIT:

Also another problem I've found that might improve the nomination process, and address part of Albinos concern, is the length of time allowed to vote in the nomination process. Because anybody could just nominate at any point during the process, some people were nominated near the end and therefore did not get the same amount of time for the public to think about them than some early nominees. I wouldn't say this is inherently unfair, but I think it's benefit everyone, including nominee numbers, and integrity of the publics decision, if all nominees had the same amount of time to be voted on

So nomination period starts and everybody nominates people, then nominee voting period starts where we get to vote on those people to be on the ballot.

by Thor + Satellite

Quote from: pop-tart clock;1905428I think yoyo is the best one.

AMPEEEM

Man, I wish I had gotten in on this earlier.

Anyway, totally voted Pineapple for Supermod, Grey for noomber 1 and Lotus for nomber 2, but that was a totally popularity vote because he is my hommie, number three is Absinthe because he's a cool fucker like Albino except he's still around and then Asshat because I always secretly thought he was a smart guy, and then just pressed buttons.

miracle fruit

remember when everyone was all 'clock crew is an oligarchy, always was and ALWAYS WILL BE'
welp i guess you were WRONG HAHA FAGOTT
FUCK YUO TO DEATH

YoYoClock

Quote from: RibsClock;1852392The way we've done it for the past decade has been that the staff decide who's on staff, nana nana boo boo stick your head in doo doo, and incumbents get to stay in office until they quit, kick each other out, or someone blows up the site.

That you get to vote twice a year whether they stay or go can't be that bad, can it?

Well no, I do agree the current system is obviously better than what we had before, but that's no reason not to think of ways it could be made more representative. If it stays this way I'm not gonna throw a fit or anything. I'm not sure why having been elected in the last election gives a staff member the right to easy way into the next election really, that's all.

It seems having incumbents having any kind of advantage is pointless in our current system. It seems it was only enacted because it's just something they do in politics, hey lets do that too why? i dunno

by Thor + Satellite

Quote from: pop-tart clock;1905428I think yoyo is the best one.

Slurpee

Okay, see, my problem is, if
Quote from: RibsClock;1852397Well actually it does have a point and it's not just because that's something they do in politics. It's to make our exceedingly frequent elections less disruptive to the present staff. This one is already particularly disruptive, as it's going to be removing half or more of our existing smods.

If staff are to be voted out, we want it to be for a good reason and because there are specific replacements in mind, not because people got high and forgot to vote in the nomination thread.
why have biannual elections at all, when we've found such success with the benign oligarchy? The admin position seems tailor-made to fulfill the purposes served by that sainted role. It seems to me we're drawing undue scrutiny to people expected to serve that valued occupation.

Why not just put in a system where users can force a staff recall election by voter initiative? Something like a petition signed by 67% of the average daily visitors over the last month.
That seems sufficient to me to oust a stagnant or abusive administration, but out of sight and mind enough to not disrupt an active, competent staff.
And that way if, say, I'm elected admin, and me and the other two guys just sit around holding our dicks for two months, the people can initiate a movement to replace me without having to wait until May or whatever.

I'm seriously lukewarm on the whole democratic Clock Crew thing.
With a system this formal, the focus of the Crew at large is going to be bureaucratic. We're all going to be taking an active role in how the Crew is run, and that sounds nice, but it's not. We'll be at each other's throats, and, in so being, we're going to be diverting what could have been creative energy into arguing. We're boho trolls and artists, but we're acting like politicians. Just look at this thread.


And to go off on a wild tangent, defaulting to a vote precludes organic discussion. The direction taken by any leadership, especially for policy-making, is a sincere question of philosophies, and democracy seldom does that question justice. To take the eclectic opinions of whatever members happen across the site during the elections, pound those opinions down into a brass tacks, wholesale decision, and then just add up the results, is a gross oversimplification.
I'll just come out and say it: Not everybody's opinion is equally valid. I have the sneaking suspicion that it's anathema to say that, but I don't know why. It seems obvious to me that, like any internet community, we have a loose core of dedicated members- people with their fingers on the pulse of the community, talking to others, contributing to projects. In essence, the core members are people who feel they've given to the Clock Crew, and expect some recognition in return, and we need to be wary of those expectations, lest we lose those people, be it in approval, contributions, or even presence. Democracy "works" because people feel as though their voices are being heard. The aforementioned core members are not going to get that feeling when some half-assed vote they threw in a month ago becomes an excuse for something they don't approve of.

OR WHATEVER~.

I love you, Clock Crew, I just don't want to see you get hurt again.

GreyClock

Quote from: RibsClock;1852377It's not ever going to stop people from thinking "I think Strange should be admin because he's a nice guy and a good animator who's been here a long time" and disregarding whether these things (while all quite good things!) actually pertain to him discharging his duties and make him more qualified than Slurps, for example, who is a grumpy tit who hardly ever makes flash, but has a good mind for being an administrator, he knows how to friggin' post without bringing shame to grorious crock crew.
One could argue that being a good animator would make someone more qualified as the charter describes that a large part of being an administrator is organizing holidays, collaborations and the Academy? After all we are an animation group so why are capabilities as an animator suddenly considered bad criteria? Lead by example and so on. Yet what qualifies Slurpee as an administrator is "having a good mind" and "knowing how to post"? Surely the same things apply to someone like Strange? Or indeed all of the nominees? Maybe you just picked horrible examples to make your point? In my opinion Slurpee is the example of a vote based on a cult of personality. His nomination thread is basically "but I like him so yes." Even after he himself expressed doubts over his capabilities. And the entire system /\ :golfclap:

TequilaClock

All I have to say is that I voted.

YoYoClock

I can't say that doubts about whether this democratic hoohah will work or not aren't founded, but it's not like we don't have all the time in the world to find and perfect a system we think works. It's sortof pointless right now to be discussing how this all isn't gonna work. We should just wait and see, do our best to keep it civil, and have fun.

besides hur hur internet hur hur serious business hur hur

by Thor + Satellite

Quote from: pop-tart clock;1905428I think yoyo is the best one.

PowerGloveClock

Quote from: Topcatyo;1852249argh ya got me

topcatyo for all the staff positions, everyone else is doing it wrong
Quote from: FLOUNDERINYOBUTT;1837615I think Kodiak is the only person on  this entire website who dislikes Slurpee. I still dont understand how  thats possible. He\'s so loveable and funny. Every guy wants to be his  friend and every girl wants to date him. Understandably Slurpee is not a  very happy person.

GreyClock

Quote from: RibsClock;1852424Yes one could argue that.

One could also argue that you don't actually have to be skilled at flash at all to do any of those things, and that those pertain more to management (key word organizing those things)
Manage what? "Hey, do an Academy this Saturday, will you?" "Hey, do some sort of collaboration, will you?" It's not rocket science. It's more like dead weight.

Quote from: PineappleClock;1846998This is a group of three members: Head developers or artists who will lead the community in activity-related endeavours (crew holidays, publicity stunts, collaborations, weekly activities like the Academy), development activities (planning site features for the coders to implement) and creating site and crew policy. The admins should interact frequently, working together as a group.
Maybe we've gone about this the wrong way? Maybe it would have been better if nominees had given some general idea about how they would want to fill their position? Maybe Slurpee will share what his plans are?

Quote from: RibsClock;1852424Because one can be a truly fantastic animator and at the same time be an unreliable inactive weenie who is a pain to deal with in the grid.
No shit. All I said was that animation skills should factor in, not that we disregard every other quality one may or may not have.

Quote from: RibsClock;1852424What's more, animation being the mode of expression for out group, it's a very public thing that people participate in actively and can see right away without having to think much about it. The other things require investigation, thought, and possibly experience to make a judgment on, and it's much easier for people to fall back on "that guy made that amazing movie!"
Well that's one of the major flaws in this transition though. You expect regular members to make some sort of reasonable, well-informed decision based on information that for the most part they don't have access too, i.e. past behavior in the Grid and so on.

Slurpee

Quote from: GreyClock;1852423After all we are an animation group so why are capabilities as an animator suddenly considered bad criteria?
Quote from: GreyClock;1852432All I said was that animation skills should factor in, not that we disregard every other quality one may or may not have.
Hey I'm a pretty good animator! =(

Look
http://files.myfrogbag.com/8xu8snn0tggygnz/picoday.swf
Look at me being pretty good
http://files.myfrogbag.com/8xu8snn0tggygnz/portale.swf

Quote from: GreyClock;1852432Maybe Slurpee will share what his plans are?

Ã,¯\:v/Ã,¯

I've been sitting on a loose plan to spur production by encouraging people to slap a clock label on flashes without clocks in them for like 3 years, but that's about it, and the fact that I've just been sitting on it is probably not a good sign.

Really, guys, when the new admin position is explained as
QuoteHead developers or artists who will lead the community in activity-related endeavours (crew holidays, publicity stunts, collaborations, weekly activities like the Academy), blah blah blah blah blah
you should probably be looking at someone like me like something the cat dragged in.

Can you name a single bit of leadership in a creative capacity that I've done?
No, you can't, because I've never gotten any collaboration of any kind off the ground, in 8 and a half years. BB10 has done more creative leadership than I have.

I do in a pinch, I do do, but it's the adminning equivalent of cutting class once a week the entire semester, and then acing the final. If it's not about to explode, I tend to just sit on it indefinitely. I try to care, but my stars is it difficult.

I'm not resigned to failure, but if you take past deeds as any indication of future behavior, and place importance on creative direction don't vote for me. t(-_-|t
I'm only gonna break break your break break your heeaaart
I'm barack obama and I approve this message.

edit: not that I don't appreciate the support. heh. <3

Asshatclock

Quote from: Slurpee;1852436BB10 has done more creative leadership than I have.

I don't think any of us has done more creative leadership then bb10.

GreyClock

Quote from: RibsClock;1852433If it were as simple as that I assure you none of this would be an issue in the first place.

To maintain a constant project like flash academy, to herd cats and keep people on task with any decent-sized collab, and to actually hammer out the details and get people excited and on board for a flash event is something that is often difficult and complicated, and not everyone is great at it.
Easy on the patronizing there cowboy. I've lead my share of successful flash events and collaborations.

I have never organized a flash academy, and only participated once or twice, but I think that the real difficulty is getting someone to lead it, right? Is this something you expect the three administrators to do? If not, they will organize for other people to do so?

Like you said the current election might be somewhat of a popularity contest and with the automatic bestowal of administrator status to the first three your whole argument of putting the right people in the right place falls flat anyway.

Quote from: RibsClock;1852433You asked me why I considered it bad criteria, I explained. It's not a very good criteria, it has only very indirect effect on running the site. Yes it has some minor application, that's true, but let's not kid ourselves it's not a main qualification to base your decision on, it's just a perk.
If you don't see how flash ability is beneficial to the creative leadership* described and required for that function, I don't know what to say?

* And not "running the site" as was perhaps the case up until this system.

Quote from: RibsClock;1852433Like I said, we're working on that. The Policy forum is part of that. We're making a major transition from the way things have been done to something quite a bit more open and participatory.
That doesn't really fix the current situation?

Quote from: Slurpee;1852436Hey I'm a pretty good animator! =(
I'm awfully sorry I didn't mean to imply anything even remotely like that.

AbsintheClock

I wish I was as good a community leader as BB10.

BluezombieClock

I haven't seen a single peggey in this thread yet... Whaaaaaaa?
╔═════════════════ ೋáÆ'¦â˜Æ'áÆ'¦à³‹ ════════════════â•â€"
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ Repost this if ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~ ~ you are a beautiful strong black woman ~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ who donââ,¬â,,¢t need no man ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
╚═════════════════ ೋáÆ'¦â˜Æ'áÆ'¦à³‹ ════════════════╝

☣ Motionmaker[/URL]


AlbinoClock

Quote from: AMPEEEM;1852388Man, I wish I had gotten in on this earlier.

Anyway, totally voted Pineapple for Supermod, Grey for noomber 1 and Lotus for nomber 2, but that was a totally popularity vote because he is my hommie, number three is Absinthe because he's a cool fucker like Albino except he's still around and then Asshat because I always secretly thought he was a smart guy, and then just pressed buttons.

I'm still fucking around!

YoYoClock

Quote from: AlbinoClock;1852462I'm still fucking around!

this is starting to get really funny to me

by Thor + Satellite

Quote from: pop-tart clock;1905428I think yoyo is the best one.

AlbinoClock

Quote from: GreyClock;1852440Like you said the current election might be somewhat of a popularity contest and with the automatic bestowal of administrator status to the first three your whole argument of putting the right people in the right place falls flat anyway.

Lots of this. When you tell people after the fact that the top people they voted for will be the new admins what you've done is make a secret popularity contest.

Also, it's way too easy for the incumbents, especially this year, as they were never chosen by the community in the first place.

YoYoClock

Quote from: AlbinoClock;1852464Lots of this. When you tell people after the fact that the top people they voted for will be the new admins what you've done is make a secret popularity contest.

Even though it was a last minute decision it says right on the voting page and in pineys announcement that the top 3 will be admin. That count as being told before voting. I'm not saying this was the best scenario but it was last minute. Next time we'll come up with better system, but I just wish people would stop suggesting we fix the system right now. By the sounds of it we're gonna end up with a decent selection even if the system sucked, so just let it be for now and we can discuss at length afterwards how to fix it for may.

Quote from: AlbinoClock;1852464Also, it's way to easy for the incumbents, especially this year, as they were never chosen by the community in the first place.

This has been addressed I think by me as well as others, and we'll hopefully be looking to find a solution to it for next time

by Thor + Satellite

Quote from: pop-tart clock;1905428I think yoyo is the best one.

AlbinoClock

I'm sure our selection will be fine. There were very few people on that ballot that I think would cause a problem if they were on the staff. What I'm not happy with is the mechanism and the dismissal of anything and everything that's wrong with it on the part of our little buddy here. Obviously we don't even know who we're going to be dealing with to get this thing changed other than Piney, but I hope whoever it is is a little more amenable.