News:

If you need instructions on how to get through the hotels, check out the enclosed instruction book.

Main Menu

The Repression of Social Evolution By Existing Authorities

Farted by AlbinoClock, February 27, 2009, 03:03:01 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

AlbinoClock

Quote from: RomanClock;1530476No, it means that dissimilar ideals can have intersecting principles.

No, it means that neither of you comprehend the meaning of futility.

Wind-up Clock

This is why i like the clock crew. The arguments here have at least some backing to them in terms of logic instead of devolving into LOL UR RONG LOL NO exchanges.
[SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]

CrustClock

I'm not equating your examples to these crimes, but there are plenty of cases of murder and rape which will never be solved. Would you say it was 'futile' to try to prevent these crimes seeing as these crimes will never cease to occur? Every time a crime gets solved, some other criminal steps into their place, not because it's organized but because people want to commit crimes. If enough people want to commit a crime, they're going to commit it. There's nothing to be done about it.

Silly Putty Clock

Quote from: CrustClock;1530734I'm not equating your examples to these crimes, but there are plenty of cases of murder and rape which will never be solved. Would you say it was 'futile' to try to prevent these crimes seeing as these crimes will never cease to occur? Every time a crime gets solved, some other criminal steps into their place, not because it's organized but because people want to commit crimes. If enough people want to commit a crime, they're going to commit it. There's nothing to be done about it.

But wouldn't it be great if you could fill out a form from the government that said you could legally have someone killed or take possession of some of their property, but there was a load of red tape that you had to step around to be able to obtain this priviledge, so that very few people killed or stole?

This is purely hypothetical, of course, and I don't know if it would really work this way or not, but maybe a lot of violent activity would be reduced if everybody could legally do it, but had to deal with restrictions. I can't say for sure. Of course, there will always be serial killers, but that's a small percentage of the population. Personally, I think regulation is a wiser approach than outright banning. Let people do things, but make sure that they have a good reason, and that they go about it a certain way.
I don't know. I'm completely uncertain about how this could apply to violent crime. All I'm saying is that it's an idea. I myself don't much like the idea of a society in which the government intrudes on everything. I also don't like the idea of having to look over your shoulder, knowing that an enemy of yours might have succeeded in signing your execution warrant or repossessing your things. It would have to be set up carefully.
8=======D~~~~>_<~~~~C=======8

screwdriver_clock

Quote from: Maltese;1530625last figure I heard was 23 percent, but that's probably wrong
Last I heard, the number was in the mid 40s since the Phelps "incident", and steadily rising up. I see a bit of promise in the future for it :)

Silly Putty Clock

Quote from: Matt;1530867Last I heard, the number was in the mid 40s since the Phelps "incident", and steadily rising up. I see a bit of promise in the future for it :)

I don't do drugs myself, but I'd support it. I say the more freedom, the better.
The government might also benefit if they can tax dealers and distributors.

Quote from: Best Basketball Game EVER;1530870He's pointing out a flaw in the "People are going to do it, therefore it shouldn't be illegal" argument. It's an attack on Albino's logic, that albino set himself up for by arguing against the legal ban on marijuana using sweeping statements about the operation of government.

I knew that, but I was trying to say that even his example might not hold up. Of course, as I said, I was completely uncertain. I definitely wouldn't call myself an expert, but I was throwing the idea out there.
8=======D~~~~>_<~~~~C=======8

Silly Putty Clock

Quote from: Best Basketball Game EVER;1530885It does hold up. Though Albino meant marijuana he phrased it in such a way as to encompass all illegal activities.

Well, I'm glad to be proven wrong on that count. I'm afraid of the idea of regulated murder. Regulated canniblism and a regulated drug trade are fine by me, but murder...
8=======D~~~~>_<~~~~C=======8

Maltese

Quote from: Best Basketball Game EVER;1530870He's pointing out a flaw in the "People are going to do it, therefore it shouldn't be illegal" argument. It's an attack on Albino's logic, that albino set himself up for by arguing against the legal ban on marijuana using sweeping statements about the operation of government.

I think a more important point of albinos has to do with harm, downloading music doesn't harm anyone, it damages an industry that supports the super rich, it's not a big deal, and anything that takes money away from the super rich, I support.

Murder and theft causes direct harm to people, whereas, I'm pretty sure that marijuana never hurt anyone, people may have hurt themselves out of idiocy involving marijuana, but marijuana itself is better for you than alcohol, which itself is actually very good for you in moderation.

Quote from: Abs in the Hot Dog;1530889Well, I'm glad to be proven wrong on that count. I'm afraid of the idea of regulated murder. Regulated canniblism and a regulated drug trade are fine by me, but murder...

I want my body eaten instead of having a funeral, I'm going to put it in my will and mention that if they don't eat me, I will fucking haunt them.

Silly Putty Clock

Quote from: Maltese;1530904I think a more important point of albinos has to do with harm, downloading music doesn't harm anyone, it damages an industry that supports the super rich, it's not a big deal, and anything that takes money away from the super rich, I support.
Although I agree, I feel an irresistable compulsion to post:
[u2]0oeDgcP_Evo[/u2]
I'm really, really sorry. Please forgive me.

Quote from: Maltese;1530904I want my body eaten instead of having a funeral, I'm going to put it in my will and mention that if they don't eat me, I will fucking haunt them.
Fuck Yeah

Quote from: Best Basketball Game EVER;1530905I want to have my bones bronzed and mechanical joints put in so that after I'm dead my body is a super-cool posable skeleton.
Fuck Yeah Mk. II
8=======D~~~~>_<~~~~C=======8

CrustClock

Quote from: Maltese;1530904I think a more important point of albinos has to do with harm, downloading music doesn't harm anyone, it damages an industry that supports the super rich, it's not a big deal, and anything that takes money away from the super rich, I support.

Murder and theft causes direct harm to people, whereas, I'm pretty sure that marijuana never hurt anyone, people may have hurt themselves out of idiocy involving marijuana, but marijuana itself is better for you than alcohol, which itself is actually very good for you in moderation.

I wasn't saying the crimes were similar, I was attacking Albino's logic that, because it is 'futile' to stop a type of crime, it is not worth the money/ effort in policing it. I even prefaced that post by saying that I wasn't equating the two.

edit: My problem with Albino's OP was that he was dressing up two very clichéd arguments about filesharing and marijuana-legalisation as a philosophy about how authorities should decide on law-making. If you claim that attempts to police a crime are 'futile' (i.e. that you can never completely remove, or even reduce, the crime from society), then why wouldn't you apply this logic to all other laws, rape and murder included? THEY happen no matter what the authorities do, as well.

Silly Putty Clock

Quote from: CrustClock;1531169I wasn't saying the crimes were similar, I was attacking Albino's logic that, because it is 'futile' to stop a type of crime, it is not worth the money/ effort in policing it. I even prefaced that post by saying that I wasn't equating the two.

I think the big difference here is that selling weed isn't a way of attacking someone.
8=======D~~~~>_<~~~~C=======8

CrustClock

Quote from: Abs in the Hot Dog;1531171I think the big difference here is that selling weed isn't a way of attacking someone.

For the forth time: no - the crimes are not equally reprehensible.

But Albino wasn't saying "why isn't weed and p2p legal? v.65985965" (which would be more honest), he was saying "why do authorities police crimes which people will always commit". I was pointing out, and am pointing out for the third time now, that for that to be a coherant philosophy you would have to say that all crimes should be legalised, as those crimes will never be fully wiped out, either. The fact that more people smoke weed/ fileshare, than there are murderers and rapists is irrelevant: if you condone one illegality via "there are people who want it/ want to do it" you must apply that logic to all crimes; otherwise you are establishing a double standard in your philosophy.

Maltese

Quote from: CrustClock;1531169I wasn't saying the crimes were similar, I was attacking Albino's logic that, because it is 'futile' to stop a type of crime, it is not worth the money/ effort in policing it. I even prefaced that post by saying that I wasn't equating the two.

edit: My problem with Albino's OP was that he was dressing up two very clichéd arguments about filesharing and marijuana-legalisation as a philosophy about how authorities should decide on law-making. If you claim that attempts to police a crime are 'futile' (i.e. that you can never completely remove, or even reduce, the crime from society), then why wouldn't you apply this logic to all other laws, rape and murder included? THEY happen no matter what the authorities do, as well.

you're missing his point about futility, rape and murder happen, but they don't happen constantly for a huge section of the population (like torrents and apparently weed is in the 40s for percentage according to a previous post)

if everyone is doing it, it shouldn't be a crime, or else we would all be criminals.
we all download media, according to US law, we are criminals, but everyone does it, it's normal, it's futile to try to police something THAT EVERYONE IS DOING

not everyone is raping and murdering, but nearly everyone is downloading, and eventually the majority of the US population will be smoking weed.

why should these things be illegal, if there is just such sheer numbers of people doing it, why have such a money making industry, such as marijuana, be illegal and controlled by those classified as nefarious characters, instead of growing it, selling it, and taxing it by the government, the numbers are there, there's a market, the amount of people doing it is staggering to say the least, and to attempt to stop it is idiotic.

murderers don't make up the majority of our population, they don't even make up the same percentage as Scientologists, but Pot-smoking Pirates make up a higher percentage of the population as Scientologists and yet they have no voice considering the legalization of these illicit practices.

Democracy at work.

AbsintheClock

Last US poll I heard it was 40% in favor of legalization, 48% of keeping the status and the rest were unsure. By the way my source was Norml.org who are notorious for being biased but they definitely keep their facts in check. More Americans want to legalize it than you think. We just need to wait till all the old people die.

Also the reason why file sharing and marijuana are a waste of money as opposed to something like murder is because pot and free mp3's don't kill people or take food off the table. If a musician isn't making money odds are it's because they don't tour enough not because they don't sell enough cds. Its all about just straight marketing but the music industry is afraid of that. As for marijuana policy once again it is a harmless recreational drug with multiple proven uses and functions. Yet according to the US government it is one of the most destructive drugs in the world, it deserves jail time, and it has no medical uses. Despite what any study has said about pot we've all just turned a blind eye. Another reason the arguments remain the same is because they've always been consistent arguments. This is once again more than I can say for the status quo.

Another reason people are so afraid of it is because we've had these bullshit drug education systems with an unrealistic "just say no" policy that's been shoved down everyone's throats. What should be taught in schools is a realistic understanding of what drugs are, what their short term use is like, and what their long term use is like. Let folks come to their own conclusions while they are still young and show folks all the facts. I'm not saying give pot to kids either. I'm saying have an open and honest dialogue with everyone. The pro-marijuana community has been open and honest about it more than any other community.

AlbinoClock

Quote from: CrustClock;1531169I wasn't saying the crimes were similar, I was attacking Albino's logic that, because it is 'futile' to stop a type of crime, it is not worth the money/ effort in policing it. I even prefaced that post by saying that I wasn't equating the two.

edit: My problem with Albino's OP was that he was dressing up two very clichéd arguments about filesharing and marijuana-legalisation as a philosophy about how authorities should decide on law-making. If you claim that attempts to police a crime are 'futile' (i.e. that you can never completely remove, or even reduce, the crime from society), then why wouldn't you apply this logic to all other laws, rape and murder included? THEY happen no matter what the authorities do, as well.

It's not futile to go after rapists and murderers. Locking them up prevents further crime. There is no gigantic self-repairing infrastructure for rape and murder. This means it is actually possible to decrease the frequency of these crimes by eliminating their perpetrators. These are not large segments of society we're talking about policing, they are handfuls of individuals without any particular connection between one another.

On top of that, there is no regulating rape and murder. Legalization won't take it off the black market or designate specific recipients. It's not really the same at all. I picked pot and piracy because they're two relatively unique legal situations that are relevant to my point, whereas most other subjects are unrelated.

SilverClock

I am a sexy bitch!
[FLASH=http://files.myfrogbag.com/02rm0o/bestpixelpalz2.swf]http://files.myfrogbag.com/02rm0o/bestpixelpalz2.swf width=250 height=200 wmode=transparent[/FLASH]
!!![/COLOR]BRAND-SPANKIN\' OLD SNIGGLEBOOTS FLASH!WATCH IT TODAY!!!!

RomanClock

Quote from: AlbinoClock;1531879It's not futile to go after rapists and murderers. Locking them up prevents further crime. There is no gigantic self-repairing infrastructure for rape and murder. This means it is actually possible to decrease the frequency of these crimes by eliminating their perpetrators.

Um......yea, there will always be rapists and murderers, and locking them up does decrease occurances, but its the same way with anything illegal. If we make rape/murder legal, there will be more of it.
Now, if we punish people who do drugs, clearly the number of incidences will decrease. And if such drugs become legal, obviously the number will increase.

So I'm not sure where you are going with this "futile" defeatist attitude.
lemayo lol :soups:

SilverClock

Roman just says the same thing over and over. :(



ps. Anyone notice the band members of Good Charlotte are getting really fat? Must be all that money off shit songs and merch.
I am a sexy bitch!
[FLASH=http://files.myfrogbag.com/02rm0o/bestpixelpalz2.swf]http://files.myfrogbag.com/02rm0o/bestpixelpalz2.swf width=250 height=200 wmode=transparent[/FLASH]
!!![/COLOR]BRAND-SPANKIN\' OLD SNIGGLEBOOTS FLASH!WATCH IT TODAY!!!!

AlbinoClock

Quote from: RomanClock;1534159Um......yea, there will always be rapists and murderers, and locking them up does decrease occurances, but its the same way with anything illegal. If we make rape/murder legal, there will be more of it.
Now, if we punish people who do drugs, clearly the number of incidences will decrease. And if such drugs become legal, obviously the number will increase.

So I'm not sure where you are going with this "futile" defeatist attitude.

See, that's the thing, the number of incidences hasn't decreased. If anything, pot has gained ground since the 80s. Hell, I've been arrested for pot before, it didn't stop me from smoking. Most of the people I know who smoke have been arrested for it at one time or another, we just learned to lay low after that. If you think the war on pot is being won,  go watch Marijuana Inc.

Look back to prohibition, did it decrease the amount of alcohol consumed? Perhaps slightly, but in return it fed the black market and criminalized droves of innocent people. It wasn't feasible. Eventually it had to come to an end, and so will this. It's just a matter of how long those in power insist on denying the reality of the situation and abusing their power.

Maltese

Quote from: SilverClock;1534232Roman just says the same thing over and over. :(

it's because he believes it's impossible for him to be wrong.