News:

If you need instructions on how to get through the hotels, check out the enclosed instruction book.

Main Menu

anselm's ontological argument

Farted by SirClock, April 13, 2009, 01:34:22 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

SirClock

Some of you may be familiar with the argument, which came about in the year 1000. An ontological argument is an argument for the existance of God. I like this argument in particular because it is so logical and simple, however there might be a mistake with it if you can find it out. So if you beleive in God, let this perhaps just be a simple reassurance.

If you don't believe in God, you should be able to point out a logical mistake. For surely one can not be in denial of this arguments conclusion without finding a problem with the argument itself!

  • One can conceptualize 'that, than which none greater can be conceived', "X"
  • Concepts exist as ideas, as mental constructs.
  • Some ideas refer to existents, others have no existing referent (existing only in understanding)
  • "X", as a concept exists as a mental construct
  • If "X" exists as only a mental construct, then it would have no existing referent.
  • If "X" has no existing referent, then it is less great than if it had an existing referent.
  • By definition, "X", if it has no existing referent, can not be 'that, than which none greater can be conceived' (as it would not meet its own definition)
  • Therefore, "X" must have an existing referent if it is to be comprehensible
  • From 1, "X" is comprehensible.
  • Therefore, "X" must have an existing referent (X exists)

Slurpee

it doesn't explicitly state it, but argument 7 assumes "if something is 'that, than which none greater can be conceived', it must default to the greater option in any binary situation." so I guess I disagree with the seventh argument, on the grounds that I only agreed with the first argument on the underlying pretense that two given "greatest" natures can be contradictory of each other, and something which nothing could be conceived of that would be greater could fall within those limits and still have nothing that could possibly be greater.

who came up with this shit I bet it was some greek douche like that asshole that postulated that it's impossible to go anywhere ever. wait was he greek? I think he was. all old dead philosopher greeks are douchebags.

Whipped Cream

Its foolish to think we can conceptualize something that no greater than be conceived.

SirClock

Quote from: Whipped Cream;1560216Its foolish to think we can conceptualize something that no greater than be conceived.
No, you can't really argue that it can't be concepted merely that the concept may not have any existing referent.

It can be concepted because its seemingly infinite. But infinity can be concepted.
See:

Lets say a delicious ham dinner is something none greater can be conceived...
now lets say its a better ham dinner...
now lets say its a ham dinner with fries...
now lets say it comes with desert...

We can just conceptually keep doing this until we've reached none greater than one can be conceived. So it can definitely exist as concept, but it may or may not have an existing referent.

Quote from: Slurpee;1560010who came up with this shit I bet it was some greek douche like that asshole that postulated that it's impossible to go anywhere ever. wait was he greek? I think he was. all old dead philosopher greeks are douchebags.
Owch I must say that stings a little. I idolize Plato and Socrates.

Everyone in their age felt the same as you about them though.

Marlin Clock

Quote from: Slurpee;1560010who came up with this shit I bet it was some greek douche like that asshole that postulated that it's impossible to go anywhere ever. wait was he greek? I think he was. all old dead philosopher greeks are douchebags.
Yeah, Zeno, but he got beat by arithmetic. If you go 1mps and keep halving it, 1/2mp1/2s+1/4mp1/4s+1/8mp1/8s...=1mps

Added together, it's infinite distance divided by infinite time, which will equal one.

RomanClock

So what its saying is that since we can imagine the concept of god, it must exist?
lemayo lol :soups:

SirClock

Quote from: Franklin G. Hamilton;1560308I can logically disagree with this.

What defines what the greatest concept is? Is it one single thing, or is it a combination of things? Whatever you answer, its easy to dispute what you would consider as the greatest, because not everyone is going to agree.
This is not the issue here because whether or not its "easy to dispute what one would consider as the greatest" conceptually it is real and logically it is possible. If we did take the time to keep thinking of things greater then the last thought eventually we'd have to come to that which none greater can be conceived, logically thats real. Yes it would have to be a single thing because it'd have to be the thing greater than all other things. Whether or not you believe it to be God and existing in reality is really up to you.
Quote from: RomanClock;1560324So what its saying is that since we can imagine the concept of god, it must exist?
Right, this is more along the lines of whats flawed about it. It suggests that by definition if we thought up of X (the greatest possible thing) that X would have exist in order for it to be greater than just the concept. But yes, thats the real mistake. Just because the definition of X must  work in concept, still doesn't mean it must have a existing referent.

SirClock

Quote from: Franklin G. Hamilton;1560342If the basis of the argument is that its logically possible, then the argument is useless. There are logical arguments for and against the existance of a god, and they are all pretty much useless as they all rely on the pre-existing belief or non-belief in god.

Unless you're presenting an absolute proof, then you're not going to gain any ground on anyone else's arguments.
No.

The basis of the argument is not that its logical possible, the basis is that the concept is logically possible. The conclusion is that its logically possible and existing.

Logical arguments never by definition rely on pre-existing belief. That idea is absurd. The entire point of using logical arguments is to get around belief.

Furthermore, logic is proof. This specific argument is flawed, as I pointed out from the beginning, so its not the best example. But if we did find a logical argument that we could not disprove, then we would assume it to be proven. And so how wouldn't you be gaining ground?

RomanClock

Can you disprove my opinion that God exists?
lemayo lol :soups:

Marlin Clock

But something that doesn't exist cannot have conscious actions, because for something to make actions it must exist to make said actions. If a god creates the world, then he could not be non-existant, for it has made an action.
He thinks, therefore He is.

Unless you were just showing the Atheist equivalent of the Ontological Argument.

Loki Clock

It's not that the argument is flawed, it's that it may be vacuously true, and there's no way of knowing it. It relies on our concept referring to a real X.

AMPEEEM

Quote from: RomanClock;1560655Can you disprove my opinion that God exists?

God is a vague term, narrow it down.

AlbinoClock

Quote from: CadillacClock;1560598An example of the Ontological Argument designed to support Atheism:

1. The creation of the world is the most marvellous achievement imaginable.

A fairly meaningless statement. Marvelous is a concept based out of human ignorance. If it were not for our inability to see the future, I suspect we'd find everything far less exciting.  

 
Quote2. The merit of an achievement is the product of (a) its intrinsic quality,and (b) the ability of its creator.

   3. The greater the disability (or handicap) of the creator, the more impressive the achievement.

Merit is, again, conceptual, but the statement in 2 is close enough to true and relevant as makes no ends. 3, however, is completely subjective. It arises from not knowing whether achievement will occur, as do all things involving likelihood. In reality, the strongest is he who is strongest, not he who appears strongest.  

The rest of this is foolishness based on these previous assumptions.

Anslem's argument is even more absurd. Literal external objects, assuming the existence of an external reality, do not "exist in understanding", they are reflected in understanding.

QuoteAn apologist would have to disagree to this as well. God, as it has always been, is beyond our understanding. Hence, the necessity of faith. If we are beneath God in understanding than it is in error to attempt to understand Him.

Not the Gnostic apologist. Faith is a misunderstood power over reality. As for understanding God, God does nothing but express his being and nature perpetually. Admittedly we're a bit distracted from it by psychological turmoil so it can be tough to notice but it's really written as plain as day in front of your face constantly.


Here's my ontological argument:

1. Multiple observers exist in the universe.

2. Activity in the universe is dictated by physical laws of causality.

3. Observers participate in activities within the universe.

4. All observers share a root of consciousness which dictates the physical laws of the universe.

5. We are God.

Alternately, if you prefer solipsism

1. Only I perceive

2. External phenomena are illusory.

3. I am God

Marlin Clock

Quote from: AlbinoClock;1602217Here's my ontological argument:

1. Multiple observers exist in the universe.

2. Activity in the universe is dictated by physical laws of causality.

3. Observers participate in activities within the universe.

4. All observers share a root of consciousness which dictates the physical laws of the universe.

5. We are God.
What kind of argument is this? It builds premises and then postulates a conclusion without explaining how it links to its premises.

Fire Extinguisher Clock

GUYS SINCE WE ARE CLOKC CREW ALL ARE VARIABLES MUST BE THE LETTER B.

AlbinoClock

Quote from: Marlix Wright;1602310What kind of argument is this? It builds premises and then postulates a conclusion without explaining how it links to its premises.

Quote1. Multiple observers exist in the universe.

If you contest this, see the solipsistic argument.

Quote2. Activity in the universe is dictated by physical laws of causality.

Something tells me this isn't the bit you're trying to contest either.

Quote3. Observers participate in activities within the universe.

I suppose this could be false, but I sure feel like I'm typing this. Any disagreement with this implies strict determinism anyway.


Quote4. All observers share a root of consciousness which dictates the physical laws of the universe.

Observers cannot act in defiance of physical law, and yet they act. This means that their actions have a common origin, that being the very laws that dictate activity within the universe.

Quote5. We are God

If we actually have the ability to influence our actions, we are influencing the physical laws of the universe. Because of the common origin of chains of causality, any power over reality is omnipotence, as it is power over all of reality.

SirClock

Quote from: AlbinoClock;1602397If we actually have the ability to influence our actions, we are influencing the physical laws of the universe. Because of the common origin of chains of causality, any power over reality is omnipotence, as it is power over all of reality.
I think a common misconception (not that you may have made it) is that something that is omniscient and omnipresent must be omnipotent.

Even if we say God is the most powerful thing possible, that does not mean all-powerful.

It seems apparent to me, at least in this universe, that much is limited to its own nature, what we know as the laws of causality, relativity, newton's law, karma.

The omnipotence you suggest in the "common origin" I think is quite true. The common origin commonly being called 'nothing' (which pre-exists all else) possesses the potential for everything, and in that way may be considered omnipotence. However, that state is not our universe, it was what is beyond our universe, beyond the laws of duality and into the One. This is why if God appears in this universe, it must be in both states at the same time (or as Buddha said, vibrating between the two faster than light and thought) and in this way cannot actually be strictly omnipotent.

I believe in a completely deterministic universe, and yet our "free-will" isn't our actions (which is always an outcome of causality) but rather our ability to transcend and return to what exists truer and before law itself.

AlbinoClock

Quote from: SirClock;1603231I think a common misconception (not that you may have made it) is that something that is omniscient and omnipresent must be omnipotent.

Even if we say God is the most powerful thing possible, that does not mean all-powerful.

It seems apparent to me, at least in this universe, that much is limited to its own nature, what we know as the laws of causality, relativity, newton's law, karma.

The omnipotence you suggest in the "common origin" I think is quite true. The common origin commonly being called 'nothing' (which pre-exists all else) possesses the potential for everything, and in that way may be considered omnipotence. However, that state is not our universe, it was what is beyond our universe, beyond the laws of duality and into the One. This is why if God appears in this universe, it must be in both states at the same time (or as Buddha said, vibrating between the two faster than light and thought) and in this way cannot actually be strictly omnipotent.

I believe in a completely deterministic universe, and yet our "free-will" isn't our actions (which is always an outcome of causality) but rather our ability to transcend and return to what exists truer and before law itself.

Ah, but that duality is a false one, an apparent subset of laws created by the higher laws of, as you put it, common origin. Like a rules card in Fluxx as opposed to the base rules about card interaction.