News:

If you need instructions on how to get through the hotels, check out the enclosed instruction book.

Main Menu

This episode of South Park is I'm a edgy teen

Farted by F U Clock, July 01, 2009, 08:50:47 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

F U Clock

I'm going to make another semi-serious thread, forgive me.

I hate this episode of South Park, playing right now. The long and short of it is that they make fun of Alcoholics Anonymous for telling people that alcoholism is a disease, because that causes people to just accept it and not do anything about it.

However, if Trey Parker or Matt Stone (or whoever writes this damned show anymore) actually knew what they were talking about, they'd know that AA has saved a lot of people's lives, and that without it there'd be a lot of fatherless (and, Hell, motherless) kids out there. They also say it's not a disease. Despite it being hereditarily linked, physically dependent, and medically proven to KILL some people if they stop drinking cold turkey.

Oh yeah, and they just had the scene where Stan's dad's such an asshole 'cause he compares his alcoholism to some guy's cancer or whatever and it's like, yeah what an asshole comparing his non-disease to life-threatening cancer oh wait my fucking dad died of liver cirrhosis due to his alcoholism I forgot.

[/rant]

AnkhClock




F U Clock

Quote from: AnkhClock;1610260South Park is I'm a edgy teen

Yes, but I figured I'd be opening up a can of worms I wasn't prepared for if I said this.

TremcladClock

That's such an old episode.
Quote from: AnkhClock;1610260South Park is I'm a edgy teen
This too.

Being offended by stuff like this is douchey.


AMPEEEM

Ah, lame, sounds stupid. There has been times where an episode of South Park just totally make me shake my head.

In one episode Stan says "I learned its wrong to eat baby cows, but I also learned if you stop eating meat all together you turn into a huge pussy," While thats funny, and I guess thats the only real point, I was still turned off. It was just an extremely unwell thought out thing to say.

F U Clock

Quote from: You ever notice;1610269Ah, lame, sounds stupid. There has been times where an episode of South Park just totally make me shake my head.

In one episode Stan says "I learned its wrong to eat baby cows, but I also learned if you stop eating meat all together you turn into a huge pussy," While thats funny, and I guess thats the only real point, I was still turned off. It was just an extremely unwell thought out thing to say.

I guess my issue with South Park in general is that these days all they do is find one or two jokes, and then recite that same joke over and over throughout the episode. And yeah, the fact that they feel compelled to throw in some preachy-bullshit that's usually half-true and way too focused on how "gay" stuff is.

RomanClock

Quote from: AnkhClock;1610260South Park is unfathomably I'm a edgy teen

mmm
lemayo lol :soups:

AMPEEEM

Quote from: FunnyUncleClock;1610270I guess my issue with South Park in general is that these days all they do is find one or two jokes, and then recite that same joke over and over throughout the episode. And yeah, the fact that they feel compelled to throw in some preachy-bullshit that's usually half-true and way too focused on how "gay" stuff is.

Oh dude, totally. Honestly Trey and Matt are trying too hard to be social commentators. Honestly, I just find them to be a little bit too macho for their own good.

I like some episodes, the one about the lice who live on the kid's head was really nice, I thought, and it actually had me coming around.

(for those who don't know its a comment on the ignorance of men who ignore the fact that Earth is a living thing and we are directly connected to it and it's most natural cycles)

I think they were growing up and when they make a mistake they are just uneducated. I doubt that fame has not compensated some of their good judgment.

DNAClock

"Bloody Mary" Good episode. Funny take on AA and bleeding statues.
NO YOUTUBE IN SIGNATURES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Munglai

my issue is that they've taken to doing almost exactly the same plot every single episode. the one where something small happens and everyone makes a big deal out of it but then it turns out it actually is a big deal for a serious government conspiracy kind of reason but ultimately the kids learn a lesson about the small issue that started the drama in the first place.

it got really bad around the time they did that cloverfield spoof and the highschool musical episode. I literally couldn't watch any of those episodes all the way through because the pattern was so obvious.

they did a pretty good job of fixing that in the last batch though, as well as keeping away from shamelessly political/contemporary stuff so I'm hopeful now.

F U Clock

Quote from: DNAClock;1610278"Bloody Mary" Good episode. Funny take on AA and bleeding statues.

I disagree, for reasons stated.

And yeah, that Cloverfield episode was dreeeadful with the joke repetition.

Odo

It's a cartoon, so it's fine if you treat it as such.
╔══════════════ ೋáÆ'¦â˜Æ'áÆ'¦à³‹ ══════════════â•â€"
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ Repost this if ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ you are a beautiful strong black woman ~ ~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ who donââ,¬â,,¢t need no man ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
╚══════════════ ೋáÆ'¦â˜Æ'áÆ'¦à³‹ ══════════════╝


Marlin Clock

I've always despised the show for obvious reasons. I've come to detest people whos humor is based solely on insulting other people.

AbsintheClock

Southpark is just grasping at straws because they're out of any half decent ideas. Kind of like the Simpsons but without any real morals behind the production.

F U Clock

Quote from: LEMMY;1610286It's a cartoon, so it's fine if you treat it as such.

I know, right? I normally don't jump on a TV show for having backwards opinions, but I guess this particular issue personally affects me, and I just know there's tons of frat boys out there going, "Yeah, alcoholism is bullshit! Let's drink until we diiie."

Munglai

Quote from: AbsintheClock;1610290Southpark is just grasping at straws because they're out of any half decent ideas. Kind of like the Simpsons but without any real morals behind the production.

good thing South Park didn't spend years setting all their characters up as beautifully well rounded people or I'd probably hate the new writing as much as the stuff the Simpsons is doing now

Odo

Quote from: Munglai;1610293good thing South Park didn't spend years setting all their characters up as beautifully well rounded people or I'd probably hate the new writing as much as the stuff the Simpsons is doing now
After seeing the Simpsons' movie I think their writers have either stopped trying or are trying too hard to grab that Family Guy (SOOO RANDOM XD) demographic.

It's torture.
╔══════════════ ೋáÆ'¦â˜Æ'áÆ'¦à³‹ ══════════════â•â€"
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ Repost this if ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ you are a beautiful strong black woman ~ ~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ who donââ,¬â,,¢t need no man ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
╚══════════════ ೋáÆ'¦â˜Æ'áÆ'¦à³‹ ══════════════╝


Munglai

Quote from: LEMMY;1610295After seeing the Simpsons' movie I think their writers have either stopped trying or are trying too hard to grab that Family Guy (SOOO RANDOM XD) demographic.

It's torture.

It's only torturous because they did such a good job before they all turned into pricks. I know these characters and I know what they would and wouldn't do. They can't even get away with turning the extras into cheap gag characters because they fleshed them out so well. Even seeing someone as minor as Otto or Milhouse's dad get strung about like a retard puppet makes me want to cry.

fuck the Simpsons was so so good

they really should have stopped while they were winning

DNAClock

Quote from: LEMMY;1610286It's a cartoon, so it's fine if you treat it as such.

Exactly.

Plus, south park's take on alcoholism isn't exactly wrong. You see... alcoholism, itself is a disorder, not a disease. Cirrhosis is a disease, a state of intoxication due to excessive consumption of alcohol is a disease, hepatitis is a disease, a health complication due to chronic consumption of alcohol is a disease. Alcoholism? I'm sorry I don't see that word on any of my psychiatry books, wait I do see it in one... oh it says "go to alcohol disorders". I DO see "disorders related to alcohol intake" which sounds like bullshit but there's a reason to call it that and not alcoholism.

Also... did you knew that the most used criteria to diagnose alcohol abuse comes from the DSM-IV? I got it, it's very useful, psychiatrists across all over the world are being trained  from knowledge of that book, the same book that used to call homosexuality a disease. It's amazing really, one day you were sick if you liked guys and there even was diagnosis tools and treatment! Next day (when the 4th edition came out) you weren't diseased... you just liked guys, no shit, that's how irrelevant this piece of literature can be, especially if you are not a psychiatrist that doesn't KNOW how to use it and interpret it.

Did you know that there's caffeine related disorders on that same book? You know that they are taking that out for the 5th edition? Yeah just like that... in a few years when we are able to buy DSM-V there will be a whole lotta less disease from caffeine, what do you guys think about that?

And that's a little problem with psychiatry (don't worry psychiatrists are aware, that's why they know HOW to use the DSM and the ICD) the problem is that these books, these texts are just a construct: that means that a bunch of guys and girls that knew about this stuff joined one day to simplify the diagnosis of psychatric disorders and thanks to their clinical experience and a whole bunch of clinical trials and studies they synthetized the diagnosis of all disorders into a bunch of pages (in most cases less than a fucking page). They made a diagnosis guide out of the most common stuff, but not everybody fits in their criteria.

Same goes for "alcoholism". Not everybody fits in their criteria... not everybody needs AA, which btw, is not THE option all the times to deal with alcohol abuse. But it's complicated, not easy to understand, so:

TL;DR

Alcohol abuse is complicated, the south park guys are not necessarily wrong, it's ok to be mad at them but they are just doing cartoons, so chill.
NO YOUTUBE IN SIGNATURES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Loki Clock

Quote from: DNAClock;1610301Also... did you knew

No, I did not infinitive!