News:

If you need instructions on how to get through the hotels, check out the enclosed instruction book.

Main Menu

butthurt iowan lawmakers actively seeking to endanger gay and transgender students

Farted by Slurpee, February 10, 2010, 12:14:29 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

Kaijuclock

Quote from: AbsintheClock;1729138I think if somebody wants to call a gay person a sodomite, faggot, or whatever that's fine. They're probably a dick and they'll get what's coming to them.

Eh, Really depends in what context it is in. I've been called these things in a hateful way before for no reason except the person is a dick.

AbsintheClock

Well there's always going to be people like that. I'm sure if you asked any black person if they've ever been called a ¥¥¥¥¥¥ before they'll probably say yes. Does that mean everyone who says ¥¥¥¥¥¥ should be put on criminal charges? The one problem with law is you can't legislate common decency. Well you can but it's seldom ever successful and it's often expensive.

On top of that, I'd like to see more education based on teaching kids how to deal with bullies verbally in a real world situation. This would not only build more confidence in kids, but it will also expose bullies for what they are. Angry people with small dicks and big egos.

BinaryClock

Quote from: BlackberryClock;1729134I like the idea of trying to influence people to stop being prejudiced, but I don't want the one doing it to be the government.

Well, since I'm pretty sure that the jury has to be unanimous when deciding whether the defendant is guilty of a charge or not, juries still have the option of deciding that a crime was committed, but not motivated by race, sexuality etc.

But yeah, a difficult situation to be sure.



I don't want to jinx anything but is this a reasonable debate in Plato's Playground? Take that MarlinClock! still love you man

BinaryClock, if you wanna play uno type !unohelp to see how to

BlackberryClock

To clarify my point about not wanting the government to "decide": not only do I not want the government to decide on what is right or wrong to think, it just isn't the place for government to ever be--I don't want it anywhere near this topic. I like what Absinthe said in this regard: you can't legislate common decency. Nor should you try, and nor is it the place of government.

It is my principle that I do not want the dichotomy between criminal acts and free speech (and thought) to be muddied with a hybrid category that is hate crime.

Marlin Clock

This is in a different context though, isn't it? Blackberry isn't arguing that removing protection from bullies for homosexuals is a good thing, he's arguing that hate crime in general is an overexertion of the law.

Schools don't strictly operate under the exact same law of the government anyway, the school basically makes its own law within reason, so the hatecrime discussion is a bit separated.


E: I never said we could never have a reasonable debate on all matters anyway.