News:

If you need instructions on how to get through the hotels, check out the enclosed instruction book.

Main Menu

The Flower - A wonderful short animation

Farted by EnglishClock, August 01, 2010, 01:34:31 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

EnglishClock

[SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]

Loki Clock


Flounderpa

nice, I hate how this is supposed to be an argument about marijuana legalization, but I did enjoyed it
ââ€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"¬à®Å"Û©ÛžÛ©à®Å"ââ€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"¬
SHUTãâ,¬â,¬Ã¯Â¼ÂµÃ¯Â¼Â°Ã£â,¬â,¬Ã¯Â¼Â¡Ã¯Â¼Â®Ã¯Â¼Â¤Ã£â,¬â,¬Ã¯Â¼Â¥Ã¯Â¼Â®Ã¯Â¼ÂªÃ¯Â¼Â¯Ã¯Â¼Â¹Ã£â,¬â,¬Ã¯Â¼Â´Ã¯Â¼Â¨Ã¯Â¼Â¥Ã£â,¬â,¬Ã¯Â¼Â­Ã¯Â¼ÂµÃ¯Â¼Â³Ã¯Â¼Â©Ã¯Â¼Â£Ã¯Â¼Â
ââ€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"¬à®Å"Û©ÛžÛ©à®Å"ââ€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"¬

EnglishClock

Quote from: Hazard Clock;1773755nice, I hate how this is supposed to be an argument about marijuana legalization, but I did enjoyed it

It is... it's quite creatively showing the real negative effects of marijuana prohibition. It's not saying "if u dont like weed ur evil", it's demonstrating that the practically non-existant health issues associated with a plant are nothing in comparison to the current situation we have with prohibition (and the hypocrisy of alcohol and tobacco being "ok")
[SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]

buttplug

Well it was all very exaggerated. I could tell very quickly that it was going to be about pot.
Quote from: Hazard Clock;1773755I hate how this is supposed to be an argument about marijuana legalization

Why do you hate it? I mean you have Carl Sagan in your signature ffs. It's just an idea you don't have to be threatened by it.
Quote from: EnglishClock;1773758it's demonstrating that the practically non-existant health issues associated with a plant are nothing in comparison to the current situation we have with prohibition (and the hypocrisy of alcohol and tobacco being "ok")
That's the part I agree with. What I don't like is how the effects of pot are always grossly overstated on both sides of the argument. It isn't going to cause world peace and allow us to build more schools, and it also isn't going to turn your kids into gansters and turn them into strung out junkies. It's just a plant that makes you feel happy and content.

People are stupid and I want to punch them.

RobClock

Brilliant animation. absolutely brilliant. I love it.

Flounderpa

Quote from: Bulba;1773761Why do you hate it?
Because I didn't want the animation to become an argument
ââ€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"¬à®Å"Û©ÛžÛ©à®Å"ââ€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"¬
SHUTãâ,¬â,¬Ã¯Â¼ÂµÃ¯Â¼Â°Ã£â,¬â,¬Ã¯Â¼Â¡Ã¯Â¼Â®Ã¯Â¼Â¤Ã£â,¬â,¬Ã¯Â¼Â¥Ã¯Â¼Â®Ã¯Â¼ÂªÃ¯Â¼Â¯Ã¯Â¼Â¹Ã£â,¬â,¬Ã¯Â¼Â´Ã¯Â¼Â¨Ã¯Â¼Â¥Ã£â,¬â,¬Ã¯Â¼Â­Ã¯Â¼ÂµÃ¯Â¼Â³Ã¯Â¼Â©Ã¯Â¼Â£Ã¯Â¼Â
ââ€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"¬à®Å"Û©ÛžÛ©à®Å"ââ€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"‰â€"¬

Munglai

Quote from: EnglishClock;1773758It is... it's quite creatively showing the real negative effects of marijuana prohibition. It's not saying "if u dont like weed ur evil", it's demonstrating that the practically non-existant health issues associated with a plant are nothing in comparison to the current situation we have with prohibition (and the hypocrisy of alcohol and tobacco being "ok")

It's not creative at all man, it's an extremely biased argument wrapped up in extremely obvious symbolism. Oh no, the thing I don't like has happened, everything's black and white now! Oh hey I know I'll draw a comparison between the badguys and the Nazis that'll convince people!

The film itself wasn't bad but I don't see how anyone can expect to make a difference with something so transparent.

EnglishClock

Quote from: Bulba;1773761I could tell very quickly that it was going to be about pot.

same here :rolleyes:


Quote from: Bulba;1773761That's the part I agree with. What I don't like is how the effects of pot are always grossly overstated on both sides of the argument. It isn't going to cause world peace and allow us to build more schools, and it also isn't going to turn your kids into gansters and turn them into strung out junkies. It's just a plant that makes you feel happy and content.

People are stupid and I want to punch them.

True that, both sides can be responsible for stretching the truth at times (some sides more than others), but I don't really think this flash was meant to connote "world peace" being made when they found the flowers. It showed people being happy, relaxing in a social setting and talking, aswell money being made from a tax. Pot does make you do those things, and if marijuana were to be legalized, it would bring in billions and billions of revenue each year. New schools would be built... among other things.
[SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]

buttplug

Quote from: EnglishClock;1773767True that, both sides can be responsible for stretching the truth at times (some sides more than others), but I don't really think this flash was meant to connote "world peace" being made when they found the flowers. It showed people being happy, relaxing in a social setting and talking, aswell money being made from a tax. Pot does make you do those things, and if marijuana were to be legalized, it would bring in billions and billions of revenue each year. New schools would be built... among other things.

It still grossly overstated the negative effects of pot prohibition. I mean for the most part the government cracks down on people moving large quantities of the stuff, not some dude sitting on his stoop smoking a joint (or flower or whatever). People killing each other over drugs are part of a bigger problem, not just pot being illegal.

EnglishClock

Quote from: Munglai;1773766It's not creative at all man, it's an extremely biased argument wrapped up in extremely obvious symbolism. Oh no, the thing I don't like has happened, everything's black and white now! Oh hey I know I'll draw a comparison between the badguys and the Nazis that'll convince people!

The film itself wasn't bad but I don't see how anyone can expect to make a difference with something so transparent.

Thing is, despite the general safety of the plant being obvious and common knowledge to a huge amount of people today, there are still many people that genuinely believe marijuana is evil. The symbolism may seem extremely obvious to you, and that's because it is, but there are millions who do not see how marijuana being illegal is more damaging to society than legal. The simplicity is for the sake of getting the message across to the ill informed.

Honestly, I didn't think it was a comparison to nazism when the bad guys showed up and locked people away for using a plant, it's just what actually does happen.


Quote from: Bulba;1773769It still grossly overstated the negative effects of pot prohibition. I mean for the most part the government cracks down on people moving large quantities of the stuff, not some dude sitting on his stoop smoking a joint (or flower or whatever).

The fact that the police may mainly focus on dealers is besides the point. Sitting on a stoop smoking a joint is something that you can get arrested for. Thousands of people get arrested every day for posession.


Quote from: Bulba;1773769People killing each other over drugs are part of a bigger problem, not just pot being illegal.

I agree - drug prohibition as a whole doesn't work. But that's almost a whole different can of tomatoes...

(by the way, marijuana accounts for the largest amount of profit made by the mexican drug cartels, and we all are aware of the violence associated with them)
[SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]

Munglai

Quote from: EnglishClock;1773771Thing is, despite the general safety of the plant being obvious and common knowledge to a huge amount of people today, there are still many people that genuinely believe marijuana is evil. The symbolism may seem extremely obvious to you, and that's because it is, but there are millions who do not see how marijuana being illegal is more damaging to society than legal. The simplicity is for the sake of getting the message across to the ill informed.

Honestly, I didn't think it was a comparison to nazism when the bad guys showed up and locked people away for using a plant, it's just what actually does happen.

But telling people they're wrong by demonising their beliefs or the things they like (they made alcohol look pretty evil here) doesn't work. This kind of stuff only rallies people who are already believe it because it isn't providing any proof or anything to think about, it's just telling you to think what they think.

Also the bit with the tank was totally a nazi reference.

RobClock

Quote from: Munglai;1773773Also the bit with the tank was totally a nazi reference.
Yeah, that was pretty blatant.

EnglishClock

#13
Quote from: Munglai;1773773But telling people they're wrong by demonising their beliefs or the things they like (they made alcohol look pretty evil here) doesn't work. This kind of stuff only rallies people who are already believe it because it isn't providing any proof or anything to think about, it's just telling you to think what they think.

OK, this I can agree with. Of course I don't think alcohol should be illegal either, and it's wrong to make the portrayal that people who drink alcohol are consistently clumsy and ill-mannered, but how else could they make a comparison between the two effects? Medically, scientifically, (legal) alcohol causes much much more damage than (illegal) marijuana, this is a fact that needs mentioning when debating the prohibition.

They didn't show hundreds of thousands of people dying annually from alcohol related problems, a real phenomenom, so I don't really think they were stepping over the line when they showed drunk people being clumsy and looking ill. It's kind of difficult to make a "factual" comparison with this kind of thing really, but you are right, they could've come up with a more accurate and fair representation of alcohol, but again it's just awfully difficult to not demonize something that is much worse than what it's being compared to.


You say this kind of thing doesn't convince people because it doesn't provide proof... how exactly do you provide "proof" without shoving a scientific document or article in somebody's face? All the data and facts already exist. We can't "prove" it anymore than it has been proven. There's no excuse for ignorance of this kind of thing today, the information is there.

Funnily enough, anti-drug folks aren't actively searching for proof of something they already believe to be false. That goes for neutral people, too, who might have been swayed by the consistent lies and have abstained/ignored anything to do with drugs. The more the truth is told, the better. This kind of thing is just spreading a message of knowledge which already exists.

Aside from that yeah it's a pretty fun animation.
[SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]

Munglai

Quote from: EnglishClock;1773781OK, this I can agree with. Of course I don't think alcohol should be illegal either, and it's wrong to make the portrayal that people who drink alcohol are consistently clumsy and ill-mannered, but how else could they make a comparison between the two effects? Medically, scientifically, (legal) alcohol causes much much more damage than (illegal) marijuana, this is a fact that needs mentioning when debating the prohibition.

They didn't show hundreds of thousands of people dying annually from alcohol related problems, a real phenomenom, so I don't really think they were stepping over the line when they showed drunk people being clumsy and looking ill. It's kind of difficult to make a "factual" comparison with this kind of thing really, but you are right, they could've come up with a more accurate and fair representation of alcohol, but again it's just awfully difficult to not demonize something that is much worse than what it's being compared to.


You say this kind of thing doesn't convince people because it doesn't provide proof... how exactly do you provide "proof" without shoving a scientific document or article in somebody's face? All the data and facts already exist. We can't "prove" it anymore than it has been proven. There's no excuse for ignorance of this kind of thing today, the information is there.

Funnily enough, anti-drug folks aren't actively searching for proof of something they already believe to be false. That goes for neutral people, too, who might have been swayed by the consistent lies and have abstained/ignored anything to do with drugs. The more the truth is told, the better. This kind of thing is just spreading a message of knowledge which already exists.

Aside from that yeah it's a pretty fun animation.

It doesn't convince people because it's so obviously biased. It presents the world as being 100% good when flowers/marijuana er legal and 100% bad when they aren't. When you make a film you have to be aware of the doubts that audiences are going to bring with them and either explain them away or acknowledge them to keep the audience on your side. If you're doing something factual, obviously you have to do this a lot more.

As far as proof goes, basically if you're making something this direct you really need to be chucking some facts around. There's ways to get those facts across without just waving them in the audience's face - analogies, comedy, motion graphics etc. - and if they're handled properly they can be more enjoyable than fiction because people really do enjoy learning things they don't know as long as you don't patronise them.

If you want to make something vague and floaty like this you have to get a lot further away from the issue. You can't be broad with your message if you're not also broad with your approach. The wishy-washiness of the message here combined with the obvious close parallels with real life just makes the film maker come off as a guy who doesn't really understand the issue or doesn't take it seriously.

I'm not at all against the things the film promotes I just think it does it in a pretty childish way.

edit: also why was alcohol shown at all? Marijuana gets a nice, friendly analogy, why doesn't alcohol?

EnglishClock

Yeah it really is very watered down, basic, and overly "cutesy". I agree there would've been much better ways to convey the precise message that didn't seem as though it was intended for a child, and there's obviously many other existing things that educate people a lot better than this did. I guess this kind of thing just doesn't work well when trying to represent such a serious issue from real life, and for it work 100% properly needs more depth, structure, factual education, etc.
[SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]

AC Slater

Drugs are silly. That's all I have to say about that nonsense.

But the animation was good.

Loki Clock

What Munglai's talking about is my problem with most legalization activism. No one seems to be having an honest discussion, just vomiting emotions against the wall. So the only way people in the middle get anywhere is by trying it themselves.