News:

If you need instructions on how to get through the hotels, check out the enclosed instruction book.

Main Menu

Superman renounces American citizenship in Action Comics #900

Farted by miracle fruit, April 29, 2011, 11:37:32 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

miracle fruit

i like how jimmyjimmyjimmy capitalizes 'Solution' like its the final solution or something

GearBoxClock

Wasn't Superman created by a Canadian?

[U2]D9GYWbhBoHM[/U2]

miracle fruit

Quote from: Ram.;1818312Wasn't Superman created by a Canadian?

co-created, shuster (canadian) drew superman and siegel (american) wrote the character

edit: either way hes a kryptonian anyway so i dont see why this citizenship thing is such a massive ordeal

then again im not an american values preaching bigot like these wonderful people on fox

NintendrCkolc

Quote from: CadillacClock;1818301FOX News readers take the news badly,

A bunch of right wing conservative news outlets (Like Drudge for instance) have been passing around the story as if it's some sort of sinister liberal plot.

Slurpee

1) World-famous superpowered free agent realizes his American citizenship presents him a representative of the 'States to foreign authorities.
2) He cannot in good conscience knowingly represent his home country on the world stage.
3) He cannot in good conscience act only when it's politic to do so.
4) Ergo, he renounces his citizenship.
5) [extremely important information available only to readers of Fox News]
6) Somebody is trying to say America sucks >=O!!!!!

It's the same type of reasoning that leads from
1) Opposing political party thinks I'm an insane idiot
2) So does the rest of the world
to
47) THEY ARE IN A SECRET CABAL TRYING TO INSTILL A ONE WORLD POWER ON ARE COUNTRYYYY



That said,
I don't know how or why Goyer came up with this story, but, speaking as an amateur writer and a comic book fan, it's so high concept and so in character for Superman that it's amazing. Supes has only ever done what he thinks he can do to help. That's what every great Superman story has been about. Not being able to help people in need is Superman's version of hell. He'd do what he had to. This has the potential to be legendary. My hopes for Goyer's ability to write Man of Steel increased tenfold.

DWARFINATORclock


miracle fruit

Quote from: DWARFINATORclock;1818336Slurpee how can you ever doubt Goyer????

he's written quite a few turds. i guess them being turds cant be attributed to goyer alone but he doesnt always come up with the most fantastic stories

and also to correct you goyer wrote the screenplay for batman begins but the nolan bros did the dark knight. although i think he did help come up with the story though

imo you can tell big time because batman begins had a lot of cheesy one-liners

DWARFINATORclock

Quote from: MiraclefruitClock;1818342he's written quite a few turds. i guess them being turds cant be attributed to goyer alone but he doesnt always come up with the most fantastic stories

and also to correct you goyer wrote the screenplay for batman begins but the nolan bros did the dark knight. although i think he did help come up with the story though

imo you can tell big time because batman begins had a lot of cheesy one-liners

Them being turds can be attributed to Goyer not giving a fuck and just doing it for the money.

Slurpee

Quote from: DWARFINATORclock;1818336Slurpee how can you ever doubt Goyer????
It's more that I didn't see how him (and Snyder and Nolan) helming a Superman project made any sense.

It felt like a desperation move on DC's part, to pull a blockbuster out of a limping franchise- hire some professionals, and let them take care of it. The path from Superman to great cinema is considerably different than the path from Batman to great cinema.

miracle fruit

Quote from: Slurpee;1818349It's more that I didn't see how him (and Snyder and Nolan) helming a Superman project made any sense.

It felt like a desperation move on DC's part, to pull a blockbuster out of a limping franchise- hire some professionals, and let them take care of it. The path from Superman to great cinema is considerably different than the path from Batman to great cinema.

watchmen convinced me that snyder can do wonderful things to campy tights-wearing superheroes like superman

goyer is just the guy to write superhero movies

and anything nolan aka midas goes near turns to gold so it couldnt hurt having him produce

Losperman

Quote from: Slurpee;18183281)That said,
I don't know how or why Goyer came up with this story, but, speaking as an amateur writer and a comic book fan, it's so high concept and so in character for Superman that it's amazing. Supes has only ever done what he thinks he can do to help. That's what every great Superman story has been about. Not being able to help people in need is Superman's version of hell. He'd do what he had to. This has the potential to be legendary. My hopes for Goyer's ability to write Man of Steel increased tenfold.

This is a very well-spoken observation. One of my favorite things about Superman is that he is cursed to be the torch-bearing boyscout for all of Earth's superheroes whether he likes it or not. And they've touched on his allegiance to the US so many times that in many cases he became the President's lapdog. I haven't read everything with President Luthor, but from what I have read they didn't play that up nearly as much as I would have liked. I would have loved to have seen Lex orchestrate something where Superman had to do something he didn't want to in "defense" of the US. They may have done that, but I haven't read it yet. I'm still catching up on a lot of stuff. And I'm rambling. Superman is cool. Ok I'm done.
Sig by {{{Zombie Lincoln}}}


:capn: BUSTAS! :capn:

miracle fruit

Quote from: RibsClock;1818359BUT IT DOESN'T COUNT BECAUSE NEVER THE TWAIN SHALL MEET

non canon DC/MARVEL crossovers do exist. as a kid i remember one where wonder woman lifted mjolnir

Silly Putty Clock

Quote from: RibsClock;1818359It's funny how this, according to Captain America, places him right in the 'true patriot' category.

BUT IT DOESN'T COUNT BECAUSE NEVER THE TWAIN SHALL MEET

GREAT SCOTT
8=======D~~~~>_<~~~~C=======8

miracle fruit

i might be alone in liking the amalgam universe, i love some of the characters like doctor doomsday




Losperman

Quote from: MiraclefruitClock;1818381i might be alone in liking the amalgam universe, i love some of the characters like doctor doomsday


Hahaha, that is hilarious. I can't imagine Doomsday talking like he knows anything about anything.

Quote

Hot damn. Most unbeatable superhero ever.
Sig by {{{Zombie Lincoln}}}


:capn: BUSTAS! :capn: