News:

If you need instructions on how to get through the hotels, check out the enclosed instruction book.

Main Menu

Abortion: Right or wrong?

Farted by TequilaClock, December 06, 2011, 08:17:44 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

TequilaClock

Quote from: clammo;1878988If you vote for choice, do you believe that women who make the choice to have unprotected sex should be free of the consequences?

No.

AlbinoClock

I think a woman ought to have the right to decide not to carry a pregnancy to term, but I think everyone can agree that the fewer abortions that happen the better, simply because it's hard on the people involved. Instead of attemping to decrease the number of abortions by making it illegal, it seems to me that a better approach would be making it easier to get contraception and making it easier to have a family. I can't speak to the economic situations in other countries, but in the US at least I think there would be fewer abortions if there were more financial stability for the average person.

QuoteIf you vote for choice, do you believe that women who make the choice to have unprotected sex should be free of the consequences?

They're not. They're faced with a decision of either carrying a child to term or getting an abortion, neither of which is easy.  I certainly don't think they should have their pregnancy forced on them by the rest of society as some kind of weird punishment or part of some religious nonsense.

TequilaClock

Quote from: clammo;1878992Can you elaborate?

Albino covered plenty of what I got to say. Abortions should be taken as a serious procedure, not a ticket out of consequences. Abortions are a risky procedure for women as it could hurt their organs, hormonal balance, and lots of psychological damage to top it.

Of course there will be some horrible people that will keep using abortions as a method of getting out of any responsibility towards their child, but way too many do absolutely horrible things to get rid of their problems as well, so that's a different issue that covers way many other situations.

Plus, there is also the idea of keeping the child after all; not to mention adoption (legal limitations may vary), but that is also a choice that is up to the mother and should not be decided by anyone else.

And let's not talk about dogmatic issues, because they are absolutely irrelevant on the first place.

AlbinoClock

Adoption can be really bad. I'd rather not have a child than give it to the state.

TequilaClock

Hey, don't look at me. I am just saying that some people find that to be a good idea.

Topcatyo

I agree with pretty much what Albino said, but I do say there should be a cutoff date for abortions.  If you've had the baby for, say, a month (just pulled that out of my head), abortion ceases to be an option.  I do think that making abortions legal would be a smart move, though.  Simply put, the world already has way too many people in it, bringing more people into it that we don't even want is just a burden on somebody that there aren't enough resources to handle.  The Earth just officially hit 7 billion people not long ago.

AlbinoClock

Quote from: Topcatyo;1878997I agree with pretty much what Albino said, but I do say there should be a cutoff date for abortions.  If you've had the baby for, say, a month (just pulled that out of my head), abortion ceases to be an option.  I do think that making abortions legal would be a smart move, though.  Simply put, the world already has way too many people in it, bringing more people into it that we don't even want is just a burden on somebody that there aren't enough resources to handle.  The Earth just officially hit 7 billion people not long ago.

You mean it's been born for a month? That would be interesting. I don't know if you've ever knocked a chick up, but it takes a while before she'll notice. At a month she could very well not even know she's pregnant.

I really don't want to read up on abortion laws to figure out if it's the second or third trimester when they're no longer supposed to abort, but it's one of them. At any rate, that's not something that should be left up to any layman.

And they're already legal. Roe v. Wade.

TequilaClock

Quote from: Topcatyo;1878997I do think that making abortions legal would be a smart move, though.  Simply put, the world already has way too many people in it, bringing more people into it that we don't even want is just a burden on somebody that there aren't enough resources to handle.  The Earth just officially hit 7 billion people not long ago.

We were talking about this yesterday, actually. My astronomy teacher mentioned how just on 2000 the population had hit 6 billion. At this rate, we might reach 8 billion in 2017, which is just scandalous.

But I digress.

AlbinoClock

Quote from: clammo;1879002I would argue that there are women who use abortions as a 'get out of jail free' card, so to speak. Women who just want to drink and party, who get knocked up, just want to keep drinking and partying, so they get the fetus aborted. I could dig through lamebook to find a few posts about pregnant women looking to get abortions because they just don't care about it.

Not being a woman, I can't speak from direct experience, but from what I've heard from woman who've had abortions, having your cunt vacuumed out isn't exactly "free". At any rate, I don't think it's society's place to be putting a moral impetus on what people do with their own bodies.
 
QuoteThat's the tricky thing. For those who do support abortion, how do you justify the cut off date where the fetus is beyond aborting? According to wikipedia, the brain and heart are developing at approximately 11 weeks after fertilization. However, in the average fetus, after 3 months, weighs approximately 1 ounce (or 0.06 pounds) according to this site on fetal development. Unless the mother directly investigates if she's pregnant, she may not even know until after the brain and heart are developed. (And yes, there are cases of women not knowing they are pregnant until it's late in the pregnancy.) Also, this note from wikipedia is also telling: "A woman pregnant for the first time typically feels fetal movements at about 21 weeks..."

Again, I'd save that for the doctors. I don't think anyone should be forced to carry something inside them that they don't want to.

QuoteIs overpopulation really a valid excuse to justify terminating a baby's life? I would suggest that if we needed to start population control, a better place to look would be in prisons, not wombs. (Not that I support population control!!!)

I don't think if it were a question of how to systematically lower the population that either method would be appropriate. At least in the case of a mother deciding not to carry the child she's bearing to term, it's actually involving something that's obviously part of her body. A government's entitlement to decide the fate of prisoners is less clear, and certainly more of an imposition.

In both of these situations, lowering the population by executing prisoners, and forcing mothers to carry fetuses to term, government is imposing its ideals onto individuals without their consent. I don't think that's appropriate in these cases.

Topcatyo

Quote from: AlbinoClock;1878998You mean it's been born for a month? That would be interesting. I don't know if you've ever knocked a chick up, but it takes a while before she'll notice. At a month she could very well not even know she's pregnant.

I really don't want to read up on abortion laws to figure out if it's the second or third trimester when they're no longer supposed to abort, but it's one of them. At any rate, that's not something that should be left up to any layman.
I know, as I said I pulled "a month" out of my head, I didn't feel like trying to remember what the legal date is an all that.

QuoteAnd they're already legal. Roe v. Wade.
Yeah but there are wacky laws that are still restricting the crap out of them (or I at least know they are trying to pass hotly contested regulations which is complicating matters).

I'll be happy to discuss more after class, which is now (fuck)

FLOUNDERMAN_CLOCK

Depends on how far along the pregnancy is. Its kind of hard to say when a human truly has the definitions of being "human". I've heard people say that they arent humans until they are truly sentient and self aware somewhere in the first few years of life. I'd say the severity of the death increases and development goes on. The first month or the day after its nothing, similar to cutting off a teratoma or a killing a plant. Then when the brain starts developing its like killing a kitten. And so on.

Quote from: RibsClock;18790921. That the fetus is not alive because it lacks consciousness/ability to communicate and decide for itself

....

The first two are actually the ones I have the most issue with, because it's nothing less than dehumanizing the helpless to justify killing them.

We kill things with much more intelligence and emotional depth than a 1 month old fetus in the millions for food. What makes this any different? In fact in the earliest parts of a pregnancy a fetus isnt all that different from a tumor.



Really its impossible to find a compromise here because religious people believe a soul exists at conception therefor its murder the moment the sperm meets the egg. Some even think its a grave sin just to masturbate or have protected sex because you're depriving a baby that does not exist the right to start existing.  Which honestly, is idiotic.

pop-tart

Quote from: FloundermanClock;1879112I'd say the severity of the death increases and development goes on. The first month or the day after its nothing, similar to cutting off a teratoma or a killing a plant. Then when the brain starts developing its like killing a kitten. And so on.


I'm staying out of the debate because I have such mixed emotions and conflicting thoughts on the matter that I don't know what to say. But this statement is really wack

AmberArachnidClock

Okay here we go, I just wrote a huge-ass paper on this issue. I won't post the 12 pages here, but I'll post a few highlights.

The idea of having a cut-off date can be strongly argued against. It's arbitrary, and dichotomous to do so when growth is so gradual. Not to mention that no trait a fetus exhibits in the womb is particularly human.

Many states make abortion illegal at the point of "viability", when a fetus has developed its organs and could live independently from the mother. But any premature baby requires strict dependence on medicine and/or machinery to keep it alive, and every baby is very dependent on its parents to survive. One could argue that independence is hardly a human trait in the first place.

In fact, placing specific restrictions on abortion might be the absolute worst thing to do. In doing so, one is acknowledging that abortions vary in their morality, but also making an attempt to weed out the morally wrong ones. However, the only woman who would treat abortion with levity (which was agreed by all of Cannoldââ,¬â,,¢s interviewees as a great indicator of an immoral abortion) would pretty much be a sociopath. I believe that when you outlaw abortions after the third trimester, you are calling every mother doing so a sociopath, and when you force teenagers to get parent permission, you are calling them morally incapable.

Also: I agree with your conclusion Ribs, but there are many more ways to justify abortion than whether it's a "human" or not.

EDIT: Here's one:

In response to "if you have sex you are implicitly agreeing to having a baby"
Quote from: David BooninAs Ted sat down to eat, he discovered that the crumpled wad of dollar bills in his pants pocket made him uncomfortable, so he put them down on the table while he was eating, intending to put them back in his pocket when it was time to leave. A friend who was leaving the restaurant when Ted sat down saw this and warned Ted not to put the money there on the grounds that he might forget about it, but Ted foolishly refused, and when the friend urged that he at least tie a piece of string around his finger to remind himself to put the money back in his pocket before leaving, Ted declined, saying that he didn't like the way having a piece of string tied around his finger "made him feel" when he was trying to enjoy a meal. Unfortunately, Ted was so lost in the rapture of his meal that he did indeed to forget to put the money back in his pocket, and about ten minutes after he left the resaurant, he suddenly realized his mistake and headed back to clear things up.

By leaving the money on the table did Ted implicitly agree to give the waiter the money? By having sex does the woman implicitly agree to take care of the possible resulting baby?

An argument against having to care for babies resulting from rape:
Quote from: juidith jarvis thomsonYou wake up in the morning and find yourself back to back in bed with an unconscious violinist. He has been found to have a fatal kidney ailment, and the Society of Music Lovers has canvassed all the available medical records and found that you alone have the right blood type to help. They have therefore kidnapped you, and last night the violinistââ,¬â,,¢s circulatory system was plugged into yours, so that your kidneys can be used to extract poisons from his blood as well as your own. The director of the hospital now tells you, ââ,¬Å"Look, weââ,¬â,,¢re sorry the Society of Music Lovers did this to you.... But still, they did it, and the violinist is now plugged into you. To unplug you would be to kill him. But never mind, itââ,¬â,,¢s only for nine months. But then he will have recovered from his ailment, and can safely be unplugged from you.

AmberArachnidClock

Quote from: pop-tart clock;1879113I'm staying out of the debate because I have such mixed emotions and conflicting thoughts on the matter that I don't know what to say. But this statement is really wack

I actually really like Floudy's statement because it's the next logical step of restricting abortions after a point of time.

FLOUNDERMAN_CLOCK

Quote from: pop-tart clock;1879113I'm staying out of the debate because I have such mixed emotions and conflicting thoughts on the matter that I don't know what to say. But this statement is really wack

Tell me, what makes humans special. What makes us different from animals. Besides being "god's chosen species" or whatever. What makes our lives more significant than others? Is it our intelligence? Our emotions? Opposable thumbs?  If you lack those, are you still a human? Is a corpse still a human? A bundle of cells created right after sex, what makes that better than some bacteria? Does the potential to become a full grown human make it more important? Does that make an acorn a tree, or some silk from a silk worm a beautiful dress?

buttplug

I'm pro choice. But my real issue is with sexual education in the USA. There are still places that basically teach abstinence-only, despite it now being obvious that this is a TERRIBLE method of education.

Topcatyo

Quote from: Buttplug;1879119I'm pro choice. But my real issue is with sexual education in the USA. There are still places that basically teach abstinence-only, despite it now being obvious that this is a TERRIBLE method of education.
This is very true.  We were taught about condoms in class but it was very minimal and they really stressed on not having sex with people ever unless you're gonna marry which I understand is the traditional view but isn't necessarily what anybody actually follows through on, if they even bother to try to.

K3LTR0N

id prefer to have the choice whether to keep a baby in me or not. sry baby!!!!


AlbinoClock

Quote from: RibsClock;1879092However, I think if we consider honestly, that a lot of it is that it's simply convenient emotionally, socially, physically, and financially in the selfish sense to justify the termination of the fetus on the arbitrary and frankly poorly established premise that it is not "human" or "alive", and that seems to have more sway in the decision in people's minds than establishing the truth of the matter.

Unfortunately we can't really establish "the truth of the matter", so it's really just a matter of how we define things. I agree that it's pointless to talk about it being human or alive or not, but that's because I don't think anyone should be forced to carry someone around inside of them if they don't want to, whether that person will die or not. You don't force kidney transplants on eligible donors.

Quote from: pop-tart clock;1879113I'm staying out of the debate because I have such mixed emotions and conflicting thoughts on the matter that I don't know what to say. But this statement is really wack

Why? It's true. A fetus, at early stages, isn't as complex as a cat, because it hasn't finished its development yet. We go from being a single cell to a whole being, it's not as though we maintain the same level of complexity throughout.

Quote from: SatelliteClock;1879114In response to "if you have sex you are implicitly agreeing to having a baby"

If this were true it would be legal to poke holes in condoms.

F U Clock

"Did I request thee, Maker, from my clay
To mould me Man, did I solicit thee
From darkness to promote me?"

I don't know if anyone feels particularly GUNG-HO about abortion, but it's a convenience I as a man am glad exists. If my girlfriend got knocked up, it wouldn't be as simply as, "Oh well let's go get you an abortion right quick!" It would probably be a long, painful conversation. I can only imagine how much more severe it would feel being on the woman's side.

I won't argue for when life begins and all that jazz. It's a distraction from what the real issue is, I think. America's birthrate is pretty fantastic so I think it's easy to forget that childbirth is fucking dangerous and causes drastic changes to your body. Telling a woman she has to go through that is pretty fucked, when it's her body. If we outlaw abortion, will she become a murderer if she drinks too much and the baby is stillborn? Will someone else be a murderer if he punches her in the stomach? Will these women who are unable financially or emotionally to care for a baby not seek out any of the more ancient methods of abortion to get rid of it? Or turn to dangerous home-made abortion devices like coathangers? And that's not discussing the whole rape/incest thing.

All in all, I think it's too much of a case-by-case basis to say whether abortion is right or wrong, and it's not something the government should tell you you can't do for reasons provided.