News:

If you need instructions on how to get through the hotels, check out the enclosed instruction book.

Main Menu

Abortion: Right or wrong?

Farted by TequilaClock, December 06, 2011, 08:17:44 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

AmberArachnidClock

Quote from: RibsClock;1879206That seems to imply that the individual is portrayed as a stranger because it's more morally acceptable to kill a stranger for selfish reasons than someone you were actually familiar with.

And I sincerely doubt that's what you think. Perhaps you could clarify?
Because Thomson (the author who wrote the famous violinist example) wants us to be as logical about the situation as possible, and a stranger in the example is the least likely to engage our emotions and cloud our judgement. At the same time, by making him famous she adds value to this stranger whose life you must decide.

Also keep in mind she's not arguing what's morally good, but rather what's morally permissible. She's not saying that you are in the clear by detaching yourself from the violinist, but that the violinist does not have the right to continue using your body.
QuoteExasperated? Eh...

I'm basically in favor of illegality except in life-threatening situations and a well-funded and highly supervised nationalized system of child care for orphans and children separated from their birth parents. The present institutions in place are inadequate, even for our current needs. There should also be nationally sponsored sexual education for all children (not late-teens, prepubescent, because half the point of it is it's preventative).

However, more important (and more difficult) than that is a paradigm shift, a change in typical practice and perspective to address the root of the problem and make the legality of abortion a moot point. We need a change in how people think and feel about sex, about childbirth and children and pregnant women, about rape and rape victims, and frankly about the self-centered mentality.

However, that's quite beyond this particular debate.

Well then I guess I'll have to try to convince you otherwise then ;) . And I'm gonna do it Socrates style.

You're approach to legislation is obviously influenced strongly by your values. Do you really hold on to them strong enough to be willing to press them upon many people who think differently? Especially as a man, I would feel very wary holding this opinion. There are many women who would tear you down a size if you told them your views on legislation.

When you put such a law into place you are strongly affecting the destinies of many, many women. You are taking a big part of their control out of their lives. You might feel it's for the greater good, but they might not think so. And I can guarantee that they thought a lot more about their abortion than you did.

I guess what I'm asking is would you be willing to personally tell a rape victim that they have to go through with the pregnancy? After all she went through?

And I hope you don't ever engage in sex without the intention of having a baby, or else you are being very, very unfair to the women you bang.

QuoteCertainly a poignant thought, but by the devil's advocate qualifier I take it you have a refutation handy, I'd like to hear it.

I don't really have a refutation for that, I just said devil's advocate because it's an argument against the side I'm arguing for.

Marlin Clock

Quote from: F U Clock;1879209Personally I am offended that all of you who CLEARLY masturbate kill millions of tiny babies every day, flushing them down the toilet crammed into so much tissue.
It's too bad sperm only contain half of an individual's genome, thus being gametes, and not individuals.
Quote from: AMPEEEM;1879211Yes, but is it absolutely necessary, no holds barred, to give birth to said individual?
As an individual human being I believe it holds all rights attributed. This is nonnegotiable.
QuoteAlso, just another thought that came into mind, regardless of the on going debates about whether or not abortion is wrong, I just don't think the law in America is ever going to fully crack down on it. There will always be a place to get abortions, and people who really want to get them will get them. Is this debatable, what do you guys think?
Of course, almost anything made illicit has found its ways to remain active. I imagine abortion would be no different.

AMPEEEM

but can gay guys get married?

Sinister Clock

Quote from: pop-tart clock;1879212Anyone who uses the argument "we kill cows and chickens" is too stupid for me to even listen to. Life feeds on life. I have the same view on when life begins as Marlin.

It is fucked up that the most advanced species on Earth is the only one that uses extermination of its own offspring to enhance its own quality of life. You watch polar bears on Animal Planet walking thousands of miles in search of food for its young... then switch over to MTV to see some 16 year old whore who was too stupid to practice safe sex with a goddamn coat hanger up her twat trying to make sure she can still fit her homecoming dress.

That's the issue. Not rape or incest or threat to mother's safety or all the other .0001% reasons for abortion. Whether those should be protected, I have mixed feelings on.

But the people who are flat out selfish, careless, imprudent pieces of shit that use abortion as a form of birth control.. should be terminated themselves.

I am spiritual but not religious. I believe the ability to create life is a gift. Those who treat it with such disrespect deserve death.


Holy shit you are so fucking I'm a edgy teen look at all these fucking logical fallacies, you make up statistics and you fucking group every woman into this one persona which you've set up to hate with a fucking made up story with a homecoming dress and MTV and just fuck you seriously.


Quote from: Marlin Clock;1879232It's too bad sperm only contain half of an individual's genome, thus being gametes, and not individuals.

As an individual human being I believe it holds all rights attributed. This is nonnegotiable.

You were saying earlier that the whole reason you hate "killing unborn babies"  is that you're depriving it of it's future, how is killing sperm cells or eggs cells not depriving them of their trillions of futures? They both have individual and unique genetic code with the potential to become anything and do anything, just like if they were already joined up, only they have more possibilities as they could join with any egg or sperm.

How are two cells an individual but one cell not?

F U Clock

Quote from: pop-tart clock;1879212Anyone who uses the argument "we kill cows and chickens" is too stupid for me to even listen to. Life feeds on life. I have the same view on when life begins as Marlin.

It is fucked up that the most advanced species on Earth is the only one that uses extermination of its own offspring to enhance its own quality of life. You watch polar bears on Animal Planet walking thousands of miles in search of food for its young... then switch over to MTV to see some 16 year old whore who was too stupid to practice safe sex with a goddamn coat hanger up her twat trying to make sure she can still fit her homecoming dress.

That's the issue. Not rape or incest or threat to mother's safety or all the other .0001% reasons for abortion. Whether those should be protected, I have mixed feelings on.

But the people who are flat out selfish, careless, imprudent pieces of shit that use abortion as a form of birth control.. should be terminated themselves.

I am spiritual but not religious. I believe the ability to create life is a gift. Those who treat it with such disrespect deserve death.

It's been said but yeah, animals do kill and eat their young. In fact, they're way more harsh about abortion than we are since they kill their young after they're born, and they do it for very practical reasons. If there is overpopulation in their little group and not enough food to go around, those lil' bastards are dead. If a baby is born deformed or I'm a edgy teen, they usually kill it too. Not to mention, animals kill other "packs" young as a way of making sure their bloodline is the only one to survive. For instance if a outsider lion enters a pride dominated by another male and he kills or drives out that male, he will then kill all of his offspring.

AstronautClock


Asshatclock

I'm not that great of a debater but I think life is a wonderful thing and abortion should be kept to a minimum if not just not do it.

AlbinoClock

Poptart, do you have any fucking clue how many animals eat their own children?

pop-tart

Quote from: AlbinoClock;1879267Poptart, do you have any fucking clue how many animals eat their own children?

And this is everyone's answer to the ethical (not moral) questionability of killing their own child because it impedes on their career goals? Are you all devaluing human life based on the survival instincts of the yellow spotted hyrax?

We are talking about having a conscious ability to make a decision based on what is inherently right or wrong. Animals eat their own shit. Take their lead.

F U Clock

Quote from: pop-tart clock;1879274And this is everyone's answer to the ethical (not moral) questionability of killing their own child because it impedes on their career goals? Are you all devaluing human life based on the survival instincts of the yellow spotted hyrax?

We are talking about having a conscious ability to make a decision based on what is inherently right or wrong. Animals eat their own shit. Take their lead.

I actually look to the "natural world" a lot in trying to understand the differences between human society and human nature. I think a lot of people don't take into account just how animal we are and how millions of years of evolution have moulded us to instinctively behave certain ways.

Now, obviously we're not animals. We've developed a society with a moral code (which admittedly changes from person to person) and a conscious. And that's great. But sometimes I don't wonder if we'd be better off making some decisions with cold rationality. FOR INSTANCE:

One of my greatest fears in having a baby is that it will be in some way developmentally disabled. Autism is extremely common these days (1/160 newborns diagnosed, last time I checked) and I feel like if you have a disabled child you're all of a sudden made to deal with this thing you really didn't bargain for. In the wild, of course, a baby with Down Syndrome would be abandoned or eaten. Because of course the purpose of procreation is to pass on our genetic information (particularly if we're worthy of it and are attractive to other mates). So when you raise a I'm a edgy teen baby it's in blatant defiance of our primary purpose in life (from an animal standpoint), to procreate and pass on our genetic information so it will live through future generations.

Now you may think that that's monstrous of me to think that, but I'm just trying to give an example of reason trumping emotion in some cases. What can I say I have German ancestry.

SpongeClock SquarePants

#50
Quit whining and legalise abortion everywhere in the world, welcome to the 21st century mankind you lame ass. Geez what is this conservative posting, i thought this place was called clock crew not dark ages crew.

User was chilled for this post - Read the ample warnings against this kind of posting as well as the stickied thread

SpongeClock SquarePants

Quote from: F U Clock;1879275What can I say I have German ancestry.

:v

Topcatyo

in a perfect, everyone who wanted to have sex without having a baby would use birth control and abortion would only be used in situations where the condom broke or something, and the people doing the abortion would think on it like it deserves to be thought about when making that kind of decision.

however it's not a perfect world, and if abortion were legal it would no doubt be used as a birth control that meant not putting a latex bag on your wing wong, but just because people would use it for fucked up reasons shouldn't prevent those with legitimate cases from using it.  laws are not made based on morality, they're based on how detrimental they are for citizens of the country.  if somebody has no moral objections to terminating the developing fetus in their stomach then that is up to them, they'll go to hell if it exists (i don't think it does) and the fetus that hasn't developed consciousness (ideally) at that point would go on not being conscious, just like if somebody had worn a condom (or the condom hadn't broken).

however, how does not aborting a child benefit the kid (aside from the obvious "being alive" part).

human beings are going to fuck.  that's going to happen there is no stopping it no matter how much the church is going to try.  trying to fuck everything is as much a part of our DNA as having arms is.  a fun fact: even poor people fuck.

no, say a couple is in a similar situation to the one i am in, that is, being in college and having little to no money.  say thecouple fucks and by some circumstances the girl gets pregnant.

there are three options to this scenario:  they keep the baby, the have the baby and they put it up for adoption, or they abort the baby.

scenario one: they keep the baby

being that they have little to no money, and that children cost quite a hefty amount of money that these people don't have.  the couple has to drop out of college (if they're in college) and take minimum wage jobs (if they can get them), the family lives in poverty, possibly without a home, the kid is doomed to a life of poverty until he's 18 and, very likely, the rest of his life.  somebody probably dies by the time the kid is aged 8.  i'm not getting a statistic for that, but be it suicide, disease, a mugging or god knows what, living in poverty means you are much more likely to die.

the outcome: life is probably going to sucks for everybody

scenario two: they put the baby up for adoption

the kid gets put up for adoption.  in a perfect world there wouldn't be a fuckload of kids who have been put up for adoption, and every kid would find a deserving family who will be wonderful parents and the kid can live a happy life.

the world is not perfect.

the outcome: life is probably going to suck for the kid

scenario three: they abort the kid

the kid never knows about it, the couple lives their lives like normal and, ideally, don't need to get an abortion again)

while i know that these are all hypotheticals, you can argue whether or not scenario one would turn out as it does.  however, i think i'm being fairly realistic, or i try to be.  but still, if you consider how many people there are in the world, how many people live in poverty or are taking care of kids they can't afford and how many children are born into shitty situations, i view abortion as being merciful.  i understand that not every case of a person aborting a child would be one made with the best intentions, but we don't outlaw hunting because of fear for poachers.

i will also argue this: if you abort the kid before its brain forms and all that stuff that makes it a person, what's so different from using a condom?  i understand that when the egg becomes fertilized it gets both halves of the DNA, but if the sperm were to never meet the egg, the result is the same.  that genetic code does not form a human child coming out of a woman's vagina.  the only difference between that sperm never fertilizing the egg and it successfully fertilizing the egg but being terminated before whichever trimester it grows vital organs and develops a brain is that you wasted time and money and doctor's visit

AstronautClock

if a person sterilises himself or herself does that mean they are terrible people because they killed potential babies?
abortion is so tricky

Marlin Clock

Okay people, can we clarify that usually humans try to define themselves by showing how much we have divorced ourselves from our animalistic tendencies?

Second, I know everyone has their head wrapped around this concept that adoption is somehow this horrific system that only tortures parentless children and makes their lives shitty but I know quite a few people now that have been adopted and lived perfectly good lives in loving families so that is honestly a really hollow point.

Third: I tried to speak of this mostly in a biological standpoint. The reason a zygote, the cell formed when an egg cell is fertilized, is an individual is because it is not two cells, it is one cell of a human organism. Sperm cells contain half of an organisms DNA. They are still a part of that individual because their entire genome is still represented by the genome of the individual.

AmberArachnidClock

Quote from: Marlin Clock;1879300Second, I know everyone has their head wrapped around this concept that adoption is somehow this horrific system that only tortures parentless children and makes their lives shitty but I know quite a few people now that have been adopted and lived perfectly good lives in loving families so that is honestly a really hollow point.

I think something can be said for how the adoption process can traumatize the birth parents however.

F U Clock

Quote from: Marlin Clock;1879300Okay people, can we clarify that usually humans try to define themselves by showing how much we have divorced ourselves from our animalistic tendencies?

Second, I know everyone has their head wrapped around this concept that adoption is somehow this horrific system that only tortures parentless children and makes their lives shitty but I know quite a few people now that have been adopted and lived perfectly good lives in loving families so that is honestly a really hollow point.

Third: I tried to speak of this mostly in a biological standpoint. The reason a zygote, the cell formed when an egg cell is fertilized, is an individual is because it is not two cells, it is one cell of a human organism. Sperm cells contain half of an organisms DNA. They are still a part of that individual because their entire genome is still represented by the genome of the individual.

I tried to touch on the whole animal thing because I feel like a lot of things (possibly religion, chiefly) have helped people think they are a lot more different from animals than they are. I feel like if we realized that a lot of our "urges" and "temptations" come from millions of years of evolution, we'd be less quick to consider ourselves horrible people when we want to have sex with tons of 18 y-o big titted girls while eating mountains of chocolate cake.

As for the sperm thing, I'm sort of just pointing out the logical absurdity of identifying something as human that is not an actual person yet.

Topcatyo

Quote from: Marlin Clock;1879300Okay people, can we clarify that usually humans try to define themselves by showing how much we have divorced ourselves from our animalistic tendencies?
Yes but I think it's pointless because people never stopped acting like animals.
QuoteSecond, I know everyone has their head wrapped around this concept that adoption is somehow this horrific system that only tortures parentless children and makes their lives shitty but I know quite a few people now that have been adopted and lived perfectly good lives in loving families so that is honestly a really hollow point.
I'm not saying that.  What? I figured many parents feel they are doing their kid a solid by putting it up for adoption since they know they wouldn't be able to take care of the kid.  I'm sure many deserving families adopt children.  I found out my one teacher actually adopted a kid, and that guy's awesome.

I'm talking about the kids that don't get adopted.  Here's a quote from Wikipedia.
QuoteAdopted children

Adopted children are kids that were given up at birth, abandoned or were unable to be cared for by their biological parents. They may have been put into foster care before finding their permanent residence. It is particularly hard for adopted children to get adopted from foster care: only 50,000 children were adopted in 2001.[19] The average age of these children was 7 years old, which shows that fewer older kids were adopted.[19]
I tried finding a number of how many children are not adopted in the US but either I'm shit at Googling stuff or all the results after the first page start talking about other shit.

The answer I got most commonly was 52 million.  The population of the United States is 312,731,000.  One in five people would have to adopt a kid for every kid to get adopted.

QuoteThird: I tried to speak of this mostly in a biological standpoint. The reason a zygote, the cell formed when an egg cell is fertilized, is an individual is because it is not two cells, it is one cell of a human organism. Sperm cells contain half of an organisms DNA. They are still a part of that individual because their entire genome is still represented by the genome of the individual.
I am aware of all this, but if the sperm never fertilizes the egg be it through abstinence or through contraception or through a vasectomy, what difference does it make to the kid if he hasn't developed a brain or a heart?  I know I'm being awfully big picture here, but I that's how I look at it.  

I also think that big picture is how you look at it in terms of overpopulation as well as what situation the kid is being born into.  I know plenty of children are accidents and live happy lives, but i think the likelihood of parents who made the conscious decision being better parents is a lot higher when you take into account families with low-income or possibly abusive parents or just shitty parents.  If giving birth to the kid means him not getting adopted for a long time like 52 million (supposedly) other children or being born into poverty or terrible parents, the morality of abortion goes beyond just "when do we consider it a person".

pop-tart

If you use condoms or masturbate or get a vasectomy or whatever that is not the same. The human life has not been created yet. You are actually designed to release some of that material naturally if you don't procreate with it (whether it be menstruation or nocturnal emission or whatever.)

Also like to mention I never said a damn thing about the legality of abortion. So the whole "legalize it lame ass" shit that got Spongey booted.. is moot. Politically, I am pro-choice.

I said the use of abortion as a birth control alternative instead of responsible family planning is deplorable to me spiritually.

I feel it is human the moment of conception.. regardless of development. If we start gauging a living human's right to live based on it's stage in life... you could use the same argument for a newborn baby's right to live versus an adult. "It doesn't even have teeth yet so it's not a real person.."

Topcatyo

actually pop as far as i can tell i pretty much agree with you entirely.  i think abortions should be legal but i don't think they should be used as birth control because, don't get me wrong, abortion is still pretty shit