News:

If you need instructions on how to get through the hotels, check out the enclosed instruction book.

Main Menu

Bush administration sneaking in one last rule

Farted by FLOUNDERMAN_CLOCK, December 06, 2008, 12:07:29 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

FLOUNDERMAN_CLOCK

"The outgoing Bush administration is planning to announce a broad new "right of conscience" rule permitting medical facilities, doctors, nurses, pharmacists and other healthcare workers to refuse to participate in any procedure they find morally objectionable, including abortion and possibly even artificial insemination and birth control."

http://www.latimes.com/news/nationworld/nation/la-na-conscience2-2008dec02,0,7013690.story?track=rss

buttplug

Uh why are they trying to inject something as subjective as morality into medical practice?

EDIT: why do I even ask

Marlin Clock

They weren't allowed to do that before? You must be against free will if you think that's a bad thing. What's the use of the Hippocratic Oath if a doctor is forced to work against their morals?

hibiscus

Quote from: Marlin Clock;1463075They weren't allowed to do that before? You must be against free will if you think that's a bad thing. What's the use of the Hippocratic Oath if a doctor is forced to work against his morals?
:this:  Exactly.

Heliopios

Quote from: Marlin Clock;1463075They weren't allowed to do that before? You must be against free will if you think that's a bad thing. What's the use of the Hippocratic Oath if a doctor is forced to work against their morals?


Privacy =/= Morality

The Hippocratic oath is nothing more than a verbal statement of your patient's right to medical privacy, nothing, and I mean absolutely nothing, gives the doctor the right to choose his or her patients based on their fucking moral values.

If you allow that, you're basically destroying the base rule of doctoring, which is to help people, not your own morality.
:]

mauserclock


Marlin Clock

Quote from: Heliopios;1463084Privacy =/= Morality

The Hippocratic oath is nothing more than a verbal statement of your patient's right to medical privacy, nothing, and I mean absolutely nothing, gives the doctor the right to choose his or her patients based on their fucking moral values.

If you allow that, you're basically destroying the base rule of doctoring, which is to help people, not your own morality.
This isn't about doctors choosing their patients you overly aggressive sociopath, it's doctors being forced to do something they don't want to do. These doctors have been given the freedom of not having to do procedures they find morally wrong, not deny treatment to patients.

Hippocratic Oath:
QuoteTo teach medicine to the sons of my teacher.
 
To practice and prescribe to the best of my ability for the good of my patients, and to try to avoid harming them.
 
Never to do deliberate harm to anyone for anyone else's interest.
 
To avoid violating the morals of my community.
 
To avoid attempting to do things that other specialists can do better.
 
To keep the good of the patient as the highest priority.
Those bolded areas could completely be taken by the physician through their own moral system.
If a doctor believes an unborn child is a person, then performing an abortion would go completely against harming another person, for any reason.

Think before you speak asshole.

TequilaClock

Wait, why to take moral measures on artificial insemination? Its practically exactly the same as the normal fecundation process, just less carnal.

Heliopios

Quote from: Marlin Clock;1463099Those bolded areas could completely be taken by the physician through their own moral system.
If a doctor believes an unborn child is a person, then performing an abortion would go completely against harming another person, for any reason.

Think before you speak asshole.


You'd be for this just because the simple fact you're a religious fanatic. Even if the law were unjust and forced doctors into a corner due to the majority's view on a certain medical practice made them think their job were in danger if they did said procedure. This proposed law would only encourage private doctors to discriminate based on their choice of procedures. The last thing we need is privatized medicine to get another benefit from a foolish government.
:]

Marlin Clock

What I'm basically hearing here is "Yay for fascism, the only way to stop those mean free thoughts and actions us pesky people have."

Seriously, is it not ones right to do what they wish? Is the unwilling subjugation of others by law not one of the core evils fought in America's history?


In an economic sense, why do you care so much? That means more money will be going to the amoral doctors who do those sorts of procedures in the first place.

Heliopios

Quote from: Marlin Clock;1463115Seriously, is it not ones right to do what they wish? Is the unwilling subjugation of others by law not one of the core evils fought in America's history?

It's your right to do what you wish, but this is not simply people exercising their freedom of choice, it's an attempt by a dying organization to score some points with liberals for some fucking ridiculous reason. It all sounds good on paper, allowing doctors to freely choose their procedures without fear of prosecution, but in reality all this will do is encourage sect-like forms of medicine, making things like abortions cost much more money and allowing religious nuts to get a death grip on the industry.
:]

Marlin Clock

I can't understand that at all. Does this bill budget for some kind of human spawning project that creates conservative doctors? I cannot see how this will make abortions any more costly. Also, Death grip on the industry? Come on Heli, that's propagandist bullshit and you know it. You make it sound like doctors who actually have moral fiber will be bad for medicine, I don't see how that is.

mauserclock

it is your freedom of choice to have a job. If you do not do said job well because you think that it is "immoral" (i.e. dont like it cuz you're religious) then nothing happens?
fuck no if you dont like what you have to do quit

Marlin Clock

Quote from: MauserClock;1463140it is your freedom of choice to have a job. If you do not do said job well because you think that it is "immoral" (i.e. dont like it cuz you're religious) then nothing happens?
fuck no
What? Do you think that's all doctors do are immoral practices or something? The doctor's job is to care for a patient. Doctors specialize in specific kinds of medicine and I doubt you even have a grasp on how that works with an answer like that.

mauserclock

Quote from: Marlin Clock;1463143What? Do you think that's all doctors do are immoral practices or something? The doctor's job is to care for a patient. Doctors specialize in specific kinds of medicine and I doubt you even have a grasp on how that works with an answer like that.
no i dont think that
i think they are supposed to care for a patient
if they dont and just decide that caring for them is immoral then im pretty sure thats a bad thing
you seem to think a lot of things doctors do are immoral though

TequilaClock

Also if America is going to keep a melting pot community, they should make rules very wide opened despite of religion.

There goes another one for freedom.

Slurpee


Silly Putty Clock

Quote from: Marlin Clock;1463099This isn't about doctors choosing their patients you overly aggressive sociopath, it's doctors being forced to do something they don't want to do. These doctors have been given the freedom of not having to do procedures they find morally wrong, not deny treatment to patients.

Hippocratic Oath:

Those bolded areas could completely be taken by the physician through their own moral system.
If a doctor believes an unborn child is a person, then performing an abortion would go completely against harming another person, for any reason.

Think before you speak asshole.

Ad hominem! Ad hominem!

Where in any of Heliopios' posts do you find evidence of him being a sociopath, or aggressive in the slightest?
More importantly, what does that have to do with this issue? Doctors know what they signed up for. If they knew they were going to have to perform procedures that they find morally objectionable (although I think it's rediculous to find most of those procedures immoral, and in fact immoral to refuse to perform them), they should have chosen to specialize in another area of medicine.

EDIT:
Quote from: Marlin Clock;1463137I can't understand that at all. Does this bill budget for some kind of human spawning project that creates conservative doctors? I cannot see how this will make abortions any more costly. Also, Death grip on the industry? Come on Heli, that's propagandist bullshit and you know it. You make it sound like doctors who actually have moral fiber will be bad for medicine, I don't see how that is.

I cannot fathom the absolute stupidity displayed in this post.
It doesn't create conservative doctors; it simply enables them to act on their conservative mindsets. I realise that Heliopios didn't elaborate very clearly on what he meant, but surely you were able to pick that up. As for the bit about raising abortion prices, yes, "death-grip" might have been a bit of an exagerration, but the basic idea of what he said makes sense. It's simple economics; supply and demand. If you decrease the number of doctors who will perform abortions, the price for their services will rise. I also find it extremely ironic that you call his exagerrated statement "propogandist bullshit" when you yourself used the term "moral fiber" when a term like "strong religious beliefs" would have been more fitting, strongly implying that those who follow conservative Christian religious beliefs are somehow morally superior to others.
8=======D~~~~>_<~~~~C=======8

RomanClock

So it allows doctors to practice how they like, which is how it should be in the first place. Anyone against this is just hung up on "morals" when doctors already do this, this rule will just legally protect them in their choice to practice how they want.

People who say doctors shouldn't be able to choose how to practice are just idiots that think doctors are slaves to patients.
lemayo lol :soups:

Silly Putty Clock

Quote from: RomanClock;1463206So it allows doctors to practice how they like, which is how it should be in the first place. Anyone against this is just hung up on "morals" when doctors already do this, this rule will just legally protect them in their choice to practice how they want.

People who say doctors shouldn't be able to choose how to practice are just idiots that think doctors are slaves to patients.

Again, I will stress that doctors chose their own professions. If somebody is studying to become a doctor and finds out about a procedure in an area of specialized medicine(which they should know well ahead of time if medical schools are doing their jobs), they can choose to study a different area. Long story short, if a doctor has to perform a procedure that (s)he finds morally unacceptable, it's the doctor's own fault.
All of this bill's supporters seem to be overlooking the fact that not all doctors have to perform abortions or participate in any of the other procedures described, which all seem to be reproductively oriented. Besides, the only reasonable objection I can see any doctor having to any of those procedures is a refusal to look at living things as objects that can be broken down into a set of mechanisms and chemical reactions, which is essentially what medical science is. So is a doctor who is morally opposed to these procedures really fit to be a doctor, anyway?
8=======D~~~~>_<~~~~C=======8