News:

If you need instructions on how to get through the hotels, check out the enclosed instruction book.

Main Menu

Gay Marriage

Farted by AbsintheClock, April 03, 2009, 11:51:55 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

AbsintheClock

Quote from: RomanClock;1556874I also beleive its not an unwillingness to teach them things, its teaching them OTHER things.

Well if you end up teaching them other things than clearly you're teaching it wrong.

QuoteAnd overall, there are usually reasons for everything, and they are not always easy to articulate or explain. There is a reason that pure homosexuality has been taboo in basically every culture for all of human history.

Sure it's easy to explain. It's called homophobia. You're afraid of gay people, and you are creeped out by looking at them.

QuoteThere are many feelings on things that aren't simple to describe, and we try to simplify it into a way that's easy to teach others about these things. I guess you can take this subject as one of those things I just can't accurately articulate what I think of the subject and so it doesn't make sense to someone who thinks in a different way.

Well if you can't articulate it then your point is invalid.

QuoteI just don't think this is a good thing. And assuming its because of religion, then you are just simply ignorant. I find it disturbing that so many people mistake personal opinion for some religious restriction or affiliation, rather than thinking of it as someones individual thought. Though that's probably getting into another subject as well.

I don't think that breast implants are a good thing, but that doesn't mean I think it should be illegal. If you really expect folks to go on "just a feeling" then you must understand that there is nothing to debate about. We get that you find homosexuality immoral, and that you have no clue why. Clearly as you said it's not your religion which you yourself have brought up in prior debates. In fact the fact that you've brought religion into this kind of feels like you're playing flopsy on this and that's not fair.

Also clearly you don't understand why you think it is immoral because if you can't articulate your opinion then you really don't have an opinion. Just a queasy feeling in your gut when you see two gay guys making out. That's all it is, you don't like gay people being gay.

And on top of that, and unrelated principle was also violated, where judges decide for the people. That's a whole other thing for me.

To determine if you're a homophobe watch this video here, and observe your own reaction.

[u2]hajTNlooZKE&autoplay=1[/u2]

TequilaClock

I think its fine legally and even morally.

In a world full of bullshit, love is the only thing you can get for free and its worthwhile. I say let the fuckers do their awkward skeet-skeet as I see it as purely human behavior.

Of course, it is not natural by instinct or survival laws, but I think that banning gay marriage is against their freedom and even express themselves.

In the point of "thinking about the children", I think education programs should also include a wider view on social science for accepting it as part of tolerance. Not early as elementary school because it would be really fucking weird shit, even more than sex education. Maybe at 8th grade or something.

SirClock

Quote from: RomanClock;1556874And overall, there are usually reasons for everything, and they are not always easy to articulate or explain. There is a reason that pure homosexuality has been taboo in basically every culture for all of human history.
And it is only through challenging ourselves to find explanation for what we can not explain that we will ever begin to explain anything.

People who don't want gay marriage... its because they don't want to know that it truly isn't "their fault!" or immoral.

Marlin Clock

You know what else dolphins and chimps do? Kill their own for apparently no reason. Chimps, our close relatives, go as far to eat them afterwords. I guess since there's cannibalism in the animal world too we should just stop arguing and dig in!

BinaryClock

Quote from: Abe Frohman;1557755You know what else dolphins and chimps do? Kill their own for apparently no reason. Chimps, our close relatives, go as far to eat them afterwords. I guess since there's cannibalism in the animal world too we should just stop arguing and dig in!

Uh humans already do that a lot.

Also the point was that one of the most prevalent arguments against accepting homosexuality is that it's "not natural", when it in fact is.
BinaryClock, if you wanna play uno type !unohelp to see how to

SirClock

Watch out everyone. It'll turn out homosexuality is the next step in evolution!
(dont)

Marlin Clock

Quote from: BIN 9000;1557760Uh humans already do that a lot.

Also the point was that one of the most prevalent arguments against accepting homosexuality is that it's "not natural", when it in fact is.
Murder also seems to be pretty natural in the animal world. Is it legal in ours? Of course not.

Slurpee

nobody thinks that just because something is natural means it's morally sound, marlin
and nobody implied that, either, the "it's natural" line is just a response to the "it's not natural" line

so unless you want to equate homosexuality with murder I'd sure like to know why you chose to pursue that line of thought at all

Slurpee

Quote from: RibsClock;1557958He was using an example to point out the flaw in the argument, not saying that homosexuality and murder are equivalent.
well if you'll check the first paragraph in the post you quoted I think you'll find I spent it pointing out that that wasn't what he was doing

which is the only reason for any ire on my part, so

heineken

Quote from: Abe Frohman;1557755You know what else dolphins and chimps do? Kill their own for apparently no reason. Chimps, our close relatives, go as far to eat them afterwords. I guess since there's cannibalism in the animal world too we should just stop arguing and dig in!

You've just compared millions of decent people (homosexuals) to murderers and cannibals. I will not accept that and I want you take your point back or I will backfire your bullshit argument by ranting about the atrocities commited by the church and religious zealots in general.

Because that's exactly the point you're making, isn't it?
If I can't defend homosexuality as being normal by quoting an imperfect nature of humans, you certainly cannot defend homosexuality as being "sin" by quoting a horribly twisted and awful scripture.
You should watch this movie.

This movie is good.

heineken

Quote from: RibsClock;1557961So you'll flame religious people because you don't have a decent counter to his point? Certainly he may have said it in an incredibly dickish way, but he has argued effectively that "animals do it" is not a justification for it being a good or healthy thing for a human being to do.

Argue the points, don't derail it just because you're mad.

My point was something similar to his, namely "just because it's in the bible doesn't make it good". The bible is full of hate and religious people have done some seriously evil shit in the name of the bible, including hanging, burning and torturing people just because they didn't agree or live by the rules of the bible.

I thought I had made my point, I'm sorry if it came across as just flaming.

Quote from: RibsClock;1557961I am curious what you mean by this. Do you want him to say it's not true? Or are you asking that we pretend it was never brought up? And you're threatening him if he doesn't do this?

This is not the way we have productive arguments, this is how we end up with petty little pissing contests that go nowhere.

I would like him to say that his point was faulty and that he shouldn't have made such a comparison. It's a big insult to some of my friends and relatives and I really don't like that.
You should watch this movie.

This movie is good.

heineken

You keep repeating that I'm on a crusade against religion, but isn't it obvious from what moral ground Marlin is making his points from? Isn't it reasonable to assume, certainly because it's obvious Marlin is very much so a Christian, that his standpoint on gay marriage is based on his religion?

Using this, I try to counter his argument with something that negates his point by providing the exact opposite of his argument.
You should watch this movie.

This movie is good.

Marlin Clock

Oye. Sorry I ever spoke up.

Also, of course I'm not equating homosexuality to murder. What do you think I am, crucifix, insane?

No sin equates to the taking of another's life.

heineken

Fine, I'll take my point back and apologize for making assumptions. I'll argue again:

Quote from: Abe FrohmanYou know what else dolphins and chimps do? Kill their own for apparently no reason. Chimps, our close relatives, go as far to eat them afterwords. I guess since there's cannibalism in the animal world too we should just stop arguing and dig in!

Homosexuality isn't the same as murder or cannibalism, there's no victims of homosexuality but there are most certainly victims of murder. That's why they are completely different. I agree that we shouldn't just do something just because animals do it, but when people argue that homosexuality isn't natural, they're wrong because homosexuality occurs in hundreds of species. In fact, all bonobo's are bisexual!
You should watch this movie.

This movie is good.

heineken

Quote from: RibsClock;1557997I would say that the only victims of homosexuality are those who are victimized by the condition, not by the practice of homosexuals.
I agree completely

Quote from: RibsClockAlright, here we get to the actual argument.

Now, in the sense that it occurs in nature, homosexuality is entirely natural. In fact, in that human beings are almost always capable of responding sexually to both sexes it could be said that humans are naturally bisexual.
I'm not sure what you're saying here..?

Quote from: RibsClockNow in the sense that our reproductive systems operate through sexual interaction with the opposite sex, not the same sex, it is a deviation from natural human reproductive impulses.
Yes, and I think this is what bothers the opposition of gay marriage. But if this is an argument to ban same-sex marriage, shouldn't it also be illegal for infertile people to get married?

Quote from: RibsClockOn that note, would you say it would be 'natural' for a cow to have five legs?

This is an interesting point and actually provides me an opportunity to define what the word "natural" means to me.

Probably not. I highly doubt cows are able to have twins, but if they are able to, then the fifth leg could be the result of a conjoined fetus (sp?). In that case, yes, the fifth leg would be natural. Strange and unusual but still natural. If the cow has been eating grass poisoned with radiation and the fifth leg is caused by a mutation in the cow, I'd consider it unnatural. Even then though, you can still debate this. Some people would only call the fifth leg unnatural if it were, say, literally sowed on by some psycho scientist. For me the line of natural/unnatural is if it occurs under completely ordinary circumstances or not. Seeing as homosexuality occurs everywhere in the world in all sorts of species and social groups, I'd say it's natural.
You should watch this movie.

This movie is good.

FileCabinetClock

Quote from: Abe Frohman;1557755You know what else dolphins and chimps do? Kill their own for apparently no reason. Chimps, our close relatives, go as far to eat them afterwords. I guess since there's cannibalism in the animal world too we should just stop arguing and dig in!

Murder...gay sex...murder...gay sex

shit, you're right, they're the SAME THING

that is, of course, a terrible fallacy, but possibly because (in my opinion) "because animals do it" is also a pretty lame argument.
the man, the legend

Marlin Clock

I'd like to know where you got that because I see nothing that says all mollies are female.

Marlin Clock

To be perfectly clear, everything I've read says nothing about Mollies being lesiban, just that, since they can only reproduce through parthenogenesis, that they need to use other closely related species in order to stimulate it.

heineken

I'm too tired to absorb and process all these arguments, but I encountered one argument so far that's absolutely flawed, which was RibsClock's point that a car was made to get one somewhere, and therefore sex is meant for reproduction.

I sometimes drive my car for the heck of it. I just drive and don't stop anywhere until I get home again. That's sex, right? Sometimes you do it just for the fun of it. Actually, most of the time. So far I've never thought "Oh boy I just hope she'll get pregnant this time" when I was having sex, but quite the opposite really.


Screw it, ignore this post, I shouldn't be arguing when I'm not reading the arguments.
You should watch this movie.

This movie is good.

Marlin Clock

Quote from: CadillacClock;1560029The last time I checked an entire page was devoted to Marlins argument. Which was highly rooted in the works of Thomas Aquinas.

The same works, I might add, that have caused such a problem for homosexuals and became heavily rooted in the opinion of early Evolutionists.

No need to make note of it though!
What argument, what page?
QuoteThe species has sex and makes flirtatious and physical acts (that would be deemed sexual) with other Molly's. Which are, by nature, clones of themselves and female, entirely. They use males to stimulate their reproductive organs without mating with them.

Glad I could clear that up.
Quote from: wikipediahttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poecilia_formosa
This means that although females must mate with a male, genetic material from the male is not incorporated into the already diploid egg cells that the mother is carrying (except in extraordinary circumstances), resulting in clones of the mother being produced en mass.
If by flirtatious acts with other mollies you mean other molly species, then yes. Also, they do still need to mate with them in the sense of the action along with exchange of genetic material.
QuoteThis lends itself towards a large potential for population growth as long as host males are present.
Also, this suggests that they do not have any stimulation within the species. Also, apparently they can make male triploid hybrids occasionally, since their host males are all of the same genus.


E: It's taking all my strength to not take pleasure from the fact that Caddy's argument for the past day has been made null and void.