News:

If you need instructions on how to get through the hotels, check out the enclosed instruction book.

Main Menu

Gay Marriage

Farted by AbsintheClock, April 03, 2009, 11:51:55 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

AbsintheClock

Well Iowa just legalized gay marriage. (I'm pretty surprised) So I wanted to see what you folks think about gay marriage from a legal, and a moral standpoint. In my own case from a legal and a moral standpoint I think it's perfectly acceptable to allow two folks in love to get married no matter what their gender is.

Civil unions are simply another repeat of the "separate" but equal" bullshit that we had in the 1950's. Even if you don't like gay people at all you should consider all points. First point is state revenue. States can gain a lot more in taxes through married couples especially those without children.

In many states there is a constitutional statement that says "All men are born free and equal, and have certain natural, essential, and unalienable rights; among which may be reckoned the right of enjoying and defending their lives and liberties; that of acquiring, possessing, and protecting property; in fine, that of seeking and obtaining their safety and happiness." This notion was first made by Massachusetts seven years before the declaration of independence.

From a moral standpoint I believe that if you are against gay marriage then you should simply not marry somebody of the same sex. Other than that I would advise minding your own business. Just because it is law in places does not mean you have to recognize it in private.

MonsterMunch

Gay people should have the same right that straight people have to turn their undying love into a legal contract that wagers that they will love each other or they lose half their shit.

EDIT:- Side question, is gay marriage legal in Nevada?

Because you know there would be a lot of idiotic friends getting $55 weddings as part of a drunk bet or something.

AbsintheClock

Nope. Gay marriage is illegal in Nevada. A drive thru wedding however is perfectly acceptable especially when performed by a morbidly obese Elvis impersonator.

SpongeClock SquarePants

gay marriage is cool, im glad its been legal for a while here. Coming to think of it i think the netherlands was the first to do so.

EDIT: "The Netherlands has allowed same-sex marriage since 1 April 2001, the first nation in the world to do so."

still, 2001 feels like fucking yesterday. It feels like we were still in de dark ages before 2001..... :/

TremcladClock

From what I've seen, most arguments in opposition of same sex marriage boil down to archaic, illogical moral quibbles or other such verbal diarrhoea. You could stress the point that children won't receive adequate role influences when raised by same-sex parents, but that would be awfully daft, considering how many useless heterosexual parents there are in the world.


Sinister Clock

There really is no valid argument against gay marriage besides religious drivel. I'm not trying to insult religious people, just those who take it too far and force their views on others.

I think about what society was like 100, 200, 1000, etc... years ago and I think we've made some improvement but at the same time I want to live 100 years in the future when we've progressed more, but then I imagine I'd still see problems in society and want to advance 200 years more, etc... I'm wondering if we are always improving, will we eventually reach a cap where we can improve no more and we are a perfect society?

Also why the fuck do we only have civil marriages in England? We have virtually no religious nut cases here and nearly everyone is in favour for gay marriage, anyone who's not is shunned as some BNP bastard or whatever.

Marlin Clock

I think there should be no legal standpoint. Marriage is a religious sacrament, thus it shouldn't be secularized because of the ideal of separation of church and state.

To make perfectly clear, if it wasn't obvious, am morally against gay marriage and homosexuality, but I do not believe the government has the right to forbid it. I believe only the religions who consecrate marriage should have the right to bar or accept gay marriages from their churches.

Freedom is the God given right of all men, even the freedom to sin.

patriotclock

Morally I am supposed to be against it but honestly i do not care either way since it doesnt affect me at all. Its just gross imo

GearBoxClock

Wow, Marlin has a good point. Kinda.

I literally cannot think of any reason not to allow gay marriage, that isn't a religious thing or about how the children are raised. There are many benefits as well. If you don't like it, just don't go to a gay marriage.

RomanClock

How about the government JUST STAYS OUT.
Note that the 'court' decided for the people, which basically means the small percentage advocating this is bypassing how laws should be made.
Note, I also beleive marriage is NOT a RIGHT. Too many people think they have rights that don't exist. You don't have a right to a job, a car, a house, a drivers license, college, etc. You basically have the right to speak and make choices freely and to live (that's a quick and dirty summary but I'm not here to go into details).
Not only that, marriage is a religious practice, nothing to do with the government. The government only gave it benefits because it produced children and a (usually) good environment yo grow up in.
I see no positives in allowing gay marriage. Being gay is no different than having any other sexual preference. It has nothing to do with civil rights. There is no way you can PROVE without a doubt someone is gay/not-gay. You can prove you are a woman, you can prove you're black (or other ethnicity), not that either of those factors really matter to me.
Again, the COURT decides one an issue that should be decided by the people.
Not to mention why are we talking about gay marriage in the first place? IT DOESN'T MATTER AT ALL, we are just clogging up the system with more garbage instead of working on more important things.
Overall, I'm really sick of 'straight v gay' when its just different sexual preferences.
No laws need to be made concerning the subject at all.
lemayo lol :soups:

Sinister Clock

Quote from: Abe Frohman;1556123I think there should be no legal standpoint. Marriage is a religious sacrament, thus it shouldn't be secularized because of the ideal of separation of church and state.

To make perfectly clear, if it wasn't obvious, am morally against gay marriage and homosexuality, but I do not believe the government has the right to forbid it. I believe only the religions who consecrate marriage should have the right to bar or accept gay marriages from their churches.

Freedom is the God given right of all men, even the freedom to sin.

How is marriage a relgious sacrament? People get married all over the world regardless of religion, are you against athiest marrying?

RomanClock

Quote from: Sinister;1556249How is marriage a relgious sacrament? People get married all over the world regardless of religion, are you against athiest marrying?

Its a common cultural, social, and religious practice to bind a man and a woman (or women) for since basically forever. Its almost hardwired, people get angry when someone is in a relation with someone else because whatever reason.
lemayo lol :soups:

heineken

A while ago I found a page that compared arguments, all of them based on religious foundations, with other statements.

For instance, a pastor was asked how he felt about gay marriage, and he quoted a verse from the bible that said all sorts of nasty things about sodomy and homosexuality. Then he was asked about some really awful bible quotes that said all sorts of nasty things about headens and non-christian religious people, involving death and torture, and his argument was that it shouldn't be taken seriously in this society.

My point is, if you think homosexuality is wrong and are apposed to same sex marriage JUST because the bible says so, then you only have right to speak if you beat your wife with a stick as thick as your thumb, give 10% of your total income to charity and have poked your eye out if you ever looked at a nice set of boobs.

I would like to add this, by the way:

Quote from: Abe Frohman;1556123This post directly translates into "atheists don't marry" and "god hates fags".


(User was banned for this post; Reason: Stop misquoting Marlin like a douchebag)
You should watch this movie.

This movie is good.

RomanClock

Quote from: Crucifix;1556276A while ago I found a page that compared arguments, all of them based on religious foundations, with other statements.

For instance, a pastor was asked how he felt about gay marriage, and he quoted a verse from the bible that said all sorts of nasty things about sodomy and homosexuality. Then he was asked about some really awful bible quotes that said all sorts of nasty things about headens and non-christian religious people, involving death and torture, and his argument was that it shouldn't be taken seriously in this society.

My point is, if you think homosexuality is wrong and are apposed to same sex marriage JUST because the bible says so, then you only have right to speak if you beat your wife with a stick as thick as your thumb, give 10% of your total income to charity and have poked your eye out if you ever looked at a nice set of boobs.

I would like to add this, by the way:

Good job not understanding religion and attacking someone and being obviously biased from the start.
PS a cross is not a crucifix.
lemayo lol :soups:

AbsintheClock

That's a strong point, and a pretty ballsy one to take and I agree with part of what triangle said. If for an example a gay couple wants to get married in a catholic church and they say no then the couple has no right to force them. On the same token if two gay people find some church or get married in court that's fine with me. It's not a matter of morality but a matter of simple public decency to respect peoples individual beliefs and to respect the freedom of this country.

I do however not agree with Roman. Marriage is a right that is bestowed on consenting adults. It should be a right to declare to the federal government that you believe at this current time you want to be with another person until one of you dies. This is perfectly reasonable in terms of a request. How would you feel if somebody told you that you couldn't get married?

There is more harm done to our citizens emotionally by ignoring their personal beliefs over some silly outdated federal dogma. A restriction on marriage, or a demeaning clause forcing "civil union" just isn't good enough. We need to be empathetic of other peoples beliefs even if we do not agree with them.

I also think it's time that folks in public have more open dialogue about gay people and how much does it really matter that they're involved in society. I'm not saying you have to accept them as one of your own, but I'm saying accept that they have a right to be themselves as long as it doesn't hurt anyone.

SirClock

Yea the separate but equal point.

Its funny that some people are apparently not smart enough to realize thats physically impossible.

FileCabinetClock

Some parents say that they don't want gays marrying because: "How am I going to explain it to my CHILDREN?"

Some people say that they don't want gays to marry because they'll want to adopt, and gays will be terrible parents.

If you can't sit down for two seconds with your little snot-nosed kid to explain that people of the same sex can be joined in holy matrimony (air quotes taken for granted here), you're a worse parent than I can ever imagine two men being.

Quote from: PatriotClock;1556125Morally I am supposed to be against it but honestly i do not care either way since it doesnt affect me at all. Its just gross imo

EW GROSS BRO DICKS HAHAHAHA EWWW

Quote from: Abe Frohman;1556123[gay sex & god]

this one of the arguments i've used as well. separation of church and state obviously is the only argument one needs for gay marriage, really.
the man, the legend

heineken

Quote from: RibsClock;1556777I'm shocked how many things people are willing to ban so they don't have to explain them to their children.

Good grief.

Not wanting or being unable to explain anything to your children is bad parenting. Even from a young age my parents made very clear to me that the things you see on the five o' clock news aren't like movies, and they actually happen in some parts of the world.

If you can't explain "you can marry anyone you like", how are you supposed to explain the harsh realities of the world?
You should watch this movie.

This movie is good.

AbsintheClock

Quote from: RibsClock;1556777I'm shocked how many things people are willing to ban so they don't have to explain them to their children.

Good grief.

Now there's a strong point. Hadn't even thought of that.

RomanClock

Quote from: RibsClock;1556777I'm shocked how many things people are willing to ban so they don't have to explain them to their children.

Good grief.

Maybe this is something more understandable to people who have children?
Perhaps if you had children, you may look at things differently.

I also beleive its not an unwillingness to teach them things, its teaching them OTHER things.

And overall, there are usually reasons for everything, and they are not always easy to articulate or explain. There is a reason that pure homosexuality has been taboo in basically every culture for all of human history.

There are many feelings on things that aren't simple to describe, and we try to simplify it into a way that's easy to teach others about these things. I guess you can take this subject as one of those things I just can't accurately articulate what I think of the subject and so it doesn't make sense to someone who thinks in a different way. I just don't think this is a good thing. And assuming its because of religion, then you are just simply ignorant. I find it disturbing that so many people mistake personal opinion for some religious restriction or affiliation, rather than thinking of it as someones individual thought. Though that's probably getting into another subject as well.

And on top of that, and unrelated principle was also violated, where judges decide for the people. That's a whole other thing for me.
lemayo lol :soups: