News:

If you need instructions on how to get through the hotels, check out the enclosed instruction book.

Main Menu

Ireland passes anti-blasphemy law

Farted by Biblo, July 23, 2009, 08:11:11 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

Biblo

http://www.irishtimes.com/newspaper/breaking/2009/0723/breaking4.htm

Utterly ridiculous. It is now possible to be fined for blasphemy.

A law protecting the irrational and punishing all else.

Also, what defines blasphemy? Anything taught in a Christian church is blasphemous against the teachings in a Muslim church which is blasphemous against Jewish teachings which are blasphemous against Christians.
It's a mess.

PirateClock

lmao, over here appertain that law is already in place, from way back when everybody was a fucking retard. It's NEVER enforced though. While ago they tried to remove it but some Cristian party made a big fuss about it and the others basically went: fine keep your bullshit law if that makes you happy.
_pirate_butchcavities (20:29:15): FUCK CLOCKS _pirate_

GearBoxClock

Hooray for misleading laws regarding religion!

AbsintheClock

I'd love to see it enforced. Oh also I'm the devil, Jesus was gay, Muhammad invented the turkish bath, and Buddha is a heroin addict.

MonsterMunch

I doubt they will be arresting people for wearing "Jesus is my homeboy" t-shirts.

Poltergeist

I think you'll all looking too deep into this, it's probably just saying that you can be punished more severely for insulting someones religion now.

GearBoxClock

Quote from: Poltergeisty;1626377I think you'll all looking too deep into this, it's probably just saying that you can be punished more severely for insulting someones religion now.

You shouldn't be punished AT ALL for insulting any religion
Freedom of speech

AbsintheClock

You can't force somebody to even respect another person's religion. That's just more cannon fodder for bigotry. (I wipe my ass with the sanatana dharma!)

Bigglesnoots

Quote from: GearBoxClock;1626378Freedom of speech
"My opinion of the Holocaust is that it never happened" is still illegal you know, free speech or not.
Quote from: Zombie Lincoln;1601675Waiting around to die is the most socially acceptable method of suicide, and it always works.

BlackberryClock

I thought all of Europe was secular and highly intellectual.

PirateClock

Quote from: Update;1626392"My opinion of the Holocaust is that it never happened" is still illegal you know, free speech or not.

They where trying to get that law abolished aswell over here, however some retards didn't understand the reasoning behind it and starting shouting "NO MORE NAZI'S!" all over the place, so again they said: fine, have your bullshit rule if it makes you happy.  Never enforced though.
_pirate_butchcavities (20:29:15): FUCK CLOCKS _pirate_

Bigglesnoots

Quote from: Jefferson Twilight;1626399They where trying to get that law abolished aswell over here, however some retards didn't understand the reasoning behind it and starting shouting "NO MORE NAZI'S!" all over the place, so again they said: fine, have your bullshit rule if it makes you happy.  Never enforced though.
negationism is an exception to free speech that should be kept incorporated in the law, imo

still enforced in Belgium, cf. Siegfried Verbeke.
Quote from: Zombie Lincoln;1601675Waiting around to die is the most socially acceptable method of suicide, and it always works.

BlackberryClock

Quote from: RibsClock;1626396Ireland has had ecumenical conflict steering much of its politics for quite some time now. As far as western Europe is concerned there is still a great deal of religious conflict, and frankly much of the supposedly anti-religious stuff is targeted to specific religions of other people, not all religion.
Yeah, I know. Just a bad joke.

Seriously though, like you said, blasphemy is vague unenforceable in any strict way. Just about anything could be blasphemous if you're willing to twist your theology around.

PirateClock

Quote from: Update;1626414negationism is an exception to free speech that should be kept incorporated in the law, imo

Why? I can deny slavery happened, i can deny all murders under Stalin and other dictators happened, i can deny that the church burned thousands of innocent women, i can deny star wars episode 1 till 3 where ever made. Why can't i deny the holocaust?


Disclaimer: pirateclock does not deny the holocaust.
_pirate_butchcavities (20:29:15): FUCK CLOCKS _pirate_

Bigglesnoots

Quote from: Jefferson Twilight;1626418Why? I can deny slavery happened, i can deny all murders under Stalin and other dictators happened, i can deny that the church burned thousands of innocent women, i can deny star wars episode 1 till 3 where ever made. Why can't i deny the holocaust?


Disclaimer: pirateclock does not deny the holocaust.
I guess you're right, though the Holocaust is probably the event that is most denied.
Quote from: Zombie Lincoln;1601675Waiting around to die is the most socially acceptable method of suicide, and it always works.

Biblo

Everything Ribs said.


Yes this is the biggest problem, the fucking vagueness of it.

And even if it wasn't vague, why should I be punished for saying that the guy who believes there's a giant bean on Mars controlling his elbows is a loon just because he's managed to convince some others into believing it too?

Biblo

Quote from: CadillacClock;1626466Ah, yes, the Troubles.

Another problem: is an Anglican blasphemous for denouncing the Pope or are such discussions entirely taboo?

This also reminds me nazi-deniers in Germany -- mass censorship over actual acceptance of a troubled past and moving on from it.


Well personally what I think they're doing is administering a blanket law so they can immediately annex any anti-Islam writings without raising eyebrows in order to avoid a sequel to the Danish cartoon "controversy"

I mean, you can see the point but it is a bit like making it illegal to stand near someone with a knife rather than making it illegal to stab people

GearBoxClock

Quote from: Update;1626392"My opinion of the Holocaust is that it never happened" is still illegal you know, free speech or not.

Well, good point. But there is actual reasons for that. There may be reasons for this, but I can't see any

Marlin Clock

Quote from: CadillacClock;1626466This also reminds me nazi-deniers in Germany -- mass censorship over actual acceptance of a troubled past and moving on from it.
I fail to see the correlation.

RomanClock

I bet 0% of people actually read what the laws said and just take the article for its word. Also, to me this just seems like an extension of hate-crime type laws, which are I'm a edgy teen.
lemayo lol :soups: