News:

If you need instructions on how to get through the hotels, check out the enclosed instruction book.

Main Menu

Clock Space

Farted by F U Clock, September 07, 2009, 10:42:07 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

F U Clock

Quote from: ̵b̵a̵n̵n̵e̵d̵ ̵t̵h̵o̵r̵;1663024That's how we'll get better, by mindlessly praising everything we see!

I just posted that I 0'd it. I had already said I was going to. Then everybody got all worked up about it and said I was trolling, and then I had to defend my position and then people thought that was more trolling and then the whole thing turned into a great big mess.

I think my problem with a 0 is just that I don't polarize votes like other people love to. So in my opinion if you feel like something is kinda' eh, you give it a 1 - 3. But a 0 is like absolute shit, so you can see my indignation.

PropagandaClock

Quote from: ̵b̵a̵n̵n̵e̵d̵ ̵t̵h̵o̵r̵;1663024That's how we'll get better, by mindlessly praising everything we see!
I am glad the art of reading has eluded you, seeing as I clearly stated that critique is always welcomed.
Quote from: ̵b̵a̵n̵n̵e̵d̵ ̵t̵h̵o̵r̵;1663024I just posted that I 0'd it. I had already said I was going to. Then everybody got all worked up about it and said I was trolling, and then I had to defend my position and then people thought that was more trolling and then the whole thing turned into a great big mess.

edit: So I guess revealing that you have a different opinion and then replying to people talking directly to you is trolling now???
No you pretty much were a cold bitch in the voting topic.




You know this because else you wouldn't have a hoard is tossers like me hjumping on the moral bandwagon to defend all that is just and holy.
[flash]http://files.myfrogbag.com/ses6on/Space.swf Width=450 height=175[/flash]

Thor

Quote from: Eff Yoo Clawk;1663025I think my problem with a 0 is just that I don't polarize votes like other people love to. So in my opinion if you feel like something is kinda' eh, you give it a 1 - 3. But a 0 is like absolute shit, so you can see my indignation.

I only vote 0 or 5, that's how I roll. I guess if I actually used the 0-5 system I'd give you like a 2
Quote from: MafiaMettaurWhat the hell is with that shit you posted? You know what, I'm joining the Locks, just to stop stuff like you!
Quote from: polyhedronclockYou're a fucking clock, what else do you have?
To be fair, you don't have anything. Clocks are just machines that tick.

F U Clock

Also, I don't think you can say people were just praising mine outright. There were several people in the Ribs v. me thread that said they liked Ribs' more, so what's the problem?

Thor

Quote from: PropagandaClock;1663026I am glad the art of reading has eluded you, seeing as I clearly stated that critique is always welcomed.
"If you do not have anything good to say, don't say anything at all." How can you critique something if you aren't allowed to say anything bad about it?
QuoteNo you pretty much were a cold bitch in the voting topic.
Well maybe my tone was rather mean but I pointed out what I didn't like and didn't just say it was shit and be done with it.


QuoteYou know this because else you wouldn't have a hoard is tossers like me humping on the moral bandwagon to defend all that is just and holy.
Once again, the people who DON'T like the movie and say nothing are the tossers, not the people who DO like the movie. I have no problem with people who DO like this movie. I have no problem with people LIKING the movie. But I DON'T like the movie. And I said why I don't. What's the big deal here?
Quote from: MafiaMettaurWhat the hell is with that shit you posted? You know what, I'm joining the Locks, just to stop stuff like you!
Quote from: polyhedronclockYou're a fucking clock, what else do you have?
To be fair, you don't have anything. Clocks are just machines that tick.

PropagandaClock

#45
Quote from: ̵b̵a̵n̵n̵e̵d̵ ̵t̵h̵o̵r̵;1663030"If you do not have anything good to say, don't say anything at all."
Critique isn't bad, it is helpfull, suggesting, often kind but sometimes harsch. What you did was not critique.




Quote from: ̵b̵a̵n̵n̵e̵d̵ ̵t̵h̵o̵r̵;1663030Once again, the people who DON'T like the movie and say nothing are the tossers, not the people who DO like the movie. I have no problem with people who DO like this movie. I have no problem with people LIKING the movie. But I DON'T like the movie. And I said why I don't. What's the big deal here?
People reacted to your posts Thor not because it regards this movie but how you presented them.
Next time don't be so blunt in your formulations, that is all :D
[flash]http://files.myfrogbag.com/ses6on/Space.swf Width=450 height=175[/flash]

NintendrCkolc

Quote from: ̵b̵a̵n̵n̵e̵d̵ ̵t̵h̵o̵r̵;1663030And I said why I don't. What's the big deal here?

You voted 0 on something that obviously didn't merit a 0 whether you liked it or not. You couldve been like, "I hate this but I'll 5 it for effort".

You know, something less dickish.

Thor

Quote from: PropagandaClock;1663032Next time don't be so blunt in your formulations, that is all :D

I suppose I'm usually too blunt because I get upset with the general lack of bluntness on the internet. It's few and far between that I see a comment on any art anywhere that isn't "I love this it is perfect".

Anyway, can this conversation be over now please? Is it possible for a mod to send just part of a thread to the grinder?
Quote from: MafiaMettaurWhat the hell is with that shit you posted? You know what, I'm joining the Locks, just to stop stuff like you!
Quote from: polyhedronclockYou're a fucking clock, what else do you have?
To be fair, you don't have anything. Clocks are just machines that tick.

F U Clock

I try to avoid telling people to 5 my stuff 'cause I don't think it's fair. People should vote what they feel. I just didn't really get the 0, that's all.

Slurpee

Quote from: ̵b̵a̵n̵n̵e̵d̵ ̵t̵h̵o̵r̵;1663012I don't know how I could be any more constructive than pointing out specifically what I didn't like about it. I even pointed out what I didn't like about it before I posted in this thread!
what you're doing is no different from the kids that vote zero on N just because tricky shows up at the end. you're sitting on the other side of the fence, when you should be above fence and friend and foe.

you really don't see what's wrong with offering "Story like it was written by a preteen, trying too hard to be badass and failing because of it." as a criticism to your fellow crew member? are you entirely sure you should be offering criticism on anything?

if you disagree with emphasizing a serious tone, say so; if you feel that the story focuses on building up the protagonist as a badass, say so.
"story by a preteen trying too hard to be badass" implies you place this at the same level as "guy jumps into a room and kills hella guys." it says to me you took in the tone, and sat through only because you were hoping for a pie in the face at the end, and when it didn't come, instead of judging the flash based on its merits, you decided you hated it.

criticism is weighing something against what it intended to achieve, how successful it was toward those ends, and attempting to express verbally why you felt it fell where it did. it's not decrying something for not being what you want it to be, gathering up everything you hated, and then stating them.

but more important than the finer points of criticism is if you're in a group of artists you probably shouldn't be a dick about their art. and I draw a fine line between giving negative criticism and being a dick.
here's me offering negative criticism and also here and here's a really preachy one
and, hey, speaking of these, what was that thing you said about nobody ever speaking their minds if they disagreed?
the key is not to be an asshole about it.

Thor

Quote from: Slurpee;1663037if you disagree with emphasizing a serious tone, say so; if you feel that the story focuses on building up the protagonist as a badass, say so.
That is what I said. You're just using different words to express the same thing.

Quote"story by a preteen trying too hard to be badass" implies you place this at the same level as "guy jumps into a room and kills hella guys." it says to me you took in the tone, and sat through only because you were hoping for a pie in the face at the end, and when it didn't come, instead of judging the flash based on its merits, you decided you hated it.
It was pretty. That was it's only merit. The merits it didn't have more than made up for that and resulted in the net total of a bad movie. This movie is in no way better than a movie where "guy jumps into a room and kills hella guys." if it was drawn well. The movie would have been better if it ended with tricky, but that's beside the point as it doesn't actually make the movie WORSE.

Quotecriticism is weighing something against what it intended to achieve, how successful it was toward those ends, and attempting to express verbally why you felt it fell where it did. it's not decrying something for not being what you want it to be, gathering up everything you hated, and then stating them.
This movie was meant to entertain the viewer. It didn't. I said why it failed to achieve it's goal. Not nicely, fine, but I did.

Quotebut more important than the finer points of criticism is if you're in a group of artists you probably shouldn't be a dick about their art. and I draw a fine line between giving negative criticism and being a dick.
here's me offering negative criticism and also here and here's a really preachy one
and, hey, speaking of these, what was that thing you said about nobody ever speaking their minds if they disagreed?
the key is not to be an asshole about it.
Alright, I wasn't nice in my comments. I admit that. I was even rude. Dickish, one might say. Is that the only problem here, that I didn't wrap my comments in a bow and politely list off the problems? I really didn't consider that because I don't really care because it doesn't matter. If I'm nice or not he's still going to hear what I have to say. And he surely isn't going to get upset about this one review.
Quote from: MafiaMettaurWhat the hell is with that shit you posted? You know what, I'm joining the Locks, just to stop stuff like you!
Quote from: polyhedronclockYou're a fucking clock, what else do you have?
To be fair, you don't have anything. Clocks are just machines that tick.

BlackberryClock

Thor, I don't think anyone will deny you the right to tell us that you didn't like the art, but the way you went about it is quite rude. Posting only "0d" is obviously trolling. I don't have much else to add to what Slurpee has said (bravo), so I'll leave it at that.

Just show some respect.

Thor

I have heard what you have to say and I'm going to work to be more constructive in the future. I felt the need to defend my position out of instinct, although I know deep down I was wrong. Just because I dislike the movie doesn't mean I have to be so confrontational

somebody ban me please so this situation has closure
Quote from: MafiaMettaurWhat the hell is with that shit you posted? You know what, I'm joining the Locks, just to stop stuff like you!
Quote from: polyhedronclockYou're a fucking clock, what else do you have?
To be fair, you don't have anything. Clocks are just machines that tick.

Slurpee

Quote from: ̵b̵a̵n̵n̵e̵d̵ ̵t̵h̵o̵r̵;1663041Is that the only problem here, that I didn't wrap my comments in a bow and politely list off the problems?
yes.
Quote from: ̵b̵a̵n̵n̵e̵d̵ ̵t̵h̵o̵r̵;1663041I really didn't consider that because I don't really care because it doesn't matter. If I'm nice or not he's still going to hear what I have to say. And he surely isn't going to get upset about this one review.
even if you don't care about the presentation yourself, it concerns you, because it affects your demeanor, and it's a matter of common decency. I can't speak for everybody, but unless criticism comes in good order, I usually don't much give it the time of day. negative criticism doesn't have the luxury of getting a pass for massaging anybody's ego. if you want it to have any manner of effect, you have to get into people's heads, and there's no quicker way to lock yourself out than an aggressive disposition.
Quote from: ̵b̵a̵n̵n̵e̵d̵ ̵t̵h̵o̵r̵;1663043somebody ban me please so this situation has closure
if you feel the matter's resolved, I can separate out the derail, and gas it, if you like. you were well-intentioned, though. I'm not going to ban you for overzealousness.

BlackberryClock

Quote from: ̵b̵a̵n̵n̵e̵d̵ ̵t̵h̵o̵r̵;1663043I have heard what you have to say and I'm going to work to be more constructive in the future. I felt the need to defend my position out of instinct, although I know deep down I was wrong. Just because I dislike the movie doesn't mean I have to be so confrontational

somebody ban me please so this situation has closure
There no reason to ban anyone, I wanted you to explain yourself instead of posting "0d" and calling people preteens, and I think a legitimate and useful conversation was the result.

Quote from: Golden Clock;1663044I think the real key is not his not liking the art, it's rather he doesn't like the spirit of the cartoon, which I can understand. It doesn't feel Clock-like to me. He basically said 'it's a movie that just happens to have clocks in it' instead of a full on 'clock movie'. I'm agreeing with him on this, but I mean no disrespect to F.U. Maybe Thor doesn't mean as much disrespect as it seems (this thread is tl;dr after a while).
Yeah, I understand that. I just used "art" to mean the animation not necessarily the visuals.

The point of contention is something I think should be talked about. I definitely see the "it doesn't feel clock-like" point. I would liken it to my personal aversion to the stereotypical "BBBBBB" "can I drive" type movies that make me want to throw my hands up with frustration.

I admit that FU's movie didn't have a Spielberg script, but I did catch myself rewatching it for the visuals and even pausing it moving it frame by frame to admire the work.

ProqagandaClock

I DONT KNOW WHAT WE'RE YELLING ABOUT

LOUD NOICES

F U Clock


ProqagandaClock

No godamnit this wont do, this much drama and noone was banned... I wont allow it. This isn't a godamn british countryclub , someone needs to be banned.


Ban me.

bgryderclock

"God bless you FU Clock"
                             by: bgryderclock
                          date: A few seconds ago
                               You taught me to love again.
  Your brilliance is wasted on the mouth-breathing Newground masses. You are bigger than a third place trophy sir, Much bigger.
BAND :: BLOG :: CODE :: MOVIES :: BACKGROUNDS :: FLA

ProqagandaClock

Quote from: HarmonyClock;1663058No godamnit this wont do, this much drama and noone was banned... I wont allow it. This isn't a godamn british countryclub , someone needs to be banned.


Ban me.
No seriously ban me, All this drama has built up one throbbin cock and if I don't see a ban I'm going to have the biggest blueballs in the northen hemisphere.

BAN MEEEEEEEE


(User was banned for this post; Reason: requested, I guess)