News:

If you need instructions on how to get through the hotels, check out the enclosed instruction book.

Main Menu

butthurt iowan lawmakers actively seeking to endanger gay and transgender students

Farted by Slurpee, February 10, 2010, 12:14:29 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

Slurpee

anybody want to defend this supervillain bullshit?

QuoteA pair of Republican state legislators has introduced a bill that would remove protections for gay, lesbian and transgender students from an anti-bullying law passed in 2007.

State Reps. Jason Schultz, R-Schleswig, and Matt Windschitl, R-Missouri Valley, sponsored the legislation to remove sexual orientation and gender identity as definitions used for purposes of protecting students in public and nonpublic schools from harassment and bullying.

Schultz told NBC affiliate WHO-TV that the rationale behind the move is to force a vote on a constitutional amendment banning same-sex marriage, since the Iowa Supreme Court pointed to laws like Iowa’s Safe Schools Law in making its April decision to legalize same-sex marriage. Ryan Roemerman, executive director of Iowa Pride Network, said the bill would open up LGBT students to bullying and harassment.

“When our state is facing record budget deficits and unemployment, House Republicans feel their time is best spent picking on Iowa’s LGBT youth,” Roemerman said in a statement. “There is no better example as to why we have this law, so youth in Iowa don’t grow up to be like these bigots.”
further reading:
http://www.whotv.com/news/who-tv-safe-schools-020710,0,164239.story
http://www.slapupsidethehead.com/2010/02/iowa-legislators-hope-to-scrap-anti-bullying-measure/

you'll have to forgive the quality of the sites I'm linking to- as with most stories where The Gays are innocent victims and can't be spun as child-molesting, tradition-destroying wackos responsible for their own persecution, this is not being covered by major news outlets- even liberal cesspools like huffington post and msnbc.

Topcatyo


Kaijuclock

You know, I think if this happens it'll be my sign that it's time to move to Canada. I could go on and on about how this is complete and utter dog shit, but I'm sure everyone here is completely in agreement on that, and it wont do much more than make me rant for half a page.

AbsintheClock

Because being married, and feeling safe in school are totally the same thing.

RomanClock

lemayo lol :soups:

RomanClock

Oh look its Cadillac Clock. Of course it's stupid to exclude a group that is bullied from an anti-bullying law. I don't understand why you always try and dishearten me? Do I have to spell out ever little detail of how I think to you? No.
lemayo lol :soups:

Kaijuclock

Quote from: RomanClock;1728715Oh look its Cadillac Clock. Of course it's stupid to exclude a group that is bullied from an anti-bullying law. I don't understand why you always try and dishearten me? Do I have to spell out ever little detail of how I think to you? No.
Yes, See this here is a debate forum. This means your opinion needs to be stated or will be left to the imagination of the person who is reading said post. That even looked as if you were advocating this to me, and I am not one to go around assuming. If you felt it was dumb then maybe more than just a sentence should suffice? A sentence that doesn't sound like you are just like "LOL WHATEVER DUDES LET EM DO IT." Kthnx.

Marlin Clock

I'm afraid I don't see the point of this being in a debate thread. I guess it's true anyone can debate any topic, but for this topic I see no reason. I know what it's like to be bullied constantly and no kid deserves that.

RobClock

so as i understand it with this bill passed it would be something like: beating someone for being ugly is punishable but beating someone up for being gay is completely okay.

is that basically the jist?

FLOUNDERMAN_CLOCK

Quote from: Marlix Wright;1728924I'm afraid I don't see the point of this being in a debate thread. I guess it's true anyone can debate any topic, but for this topic I see no reason. I know what it's like to be bullied constantly and no kid deserves that.

Well we don't have to debate with each other, this forum is for general discussion of important matters. A lot of times that includes debate but it doesn't necessarily have to.

Sinister Clock

Quote from: RobClock;1729052so as i understand it with this bill passed it would be something like: beating someone for being ugly is punishable but beating someone up for being gay is completely okay.

is that basically the jist?

Yeah I am also pretty confused by this.

BinaryClock

Quote from: RobClock;1729052so as i understand it with this bill passed it would be something like: beating someone for being ugly is punishable but beating someone up for being gay is completely okay.

is that basically the jist?

I would imagine that the law works like other hate crime laws where stricter penalties are enforced if it can be proved that the victim was beaten because they were gay.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hate_crime_laws_in_the_United_States

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Map_of_LGBT-related_hate_crime_law_in_the_United_States.svg

Goddammit, 18 states don't have hate crime laws? Are you fucking kidding me?
BinaryClock, if you wanna play uno type !unohelp to see how to

Kaijuclock

Quote from: BinaryClock;1729109I would imagine that the law works like other hate crime laws where stricter penalties are enforced if it can be proved that the victim was beaten because they were gay.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hate_crime_laws_in_the_United_States

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Map_of_LGBT-related_hate_crime_law_in_the_United_States.svg

Goddammit, 18 states don't have hate crime laws? Are you fucking kidding me?
And i happen to live in one of those states.

BinaryClock

BinaryClock, if you wanna play uno type !unohelp to see how to

BlackberryClock

Oh the irony of anti-bullying laws being altered to openly bully a minority! Wow.

But since this is the debate forum:

I have always been opposed to any kind of hate crime legislation. I don't think it's just to afford special privileges (read: unequal rights) to any group. More importantly though, prosecuting people's thoughts is a dangerous thing.

Punish people for committing unlawful acts against others; don't punish them for what they were thinking while they were doing it.

The two Republicans in this story are assholes either way.

BinaryClock

Quote from: BlackberryClock;1729115Oh the irony of anti-bullying laws being altered to openly bully a minority! Wow.

But since this is the debate forum:

I have always been opposed to any kind of hate crime legislation. I don't think it's just to afford special privileges (read: unequal rights) to any group. More importantly though, prosecuting people's thoughts is a dangerous thing.

Punish people for committing unlawful acts against others; don't punish them for what they were thinking while they were doing it.

The two Republicans in this story are assholes either way.

I don't think it affords special privileges to any specific group, if I was beat up specifically because I was white, straight, and Christian, it would be a hate crime just as if I was beat up specifically because I was black, gay and Muslim.

Although I agree it can be sketchy area to prosecute what people for what they were thinking, most hate crime charges I would assume have to be pretty obvious (trashing someone's house and tagging swastikas, or yelling slurs while kicking someone on the ground, lynching etc.) and in 1969, distinctions definitely had to be made to prevent this.

Edit: Also it's not like different punishments based on the intent of the crime is a new concept (see Manslaughter vs. Murder)
BinaryClock, if you wanna play uno type !unohelp to see how to

BlackberryClock

Quote from: BinaryClock;1729122Although I agree it can be sketchy area to prosecute what people for what they were thinking, most hate crime charges I would assume have to be pretty obvious (trashing someone's house and tagging swastikas, or yelling slurs while kicking someone on the ground, lynching etc.) and in 1969, distinctions definitely had to be made to prevent this.

Edit: Also it's not like different punishments based on the intent of the crime is a new concept (see Manslaughter vs. Murder)
Hating/disliking/thinking someone is a doodoo-head should never be a crime.

Spray-painting people houses and kicking people is always a crime.

Therefore

hate crimes are unnecessary.

BinaryClock

Quote from: BlackberryClock;1729127Hating/disliking/thinking someone is a doodoo-head should never be a crime.

True, but when someone acts on those thoughts in an especially cruel or vicious manner, that should be taken into account. And it's not just thinking a specific person is a shithead, it's thinking that an entire group or class of people are shitheads, without regard to any specific person.

When our country was founded on the idea that all men are created equal (yeah overused cliché but still), people should have the right to feel safe without fearing someone would discriminate against them based on something they cannot change.
BinaryClock, if you wanna play uno type !unohelp to see how to

BlackberryClock

The arguments that thoughts are already considered is a good one, I admit. The example you used isn't very good though; perhaps intentionality in first and second degree murder is a better one?

So I'll grant you that, but I still think that adding this new power to the police power of government is a mistake. I don't want it deciding if I my violent crime was committing with hate in my mind or not. Obvious cases (like you used) are clear-cut, but the ambiguous ones could be real problems. But more importantly, I just don't think it's the place for government to make those kind of decisions about our thoughts.

I like the idea of trying to influence people to stop being prejudiced, but I don't want the one doing it to be the government.

Quote from: BinaryClock;1729128True, but when someone acts on those thoughts in an especially cruel or vicious manner, that should be taken into account. And it's not just thinking a specific person is a shithead, it's thinking that an entire group or class of people are shitheads, without regard to any specific person.

When our country was founded on the idea that all men are created equal (yeah overused cliché but still), people should have the right to feel safe without fearing someone would discriminate against them based on something they cannot change.
There is no right to not be afraid.

Discrimination in many cases is a crime, and violence always is, so we do have a reasonable expectation of safety nonetheless.

Vicious crimes are already prosecuted well enough (mostly I guess) without hate crime laws. All hate crimes are actually just regular crime with a be of thought sprinkled in. The viciousness you cite doesn't even necessitate a hate thought, just a generalized vicious one.

AbsintheClock

I think if somebody wants to call a gay person a sodomite, faggot, or whatever that's fine. They're probably a dick and they'll get what's coming to them. But when it goes into harassment, physical violence or threats then a line is crossed. I think there's a big difference between just being a jerk, and outright being a bully.

I kind of wonder what happened to the days when you could pop a guy in the mouth for being a prick?