News:

If you need instructions on how to get through the hotels, check out the enclosed instruction book.

Main Menu

Bush administration sneaking in one last rule

Farted by FLOUNDERMAN_CLOCK, December 06, 2008, 12:07:29 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

RomanClock

Quote from: William. Shatner.;1463438I don't know. At least it was fun while he was posting. The thing is, this has become a debate about religion's impact on morality. If I understand correctly, Roman's been saying that religion has absolutely no effect on what a doctor considers to be right or wrong and therefore should be completely overlooked in deciding whether this bill should be passed or not. He's stalling the debate. Marlin was just saying that doctors abusing their freedoms would have no effect on the price of certain procedures, which to me seems to defy the most basic fundamentals of economics.

No, you just made that up. I'm saying the it doesn't MATTER what religion they adhere to. An atheist could still believe abortion and an euthanasia is bad, so he wont do them.
What I'm saying is that doctors should be able to chose what they will or will not do. This rule is simply a protection of their right to chose how to practice.

Quote from: CadillacClock;1463517Your beliefs are going to end lives. However I wholeheartedly agree that they should set up their own clinic if such moralistic objections are there. At the moment, that's not what this debate is about. You are saying "I think it would be best (plausible solution)" to a law which does not offer such a thing. The Bush Administration was not as thoughtful as you, Zombie Lincoln.

If a doctor let patients die he wouldn't be a doctor very long. Plus, the morally objectionable procedures, like abortion, euthanasia, and risky surgeries, are more dangerous than not doing them.

I have basically the same opinion as Slurpee, Marlin, Lincoln, and Absinthe.
lemayo lol :soups:

RomanClock

Quote from: CadillacClock;1463517Your beliefs are going to end lives. However I wholeheartedly agree that they should set up their own clinic if such moralistic objections are there. At the moment, that's not what this debate is about. You are saying "I think it would be best (plausible solution)" to a law which does not offer such a thing. The Bush Administration was not as thoughtful as you, Zombie Lincoln.

If a doctor let patients die he wouldn't be a doctor very long. Plus, the morally objectionable procedures, like abortion, euthanasia, and risky surgeries, are more dangerous than not doing them.
lemayo lol :soups:

RomanClock

Quote from: CadillacClock;1463626What pray tell is a risky and morally questionable operations that a doctor would find hard to do? I would like to think surgeons are more than prepared for a risky operations.

A risky operation means that the surgeon thinks there's a high possibility of death or adverse side effects. To name some: heart surgery, brain surgery, tendons, spine. Things can go wrong, a surgeon isn't perfect.
lemayo lol :soups:

RomanClock

Quote from: CadillacClock;1463643How does that fit into a "morally questionable" operations? I would also defend that "something going wrong" is much less horrible than "death". Assuming risky operations are done in the prevention of it.

It just means that you can't force the doctor to do something he doesn't want to.
lemayo lol :soups:

Loki Clock

Quotelike abortion

Considering American doctors' method of handling pregnancies, I'd say abortion is quite a lot less risky than going to full term.

AbsintheClock

All the same I think in that respect there should be doctors who respect our right to die if we choose to. It is cruel and unusual to make people resort to blowing their own heads off with guns, or hanging themselves. We should all be allowed to choose our options as human beings and respect that right. That means doctors who do believe in euthanasia should be allowed to practice nationally. It goes against the idea of life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. Death is just the end of life, you should be free to choose it, especially if it ends misery.

On the other hand if a doctor doesn't have the stomach for it he shouldn't be practicing it in the first place which is why I also agree with the law. I want to be able to know straight up if my doctor has a spine or not. On another note people should be able to have resources to find their own means of treatment. Such as allowing cancer patients to use medical marijuana. In other words the government needs to back the fuck up all together.

RomanClock

Quote from: CadillacClock;1463675I would like to think that doctors would do everything in their power to save my life. Dead, in my opinion, is much worse than some of the side effects. This is why we have open-heart surgeons, brain surgeons and I have no idea who would perform the last two but let's just assume surgeons do it. Because at the end of the day, I wouldn't be dead.

You didn't really get your point out very well, did you?

You don't understand what I'm saying.
If a doctor doesn't want to do it you can't force him. Period. End of debate.
They wouldn't be doctors if they weren't trying to save lives, and the only controversial life saving treatments I can think of are certain risky surgeries (like some abortions, such as when its between the baby or the mother) or certain medicines that have side effects that could lead to death.
lemayo lol :soups:

WildCherryPepsiClock

Bush finally does something right.I don't get why it has to be a law and I think it as always been a right for people to control their own lifes and not be slaves to everyone else.Free will should always be alowed to people but limeted to those that abuse it.Sometimes people have to do things they don't want to do.Just doing something regardless of your thoughts about it can satisfy anyone unless it violates your rights of freedom.If someone uses manipulation or tries to control thoughts of a person when informing or giving an opinion then they need to stop doing it.It is stupid enforce how people should be doing something.Nobody is perfect.Some adults these days plan kids lifes out and try to be ready for it instead of understanding that change happends and not everything happends the same.People have the power to choose for themselves but not for everyone else.This is a common mistake todays society has.They can give advice to someone but can't control what is actually done for that person.

PirateClock

does it work the other way aswell? say that euthanasia is illegal, but the doctor thinks it's morally wrong to keep the patient alive, does he have the right to pull the plug based on his morals?
_pirate_butchcavities (20:29:15): FUCK CLOCKS _pirate_

PirateClock

Quote from: CadillacClock;1464277No.

i know it doesn't it was rhetorical!
_pirate_butchcavities (20:29:15): FUCK CLOCKS _pirate_

FluxCapacitorClock

Being that it can rarely be life-threatening to not preform those procedures I don't see a problem with this.

The only case where it'd be wrong for the doctor to say no would be a threat to the mother's life if an abortion isn't preformed.