News:

If you need instructions on how to get through the hotels, check out the enclosed instruction book.

Main Menu

Abortion: Right or wrong?

Farted by TequilaClock, December 06, 2011, 08:17:44 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

FLOUNDERMAN_CLOCK

We all know fetuses are not made out of green cheese, but what if they were made of barbecue spare ribs would you abort them then?

FLOUNDERMAN_CLOCK

Dwarfinator and Miraclefruit raised a good point in their posts. Lets say your baby is going to be born horrifically deformed, braindead, or will die within 1-3 years of its existence. It will be in horrible agony its whole life. Is it moral to let the fetus develop to the point where it can truly suffer?

AlbinoClock

Quote from: RibsClock;1879382Let's nip that right in the bud.

Slippery slope argument is not even universally agreed to be fallacious, and is often used to illustrate the logical flaws in an argument (as it is here, successfully I might add) that you most certainly could make those arguments, and a bare assertion coupled with some insults isn't a refutation of his point. I'd ask that you don't toss around fallacy terminology unless you're going to critically examine your own assertions with the same fine-toothed comb, and furthermore not assume that everyone knows the terminology from their college logic class and debate club.

And is it really so "nonsensical" as you put it that human beings would deprive rights based on stages of human development, considering we already do that and always have? I don't recall my consent being needed for me to be immunized or circumcised or confined against my will or any other number of things children and infants are subjected to under a not terribly distant way of thinking, one that would be classically supported with such derision and appeals to ridicule as this subject is presently, and propped up in part by the fact that children and infants are inherently uneducated and without means to influence the matter effectively.


I'm not reading that because you're being pedantic. Do you seriously think that there's a confusion as to when a child goes from being unborn to born? I mean, not only is there an actual physical connection via a shared organ between mother and child that is severed, but it literally comes out of her. Poptart's argument that somehow this will lead to children not being seen as human is an example of a slippery slope fallacy, not a legitimate slippery slope argument.

AlbinoClock

Quote from: RibsClock;1879541Well then you can choose not to respond to it, but why should I be expected to read your crap and have you not read mine? Again, this is the debate forum: "tl;dr" or "your gay" or "ur so stupid" isn't acceptable here, debate the argument or don't, those are your options.

If you seriously are comparing me telling you that you're being pedantic is the same as saying you're gay or stupid, then I may have to change my user title.

QuoteIt's always readily apparent whether or not a baby is inside or outside of a vagina that's not the point and never was and that's really damn obvious, the discussion is in terms of human development, a thing which has varying degrees inside and outside of the womb and the fact that we've drawn an arbitrary line at that particular even is merely ancillary to that point.

No, his point was that what if we decide to draw the line after it's obviously false. We wouldn't, it's crazy.


QuoteNo this is an example of you not getting something about the argument, something which I illustrated quite well and you should probably have read rather than writing it off as pedantic.

No, it's an example of you confusing me "not getting" part of an argument with thinking it's bollocks.

And if you abuse your mod powers to try to strengthen your argument again I'm going to start making polls.

Marlin Clock

A child still requires on sustenance from the mother after birth, from an organ at that, under natural circumstances. Nothing changes in the dependency relationship. What makes the distinction then?

AMPEEEM

Quote from: Marlin Clock;1879563A child still requires on sustenance from the mother after birth, from an organ at that, under natural circumstances. Nothing changes in the dependency relationship. What makes the distinction then?

I'm actually really curious as to what your response to Dwarfinator's question will be.

Sinister Clock

Quote from: RibsClock;1879548Change it to "corpsegrinder is pedantic" :rolleyes:

Don't sling mud in the debate forum or you'll get banned, simple as that.

You really are abusing your internet power right now to try and win an argument on the internet. Maybe you should just not post in the debate forum if you're gonna start banning everyone who disagrees with you.

Marlin Clock

Quote from: AMPEEEM;1879569I'm actually really curious as to what your response to Dwarfinator's question will be.
I find those kinds of questions to be more attempts at putting different value on life depending on the circumstances. It seems like quite a legitimately slippery slope once we go to determining who can and can't live based on what they are born with.

Topcatyo

Quote from: Marlin Clock;1879587I find those kinds of questions to be more attempts at putting different value on life depending on the circumstances. It seems like quite a legitimately slippery slope once we go to determining who can and can't live based on what they are born with.
It's not about setting a cutoff, it's about giving families who find themselves incapable of taking care of a child a choice to try and prevent a human being from being born into a bad situation.

Even a more well-off family might not be able to take care of a kid if they are always working or moving.  It's not as bad a situation but still has a dramatic effect on the live of everyone.

AMPEEEM

Quote from: Marlin Clock;1879587I find those kinds of questions to be more attempts at putting different value on life depending on the circumstances. It seems like quite a legitimately slippery slope once we go to determining who can and can't live based on what they are born with.

Kinda like the discussion on whether or not an unborn baby counts as a legit and respected human life. It's all slippery.

FLOUNDERMAN_CLOCK

Quote from: Sinister Clock;1879574You really are abusing your internet power right now to try and win an argument on the internet. Maybe you should just not post in the debate forum if you're gonna start banning everyone who disagrees with you.

Yes he should just leave the thread unmoderated and let it turn into a shitstorm of personal attacks and horrifically deformed baby spam.

Silly Putty Clock

8=======D~~~~>_<~~~~C=======8

AlbinoClock

Quote from: Sinister Clock;1879574You really are abusing your internet power right now to try and win an argument on the internet. Maybe you should just not post in the debate forum if you're gonna start banning everyone who disagrees with you.

Vote.

DWARFINATORclock

Quote from: clammo;1880250would you abort ronald donald?

: o

miracle fruit

Quote from: clammo;1880250would you abort ronald donald?

yes i would

BluezombieClock

I'm totally for abortions if they're necessary.

I'm not a religious guy to start off, which helps, but I still get that it'd be a hard choice to make. It's kinda like: 'Fuck. Do I kill my future son or just make a new one when I feel ready?'.

Obviously, if you're 19 years old and your girlfriend gets pregnant, I hope to god she won't want to keep it because then you're financially fucked for a long while (assuming you're not getting much help outside of the small government help). It's not really about wanting a baby or not IMO, it's about whether you could afford to raise one and whether you could give him/her all the parental attention a young child needs.
╔═════════════════ ೋáÆ'¦â˜Æ'áÆ'¦à³‹ ════════════════â•â€"
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ Repost this if ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~ ~ you are a beautiful strong black woman ~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ who donââ,¬â,,¢t need no man ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
╚═════════════════ ೋáÆ'¦â˜Æ'áÆ'¦à³‹ ════════════════╝

☣ Motionmaker[/URL]


TimHortonsClock

Wrong.

I doubt anyone would want to conceive a child as a result of rape, though I am certain that allowing the child to be adopted would be a better solution. In the end, you're still dealing with human life.

LandlineClock

To be very blunt my stances are

Woman Was Raped: Abortion

Two teenagers or anybody of any age that had unprotected sex: Put up for adoption, care for periodicaly. It's pathetic and shameful that people who aren't responsible enough to raise a child abort the fetus.

Life-altering birth defect: Or one that will make the child's life very unpleasant, possible abortion. Depending on the severity of the defect.

In a nutshell, I think abortion is rarely needed and I'm really uncomfortable with how many people support it after having unprotected sex.
this place is deader than ever


Sinister Clock

So you're saying that those pesky teenagers having sex should be punished for having sex by forcing them to give birth to a child after 9 months and then give it up?

DickTree

If a woman was raped and is now pregnant, why would she have to be forced to give birth to the child?